Sherlocko the 'A MAN- U r7, If 'M"ST f'lb I I TH6RE POOH FEllOW ( I lltllK H) 'TTJJffigSSSV&gSF WSSF ' Ml Judgments THE weok saw tha consummation of one of tlio biggest deals ever mado in baso ball tlio Chance Tinker combination transfer, sale and release, whoso ramifications -j ran around both major leagues, touching sovoral cluba and players. Tinker at fast Is stttled. It seems. In tha position of manager for Cincinnati, and if man con get any comfort out of such a berth Joo Is entitled to congratulations. Chance seems quito sure to bo the Highlanders' now manager at tho princely salary of $18,000, with 5 per cent of tho not earnings, which ought to run his pay up nearly as high ns it was with tho Cubs. Chance lost no tlmo In repudiating tho silly story that ho bald ho would decline anything1 less than fcW.OOO becau&o McGraw got $18,000 and his rocord was bettor than Muggsy's. There were several reasons that mado tlio story foolish, the first of which was Chaneo Is not crazy; in tho next place the plan suggested would ex ceed $20,000, surely. McOraw, his personal frlond, was glad to waive and remove tho last such obstacle to Chance's getting Into Gotham. But some young men will never learn that a fact is always better than fiction for newspaper purposes. If Chaneo goes to Now York wo look for several notablo player exchanges, for the Poerless leader will bo manager for the will havo a team at any cost. His going to tho irltropolls Is a great, tiling for baso ball. It places ono of Its biggest men In tho biggest clti' and all fandom should bo glad. The next question ls," What about Hal Choso? Hugh Fullertbn remarked tho other day that Farrell needed Chance, for, aa things stood; ho had Hal Oliose and a franchise, evon no park that Is suitable. Ho Intends to use tho Polo grounds hereafter. But Chance Is t,ald to bo eager to get back into actlvo playing himself. If so, wH ho go to first base? If so, Whore will Chaso go? Well, It must bo remembered that Chase, a marvel nt firstr ls-alsoa-great second baseman. In any event, It hardly seems likely that Chaneo would caro to trade Chase, though ho might get several good players for 'Mm. until Chance know that his own condition was normal agolniAnd, Highland would bo loath to glvo up Chose, Its Idol. Thero lstalk of getting Siun Crawford. Good, but'ieyen at that; Chaso Is not to bo thought of as leaving surely. In any event, It begins to look like a great year for the New York Americans. Frank Chance will bring to the team tho successful experience of fifteen years in. tho National league, plus a ' grim de termination, Incited by his late treatment by a llttlo fellow at Chicago, to make good on a larger scalo than. ever. His passing is a ' great acquisition to the American league,, as great as it is a., loss to tho National, and every man with senso appreciates that. Even Charley Murphy may before Iho next season ends, (.'omlskcy certainly dogs now. That foxy Old Itoman! Gee, thero won't be a man out Ut that South 0lde park when tha Highlanders are led into it by the Peer less deader, late of the West Sldo! Eh. whutchasay? Poor Commy, ho'H"havc. to put on a few extra money counters. Mur phy will still have Tinker with Ills' Cin cinnati TlcdB to draw a few for him, but oh, welll Johnny Evcrs and Murph may got along throughout tho whole season. But. on tha loVcli just look what Murphy did io Chance kicked him out of Chicago, wherri ho was drawing $10,000 and what his investment drew. Into New York with $18,00) and trimmingsl Garry Herrmann' Is a man of honor and patience. After he had bought Chance for a song he continued to dicker for Tinker, and tho baso ball world won dered If he had'gbno crazy. Chance was a demonstrated fact. Tinker purely an uxperlment as a mannger. Why did not Herrmann cinch' as Ills manager thin man who had won four pennants, two world's series, two seconds and one third In seven years, and regarded by all as one of. If not the, greatest manager In the busi ness? Well, Herrmann finally told why. Ho promised Joo TinkPr nt the tlmo he engaged Hank O'Day as manager that if Hank fulled, Joe would get the next- whack at the job If ho could be secured from tho Cubs. Herrmann, be'lngtunlike another man with- whom he had to deal In order to get Tinker, was a man of his word and ho kept It to Tinker without any legal obligations to bind him, know ing ho was the loser to pass, up Chance. Kvoryboily hopes Herrmann and Tinker both will be the gainers in the end. Western league olub owners want a l.riwldtint with plenary powers, so as to traneuct tho huslnnus of president; not a ehief clerk at their beck and call. That Is why they will declaro their good cense and keep O'Neill on the Job In Chicago. The noxt question Is Johnny's Kllng's disposition. Kllng is still a great catcher and will bo a great factor In the success of Iho team landing him. How would Chance like him for his Highlanders? Itogor Bresnahan is almost sure to beat that crowd of double dealers nt St. Iouls and then get a Job backstopplng for an other kind of management, Itoger Is not strong for the suffntRottes, Miner Brown finds Rockefeller money very .satisfactory, especially In the winter time. He has set a precedent as a tutor, his pupil in pitching being a grandson of John D. Monk-Watso "Rescues" the Great Detective JIM THORPE IS STAR OF ALL Stands Head and Shoulders Over Athletio Marvels of the Year. GEORGE HORINE SHINES, TOO rinriner Olympic Gnmea Ho Wnn Wntclicd Very Closely b- Ex perts from All Porta of the World. NEW YORK. Doc. 14, With the greatest athletio year in history Just going Into tho discard, it la Interesting to, select tome of the men who mado athletio hlslprjdur lng the year., ferae great mepts.wa.re held tho world over during l&ti but tho Olympic games nt Stockholm top'ped the wholo list of amateur athletic events. The ono figure that stood head and shoulders abovo the rest of a athletla world after the Olympic games had been cleared away was that of JlnV Thorpe. Asldo from his recent marvelous feats on the foot ball field, Thorpo proved him self unquestionably the greatest all around athlete that ever started on any field. Ho not only beat his competitors In all-around showing with a good per formance In each nnd every event, but ho won a majority of the different events of the decathlon and pentathlon series wllh performances that would have won' a na tional championship In this or any other country. Jim cleared over twenty-three feet In the long Jump, over six feet In the high Jump, ran his high hurdles In 15 seconds, and ran 1C9 yards in 11 seconds, and all that while under tha heavy strain of all-around competltlo'i), The proof conclusive that Thorpe Is tho greatest of tho all-around men that ever wore a spiked shoe came In tlo 1,000 meter performances that ho showed in tho decathlon and pentathlon series at Stockholm. After the terrlflci physical and mental strain of Bevcn days' continuous competition, Thorpe w,cit to the mark for his final event in the 'decathlon looking as fresh as when Jie atartedLthe weejt. beorev "Wn. n Strenti of White.. When the, pistol ' cracked there was a, streak of white. That was Jim." Horan his first quarter in a trifle worse than 68 socolld's. and by-that time was bo far ahead that ho started to grin. He .strove through and finished the l.OCO meters. 'miiefie 'WouHniittxj'-vcuirii u ,in.v .... to pieces, something that was never done by any man in an aii'-arouna compeuiiyii. -it is safe to assert, tort, that had ho. specialised, Thorpe might easily liayo'won any one of several events on the Olympic" program. Jim appears to bo best In tho high Jump, but there's no telling what he would do In the hurdles or 'the running brqad Jump If he was to do tho one event act., The trtft.lt W iThorpq doesn't train, for any one event, and , yet ho is good in any' of them. As good a critic as Lawson Robertson, coach of tlio Irish-America Athletic 'club, declares that Thorpe does not'Unow how to Jump a yet. Robertson made this, re mark Just after Jim had cleared twenty three feet nnd two inches In the brood jump" In tho all-round championships al Celtic park on last Labor day. "He doesn't get enough off the ground.' said Robertson. "If, ho could get half svs good a rise as Outterson doiii Thorpe would do twenty-four feet and better con sistently." to iha truth that Thorite tn doing the "runnlno- broad1' depends almost solely on speed and his ability to throw his body forward on landing In the turf, -ine 'rise ho has not. llnrlue HnUen Ruction. Possibly after Thorpe no athlete raised so much ruction with tho record book dur- lne 1912 as George Horine, who broke the long standing high Jump rpcord of Mike Sweeney.,) Horine cleared tno oar ai six feet and six and one-eighth Inches. This young Callforntan, who bore himself In a most creditable manner when his record was attacked by eastern critics, has Just about revolutionized high Jump ing, instead of twisting his body over tho bar with a short jerk, Horine rolls,, over with a slow, easy motion. Many have criticized Horine's method of landing on his feet, saying that ho dives over the bar; but, though his shoul ders and head appear to start for tho ground first when the drop from over the bar takes place, Horine lands on his feet as often as the average Jumper. During the Olympic competition llorlno was watched by tho foreign officials very closely, but there was not a single criti cism of his style. Horlne's failure at Stockholm was due to the fact that he was undoubtedly stale after a hard sea Kon's training on the coast, and also to the fact that the change of climate af fected Iiu to a certain extent. It must be remembered that the California!: travelled not less than 7,500 miles to com pete In the Olympic games, and wLthouJ a chance to stop In any one place long enough to get acclimated. His jump of six feet and one inch under these condi tions was a very creditable performance for even a record holder. Ted Meredith earned a place In the ath letic hall of fame, too. Meredith was to tally unheard of until last April, when he came, like a bolt from the blue and i beforo his winning streak was over the Mercersburg youth had turned the trick that cvory American athletic enthusiast had hoped for for nearly three years. Meredith Karns l'muo, This feat was the breaking uf thu world's half-mile record, that was down THE OMAHA r 1 "Buck" Weaver, on the books to tho credit of Emillo XiUnghL In. that wonderful rnco in. tho stadium nt Stockholm the young Penn sylvanlan earned fame that will stick to him to his dying day. And yet Mere dith Is only a boy. His career lit h on- fore him. He has sonslblv clven tin font JJttll playing and is taking a comploto rest .injrn training, after which ho will como lut'Taster than ever. Tho world's dJsJUJje- onora, for 3312 clearly belonir to1a''frirelirnA. TTnnnna Kohlemalnen of Finland: This youth from the land' that 'lies under tho great paw of, Russfaiis ono of tho most remarkable distance- runners tho wprld ' has, ' ever known. . At the Olympic games at Stockholm he was supre.ne in all rrtena fiver ttin 1.17)0- mctor event. Onco only was he obliged to show anything like his best,, and that -was in .the ftOOme'ter race, In which Jean Bouln, the French dandy, finished but two feet behind the all-conquering Finn In the driving . finish that com pelled both men to put all thoy had In the running for a full quarter of a mile. ivoniemalnen was just as good over the rough ground as ho was on the flat, ifo won tho cross-country championship' by such a. margin that he had finished and was chatting with the officials about the finish post when tho second runner plodded wearily Into the stadium. ;, - Had Kohlemalnen run nt rrtrulntlr.n I at metric distances, ho would have shat tered all amateur nnd nrofenslnnnl rcc oids.fjom two to five miles. In tho B.O0O- j luoiot iuuc in wjt.uM jie met. xumn, ooui the" Finn and hla rival from Marseilles turned three miles several Beconds fastor than Alfred Shrubb's record for that dis tance. Meets Defeat In New York. Great as Kohlemalnen is on the cinder path, he had to como to New York to meet the first defeat of his careet in "a scratch race, and Ip the runner who turned the trick, Abel' Kivlat, an other history-maker of the clnderpath during the' yenv that is waning. To find the steadiest runner of the year around the mile dlxtance one has to look nb further than this same little, bowfegged Staten Islandir. Every time ho tried this year Klviat beat 4:20 for the mile and his 4:1.3 in tha Harvard stadium last June was the fastest mile of the year, barring none, Such running as Kiviat has shown this year is seen only when a Conoff or a George comes along. It Is nonsense to say that Klviat is better than John Paul Jones, or that Jones la better than JUv- lat. The two aro too evenly matched to carry comparisons as far as that, but tho fact remains that Klviat has dona tho better running month In and month out during 1912. When Kivlat and Jones meet at the mile the one that has the edge in form will win. It was o when Jones beat tho local boy in Hrooklyn In the summer of llilj, and it was so when Klviat reversed tha decision at Stockholm eleven months later. Should they be brought together again each fit to run tho race of his life either Is likely to win, and the time will be around four minutes and ten seconds, There was one wonderful performance at the Olympic games that hus been more or lens neglected, and that Is the Jeap that Albert Glutei foil of the University of 'Vermont made lij .Winning the running broad Jump for hUUnc!e Sam. Gutter Kin had a luine buck-tit th time, but in spite of this handicap he leuped twenty four fuel and eleven and thro eighths SUXDAV 13U10: DKOEMBtiK 15, Wli . oyprlght, 1912, National News Ass a Shortstop Chicago White Sox Thfil youhgster, who van ; purchased from the San Francisco team in 1BJ1, Is, ono of tho real '"comers," having' mado good after many ups and downs. Tho Cleveland team released hlin twice, but J!mmyCallahun was wise enough to k the possibilities In him. Inches, -falling shy of the world's record by Just three-olghths of an Inch. As long aa.-a year ago Harr Hlllm.au, the Dartmouth collego coacfc, statod that Gutterson was tho coming broad Jumper, "1'vo watched hlhi," said HI U matt, "and if ho will only got tha foolish notion mit of his hoad that Is a hurdler and spec- lame in .the broad Jump, you'll eo hltn do twenty-five feet at tho Olympic gumes." Rugby and American Combination Would Be an Ideal Game ilONTUHAtr, Quobec, Dec. H.-Hy combining Rugby and American foot ball. Coach Shaughnessy of McGUl university, says that na thinks that tho Ideal game could be produced. On this point ho s&yst "I believe tho Ideal game could ba pro duced by pressing tho Canadian with the American game. Itemovo tho two sdo scrimmagers and play twelyo men a sldt, and you will havo a continuous perform ance, of running and kloklng. Twelyo men a side would give greater soopa for end runs and permit moro compact llne'playa.' Add to this the snapping of theiboll out of tho scrimmage, whereby, (t could fie put In tha play Just twice als. fasjj as t)V heeling, nnd consequently start the back lino In action with the same proportion of fpeed, and tho gamo would ho perfect. In my opinion, "I believo tho American rulo of allow Ing a fair catch, Instead of giving tack ling yards, is more satisfactory to both players and spectators. A fair catch Is all a halfback requires, and tho Ameri' can rules also proteots the man from being charged after he has kicked tha ball. The Canadian rule docs also, but it Is not enforced. The loss of half the distance to the offending side's goal line would soon eliminate the charging after a man hus got his punt away. I saw oua good halfback put away for the seu- son through being charged after he had kloked." , . . , To Keep Double Synteni. The 'Western league wlltiise tho double umplie system next season In all games. If tho decision recently nut-hod Is carried out There's Still Room For a Revision of I Rulesiof Foot Ball -i-juiMjj-j'reiN, n. j., Dec. 14. In tho opinion pf William W. Ilopor. former u,th letlo director ut Princeton university, thero Is still room for revision In the. foot ball rules. However, tho former Tiger conch thinks that the greatest need at the present tlrrie, Is that of developing play ers tmder the existing rules rather than making continual changes. To Koper'a way of thinking the present niloa are a great Improvement over tho old code, or tho now revised rulcB of the lost few years. In discussing the new rules for the beheflt of I'rincetonlans Mr. nopor s,v n'hc Hully Prlncetonlan: "In the winter of 1010 the rule makers hud oilo object In view to which they de voted. ' "practically all their attention, i,. ....,, .... u .K.riu thu ru'ies4ua to moku foot ball suf Very little tlmfc'was 'spent. uu niiimiiK ieie, owing1 to inw insistent demands from 'all Vniarterfr" for' a "safe game.' " ( "Tlld season'!- of 1H0 and lll clearly demonstrate! to ull that tho foot ball rules fnvnrod tho defensive team. Thti, however. Is not tho cae to such an ex tent today. A great strldo has been takon In tho right direction by eliminating small technical points. "Much moro cun tx done In this sumo direction. In tha first place, tha rule re quiring a forward pass to be made five yards behind the lino of scrimmage should be abolished. There Is not tha slightest reason for this restriction, and it puts too great a tux upon the referee. An other Innoviitlon this year is tha rule al lowing a forward paa tor be made to a player ten yards or lets behihd the goal line. Tills Is a rulo wjiich Is unnecessary, piay snouiu do connnea to tha field bo tween the. gdal posts. "Moio strength yet should be given to tha team of the otfonse. The onslfla kick. for instance. Is a very effective play that la abolished under the existing rules, It should ba ullowed without any rest tie tlona; In fact, kicking in every way should be encouraged, The onaldo kick developa kicking on the run and the accurate plao Ing of kicks. "But with these few additions th rule should be left strictly alone. livery one of tho larger teams Is too prone by fur to confine their play to tho beaten pth. The possibilities of the open gamo under the present system of rules has not as yet been developed." Many Player lUed. Figures compiled by Secretary Heydler show players were used In the National league in Vll. Cincinnati nnd St. Loul each usod forty-one, Chicago, forty; Phil- aueipmu. thirty-nine: iiltsburgn. thirty. eight; nostou, thlrty-tjeven: Hrooklyn. thirty: anil Now Yorn. twenty-e ght. Cln clnriatl uted twenty-four Pitchers all told uud Chicago had eighteen men on Its twining rtatr at ono time or anptner Wnhou Snni AVnnla flalae. Sum Ciuwford la a conditional holdou' Thero has been talk of putting him on first Itose for the 'Tlgert, It Qalnor'r i wrist goes bud again, and Sam says he won't play flrt tor tho same money hv hus been getting as an outfielder bo cause there Is o much mor wru-W tn do a,t first base. Drawn for The Bee by Gus Mager WILL BASKET BALL L1YE ON? I Question is Whether 0orae Can So Declare Ttyese in Answering Crit Stand on Own Merits. , icism ' irYnde. of Game. MUST MAKE SPORT CLEANER General Opinion la tint I (iiime Is Wmilngr Fast niul Mtmt lie Tuned Up to lift Able to Until lta Own. NliW YOHK, Deo. H.-ls basket bull to live on lta merits or will It eventually be abandoned by tho larger colfegen how1 playing the game In tho 'enstT It' Iff tho Kolieral Impression among colltiHia.ttts-tli.it the jfamo U waning fast olid losing' huuiy uf 1U ktanchest supporter, lloughnesi of play. It seems, has Injured tho game, - but now tho authorities" are' 'frying tft doctor it up with tho avowed pUrposo of Kvlnif it Just what offset the now changes will havo on tho gamn Is 'pro voking attention from ull parts of tho country, especially from eastern quarters, Where tha foundation Is not ao solid. Maka tho game cleaner has been the slogan for several yearn. The recent ac tion of tha rulo makers Indicates that tho (rend of thulr activities Is In tho nltovo direction. That tho gamp will bo madn elcuner this winter thero seems, no doubt, providing tho authorities' plans do not miscarry. The alterations which havo been made, according to tho prominent basket ball men, are for tlio better, and come as a big step toward winning baulc lOHt supporters. Daskot ball players In tho past lmvo played tho muli Instead of Iho bull tho usual rpugh pluy ensuing. Now tho keynoto of tho rulivj is to play Iho ball and not tho pian, While no real vital changes lmvo been mado In the codo over last season, the new. rules, adopted spell a reform which should mako thu gumo us It should he. Number l'lnyrr. The novel schemn of numbering the players, such as will rulo this season, rii lear to basket ball boosters a very good Idea, both from thu spectators' and offK Vials' vlowpolnt. AVIth each tnnn wearing il six-Inch number nn tho back of hla Jersuy It will bo easier In thn future for officials and scorers to dcslgnatn tho Jlliiycrs who havo been guilty of( com mlttlng moro tlmli -tho usual number of flpula. Fouling nnd shady luetics (ijt, yv Hons description' havo been tho game iMilof drawback, but with tho number nystom In voguo now It will bo ti fiard mutter for a player to get away with the so-cHiieti rouRh-iiouse taction and , es caping punlahmont. No spectator, espv lally those who follow collego sports, will tolerate unsportsmanlike piny. . Quicker play, too, Is to rulo, and this appears to bo another good move for improvement. In thoso lively days specta tors demand speed, and unless they 'get It show no disposition to enthuse, Ono reason why play should bo faster In because In tho futuro baskets will not bo tied and thn ball will have free jiaVa uge through tho net. Still another Im provement Is the rulo pertaining to fouls. After a foul has been declared tho rcfor'oo lias power to declaro pluy ten Hftconds lifter tho ball has been placed on tho foul line, This rule, It Is said, should havo a good effect In creating faaf'nlay. coaching Is burred from thq side llties, and the rulo covers an anglo over which spectators will wasto no tears. Just whot effect theso change will hnvo on the game will not bo determined until the big season begins in earnest and tho rules put Into effect. It Is thought, how- over, that their effects will be good ones, The Persistent and Judicious Use of Newspaper Advertising is the Ttoad to Business fiuecets. He lives for the grown-ups old Saint Nick when h i s gift is a Ford. Why not concentrate the Christmas buying and get the entire family the one present; they'll all enjoy most? An order for a Ford today will insure an early delivery. Every third car Is n Ford. Nearly 180,000 have been Bold and delivered. New prices runabout f 526 touring car $G00 de livery car $62-5 town car 800 rwltU all onulpnmnt, f.o.b. Detroit. Qet particulars from Ford Motor Company, 1910 Harney St., Omaha, or direct from Detroit factory. 3 -S FOOT BALL HOT STRENUOUS H00SIER EXPERT GIVES VIEWS NeverUle of (Smile Hemilt from Col lision! llntlier Tim it front fltrntn Upon Function of the IMnyers. CHIOAllO, Dec. 14. ProbatJy no other gumo has btion criticised ob has foot ball. Iteams of paper chave' been Used In lt hllBCk. Also much hair been said Against' U na a itruln upon the? vital functions' br those participating" In '-It.' , Those famll lar with tho gnmo consider most of these criticisms without reunotiablo foundation. Dr. C. V. Hiltohlns. director of physical training at Indiana University, for one, clalhis that foot bull isn't such a physi cal tax on players as most 'persons think. Dr. llulchlns announces that tho aver age time a player U In real action In about fifteen minutes, or one-quarter of tho tlmo It takes to play the average foot ball game. He wan a spoctntor at tho recent Chicago-Minnesota game and timed the playera to provo his contention, Hcgardlng the physlcat tax on players. Dr. Hutchlna says: "Tho foot ball rules specify a gnmo of four quarters of fifteen mlnutea each Tio rununl observer considers that this represents sixty minutes of Intenso cf fort; that twenty-two men are engagod' for a full h6ur In luit only pcrsonul col lision, but In a sustained strain, upon the heart and respiratory uppuratus. Collision Are Neverc. "To one familiar with the game as played from year to year It is apparent that the severities of tho gamo result, from tho collision rather than from ntrahu upon tlio functions that mako for health v 2, and vitality. h The timer ordinarily used tor timing fool bull games was started when tho ball wbb actually snapped. It wan stopped when the progress of the ball stopped. The tlmo taken up by the m teams In lining up, giving the signal ; and making miah shift as tho signal re-tnv quired was eliminated as not represent- , tng any real physical activity. ', '' "Tho rosulta were Illuminating. I per-, sonally held tho watch with a' single pur- Ik poso In mind, Tho actual time of play from the Instdnt of snapping tho ball until tho referee declared the boll 'dowi,;.,, during tho llrst quarter of fifteen mln utns was three minutes and tmrteem in seconds. "In tho second quarter moro puntliiu, "JjJ was resorted to by both teams, and thn,,r actual time of Physical activity was three minutes and thlrty-ftve seconds. ' "Thn third period revealed action of of threo mlnutea and thirty-three second , and tho fourth of two mlnutea and fifty- five seconds. llrcvltj- of ActlTlty. "Tho brevity of actual activity In the. fourth nuarter was due to Minnesota' effort to open tho gamo by" forward passes. In un effort to nt least overcome the ad vantage of Chicago's points. While the ball In bolng brought back after an tn completed forward pasn tho timer's watclv ticks steadily pn again. With edven points to their crodlt Chicago was anxious to utlllre.nll the -tlmo permissible under the rules without penalty for delay. "Thirteen minutes and sixteen seconds was tho total time .of action In the gutmi at Marshall field. This represents tho full tlmo In which the ball was hi play nnd the players in effect. Iess than 25 pv cent of the Playlnir period wbb utilized for attack upon tho opponents' goal line, less than one-quartqr of tho time of the game devoted to activity to actual carry ing out of the maneuvers calculated to befog tho opponents." Ik I II 4 J I 1 VI .11 it "a: f it r i iM 'is