he Omaha Daily Bee VOL'. XXXVIII XO. 114. OMAHA, THURSDAY MORNING, OCTOBKK " 1 DOS TEN PAGES. SINGLE COPY TWO CENTS. CURTIS ON T11E STAN miARY of tue bee ".- , i GUARANTY PRINCIPLE WROSC Bryan Prosperity TAFT AND HUGHES Indicted New York Banker Placti Blame on Morse. EE MACE NUMEROUS PROTESTS Sayi He Told Promoter Hit Practice Would Break Bank. REFUSES BIO WAN TO HEUTZE Next Say Morn Drew Check in Favor of Copper King. CROSS-EXAMINATION 13 SEVERE ttvmM to Present Defendant Mght of Fre Agent In Con slue t ot Bank Appar . ently Falls. la NCW YfrtK, Oct. 2S The apparent de termination of Alfred II. Curtis to exon rrate himself of all blame concerning the banking' transactions for which he and Charles If. Morse are undergoing trlil In the district court here became more do fined today when under the prompting; of bla attorney Mr. Curtis produced a letter written by him under date of June 13, 1907, and addressed to Morse, In -which he pro tested vigorously against the continuance of practices Inaugurated by the latter, which In Curtis' opinion constituted a grave menace to the stability of the Bank of North America. The incident of the cve.rdraft ot J 2! 0,000 by Morse was made the subject Of searching: questions by wit ness' own attorney. Mr. Curtis related the coming of T. Augustus Helnso to him for loan of 1126,000 and his refusal to grant the accommodation. Morse remonstrated with Iilm, saying: "Unless we let them have th money they must go to the wall." Curtla stood firm, however, and retorted: "They cannot have a cent of the bank's money! If they must fall they must fall." !ro to Reieas of Helnse. But to his amazement, he testified, a per sonal check of Charles W. Morse for 1126,000, drawn to the order of Helnae. came through the next day. The check had been honored, although at the time, the witness tu'il, Morse had a balance to his credit of jnlv JS.lf. "1 went to Mr Morse," the witness said, "mill to'd him ha must protect the draft mill at once wipe out hla indebtedness. Morfe st ence sent out and got two boxes f securities snd turned over their contents to me. T told him that the securities were Insufficient and he offered to give me an order for fl.000,000 of steamship bonds which he had on deposit in London. I ac cepted and on being given the order cabled to London to have the securities held sub Jet t to tha Bank of North America's order." The Witness was then turned over to the attorneya for Morse for what proved to be cross-examination. Despite the efforts of Morse's attorneys to present Curtis In the light of a free agent who at all times waa rot utiBef the fonfrol at Morso 1ho witness persisted In maintnlnlng his contention that lis was only tie instrument of another's will and purpose. Adjournment was taken until tomorrow, when Mr. Curtis will be further questioned. Moataomejry Attain C'onrlrted. PITTSBURG. Oct. 28. William Montgom ery, cnshler of the Allegheny bank until the discovery of a shortage In Its funds of over $ I 250.000 early last summer, necessl tiitej closing the Institution, was today for the second time this week found guilty of embezzlement and abstraction of funds, his I oculatlons In tha two caaea amounting to Jtr.8.0i0. As In the first case Montgomery offered no testimony in defense. The Jury was out less than two hours. Montgomery waa also Jointly Indicted with Addison A. Altaffer, discount clerk, ths Utter being accused of aiding the cash ier tn abstracting the bsnk's funds and hearing of thle case will probably begin next week. Every effort has been made to learn from Montgomery what became of tha money abstracted, but the cashier has steadfastly refused to Involve others and It la generally believed that It la to prevent tha possibility of these being dragged Into tha case that no defense was offered. LIFE TERM J3IVEN PRIVATE Moldler Who Ran Atuuck, KIIIIbk Four Men, Given Benefit of Mht Penalty. MANILA, Oct. M. Private Mike Beeclinin of the 'First cavalry, who ran amuck at Camp Btotensburg last May and killed four of his cumradea, was sentenced to life Im prisonment today by tha trial court before which he appeared. The court took the v1w that the crime waa unpremeditated and the result of a sudden fit of anger.' Under tha Spanish law, therefore, the couit bait that the circumstances In the caas did not warrant the infliction of tho death penalty. Beecham will probably appeal from this sentence, although the supreme court, to which hla appeal must he directed, has the power to substitute the death penalty. SCOTTISH RITES ELECTION M. W. Par Use of Washington, D. C, la Chosen Sovereign Grand Csmuaslrr, NEW TORK. Oft. 28,-Closlng Its annual meeting tha supreme couix-il of the Ancient And Accepted Scottish Rite for the I'nIUd ttatrl of A met tea today elected officers as follows; Sovereign grand commander. M. W. Bay Has. Washington. I. C; lieutenant grand commissioner, Calvin W. Edwards, Alhany. N. Y. ; grand minister of slate. George N. Glbion. Washington, P. C. : grand secre tary general, tlarcui W. Morton. Provi dence, R. . grajid keeper of archives. Walter Seymour. Newark. N. J.; grand p-Sfcter of ceremonies. Bsrnuel G. Eberlv, rushlngton. I). C. ; grand marshal general, mrj A. Gltdden. Iover. N. H.; grand dardbearer. W. 12. Blxby, Haverhill, las.; grand captain of the guard, Peter O. Anderson. Brooklyn. N. Y. PIERCE "WILL GO TO TEXAS eil Magnate Indicates Ho la Ready to Stand Trial on Indict- AUSTIN. Tea.. Oct. 2S.Henry Clay Plere is coming back to Texas to answer tha Indictment returned against him In this county churglug hi in with false swearing. Ocvernor Campbell was today advised by V Judge Barclay of 8t. Louis, who repre serxed tha slats at the hearing of Pir;, that tha tt. Loulaan will leave for Tea, and be bare November 4 to atand trial. Tha case will be called before Judge Cal houn of tha fifty-third district court, but It Is be laved that an effort will be made to get change of venue. radar October lift, 1DO. GOOBeRd 1908 v nz. Ufa 7m fpj Mr a ,-r- 2 3 46 Z 8 9 10 11 12 Id 14 15 16 1Z 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 2Z 28298031 TM WIATKEB. VOn OMAHA. POI NCIL BLUFFS AND VIOINITY-Falr Thursday. FOR NEKRAHK A Fair Thursday. FOR lOWA-FuIr Thursday. Temperature at Omaha yesterday: Hour. teg 6 a. m 3 6 a. m 37 7 a. m 37 8 a. m i a. m 41 10 a. m 46 11 a. in 61 Vi m 67 1 p. m S3 2 p. m 1 3 p. m K2 4 p. m 62 6 p. in f p. m 49 7 p. m 4J 8 p. m 41 9 p. m 41 jririilTTCAXi. Official figures show that Bryan ha3 not been a vote getter for his party In Nebranka, but every time ho has been a candidate he has run behind others on the same ticket. aga I The republicans of South Dakota are confident they will win in the coming election. Faga 1 Judge Taft spent a busy day making speeches In New York City, winding up with a big meeting in Madison Squara garden. Page 1 President Roosevelt gave out a letter yesterday In which Samuel B. Donnelly upholds the president's position with re spect to Judge Taft and labor. Fage a The editor of the New York Herald made public a letter yesterday In which President Roosevelt speaks highly of the attitude of Judge Taft on public ques tlona. Para 9 POBEXOH. A band of Yaqul Indians was caught tn ambush yesterday and a number slaugh tered. Pag 1 Negotiations are under way for the set tlement of a suit by Count Bonl for the disposition of his children. Page 1 Bulgaria shows pronounced peace ten dencies and dismisses the troops who have been called for purposes of war. Paga a Private Beecham was given a life sen tence for running amuck in the Philip pines. Paga 1 DOMESTIC. Ball has been furnished for a Russian patriot held on a charge of fomenting the revolution. Paga 8 The anniversary of the establishment of the diocese of Boston la being celebrated by prelates of the Catholic church. Paga 1 Many night riders are In prison as a result of confessions made by some who have boen captured.' ... . . Page 8 X.OOA&. Governor Sheldon quotes some figures puncturing the democratic storiea about Increases of land assessment in Johnson county. Page 3 Omaha bankers are glad now they did not put $300,000 in the Kgg-O-See plant which failed In Chicago recently. Paga S City Attorney Burnham says he never saw the report held by Councilman Mc Oovern showing private corporations are using city property. Paga 3 Plans of Postofflce department forcing railroads to accept ahort line baals of pay for carrying the malls will mean a loss of 11.000,000 to the roads. Paga 10 Mrs. Arthur Guiou. leader in society and wife of a prominent lumber dealer, files suit for divorce. Paga a COaCKXBOXAX AMD UTDUBTB.IAI.. Live stock markets. Paga 7 Grain markets. Paga 7 Stocks and bonds. Paga 7 MOTEHIITI OP OCBAJI STEAMSHIP. Port. NEW YOHK NEW YOHK NEW YORK NEW YORK LIVERPOOL..... UVERPOOb ANTWERP BREMEN , CHKHHl t RO... MONTREAL.... BOSTON QIECNSTOWN. LONDON Arrived. ' Hailed. ...K. P. Cecelle. ...New Amsterdam. ...Neuatrla. ...Louisiana. ..Devonian... .. Mtureitntt. .Zealand. ,K. W. dr Grove , President Great... . Leke Michigan.. . Romanic . Prlealand ..Minnehaha BOSTON DIOCESE CENTENNIAL High Officials of tborch of East At tend Ceremonies at Great Catbedral. BOSTON. Oct. 28. With moat of the hlgheat officials of the Roman Catholic church prelacy present, the Impressive ceremonials of a aolemn pontifical mass, of which Most Rev. LMomede Falconlo, papa) delegate to Washington, was the celebrant, the five days' observance of the centennial anniversary of the founding of the diocese of Boston was begun In the cathedral of the Holy Cross today. Arch bishop William H. O'Connell of the Boston diocese. In his office of preacher, offered "thanksgiving for the blessings God has granted us during these first 100 years of Boston's existence as a diocese." Besides the church dignitaries there were also present Governor Guild. Mayor George A. Hlbbard and other represenlativea of the state and city governments, and the Judiciary. Among the well krxwn prelates present at today's services were Archbishops 'Far ley of New York. Qulgley of Chicago and Keane of Iubuque, la.; Bishops Beacn of Springfield, Henneaay of Wichita; O'Con nell of the Catholic university st Wash ington, Allen of Mobile, Pltimaurtce of Krle, Pa.; McFaul if Trenton, N. J ; O'Connor of Newark. N. J ; Chatard of Indianapolis, lnd. ; Northorp of Charleaton, 8. C, and Burke of St. Joseph, Mo. WOMAN IS CIViL ENGINEER Aw lork Girl I alqae Among; Her Sex In This Line of Work. "So far aa I know 1 am tha only woman Civil engineer actively engaged in outdoor construction work. There are other girls who sit in offices and calculate Unlons and dally with the modulus of elasticity, but they do not climb girders or ride on the steam shovel." The claim of Miss Lillian B. Muiley of New York City to uniqueness in this re spect Is not denied by local engineers of tha mala sex. Miss Manley spent Tusduy la Omaha,, staying at the Rome to break by a day'a rest the ordeal of a trip from New York to Sn Francisco. 61 u goes t California to supervise the construction of an lnlerurban railroad. ""'I Force Prudent Man in Partnership with Plunger. THEODORE BURTON GIVES REASON Borrower and Depositor In Instltu tlon Will Foot the Bill I oeer talntr of Risk Fatal to Good Bnslness. 9 CHICAGO. Oct. 28.-(Specla1.) Theodore Burton, member of the monetary commis sion of the I'nlted States and chairman of the commission on rivers and harbors of the national house, speaking of the "Fal lacies of Guarantee Banking," declares the first . and perhaps the foremost objection to be urged against Mr. Bryan's proposi tion to guarantee the deposits In the na tional banks Is that It Is wrong In prin ciple. ll says to the man who is prudent, skill ful and honest In his "banking business and methods: "We will force you. In the most important feature of banking, to become a partner with many others whom you do not know and who are widely scattered." It Imposes a regulation on bankers which would be absolutely fatal to success In any and every other line of business. It would Ignore and obliterate the difference between those who are worthy to be suc cessful, those who are to be trusted and those who are not entirely to be trusted and not fully worthy to succeed. In addition to this It would violate that cardinal principle of all business opera tions, that authority must accompany re sponsibility. This is big consideration and can hardly be too strongly empha slsed In this particular connection. The substantial, honest and 1 conservative banker would, under Mr. Bryan's scheme. have no supervision whatever over the other bankers as to their methods of con ducting their business, but would at the same time be compelled to stand as guar antor for them, for the dishonest, the reckless and the blundering ones as well as for all others. Banker Most Gnarantee Blindly. And not only Is the solid banker made re sponsible under this scheme lor any mis takes or the results of recklessness or dis honesty on the part of any other bankers, and not only is he utterly without authority over them, but he is also powerless to fortify himself with any definite informa tion as to how other bankers are conducting their business; he cannot demand to see their books or to be Informed of the safety with which their loans are being made. Right in thia connection It should be said that there is nothing so fatal to successful business as an indefinite and an uncertain risk. In the life Insurance business the companies can, by means of dependable mortuary tables, Judge correctly on the average length of life of those whom they Insure. In the fire Insurance business there Is not quite the same degree of certainty or of uniformity In the amount of damage by conflagration In other worda, the unde fined risk In the field of fire insurance la greater. And this uncertainty eompels them to charge a considerably higher rate than they would otherwise have to charge. Insurance Asnlnat Theft .Unsuccessful To put it still differently, this uncertainty costs money; It Is expensive; it must bo provided for else the business Institutions assuming such a risk must come to disaster. Insurance against loss by theft haa also been tried, but the companies which have undertaken this class of risks have been almost uniformly unsuccessful.' In a word. It haa been ascertained In practical experi ence that Insurance against theft Is outside the line of practical and rational assurance. Now, Insurance against loss by banks Is far more impracticable and objectionable than Insurance against thef't, because It In volves many more elements of uncertainty. 'No man can even remotely approximate what will be lost by the blundering of well Intending bankers or by tha dishonesty of unscrupulous ones. The variety of mistakes which can be made by the blundering, careless and ln capable banker who really intends to be honest la perhaps only exceeded by the va riety of ways in which the unscrupulous banker can manipulate the funda Intrusted to his care to the disaster of his depositors, or, under the operation of the plan pro posed by Mr. Bryan, to the disaster of the conservative and honest bankera who are made liable to those depositors. Borrower and Depositor Foot BUI. The inevitable result of making all banks or bankers responsible for the losses of others over whom they have no control would be an increase In the rate of inter est which the banker must charge on loans and diminished rate of Interest to the de positor. The conservative banker would have to say to the borrower; "A new risk has been Injected into my business. I must secure myself against It. And the only way by which I can do thla la by charging a higher rate of interest to those whom I accommodate with loans." And to the man who comes to his bank with money for depoatt he would have to Bay: "The new risk Injected Into my busi ness by this undefined responsibility com pels me to lower the rate of Interest to those who deposit with me." This consideration is especially Important to the banker with regard to deposits be cauae In proportion as hla depoalta increaae hia risk Increases In any system Involving Insurance of deposits. Naturally and nor mally the aim and desire of tha banker ia to increase his depoaits that la tha basic advantage which will lead to success but under such a scheme as Mr. Bryan pro poses he would not only be moved to hesi tate about getting too large a volume of deposits In his own bank, but th deposits In tho banka of his competitors would be the legitimate cause of the keenest concern on hts part because of the liability involved. Sueernlatloa Would Increase. Then there Is another 111 result Ingrained In thia scheme which haa not been much exploited and which is, to my mind, really the worst of all: Insurance of deposits without regard to the degree of cara exer cised by those who receive them would atlmulate the Injudicious opening of enter prises. The banker Is necessarily a conservative element in our business life at least ha is so If hs transacts the banking business according to, normal regulations. At the same time It Is known there are tiiose in that occupation who are themselves In terested in more cr less speculative en terprises In that there are many othera who are eager and ambltloua to obtain higher rates of Interest than they are entitled to and hat a proper regard to the element of security would permit. In cases where here are land promotion schemes und mining ventures, where the risk of disaster Is great, and, . perhapa. (Continued on Second Fsge J He Calls From the Baltimore American. UNITliD FRONT IN DAKOTA Republicans Campaigning' Together in State as One Man. VESSEY WILL SECURE, MAJORITY Vote. Absolutely Certain for Taft Congressional Candidates of Be publicans Confident of Secur ing; Safe Majority. BIOUJC FALLS, 8. D.'.-'bct. 28.-(Speclal.) With less than a week remaining until election, the republicans of South Dakota are confident of winning a pronounced vic tory at the polls on Tuesday of next week. There Is absolutely no doubt that William Howard Taft'a plurality In the atate will be well above 15,000 and It may reach as high as 26,000. Early fn tha campaign the democrats were confident that Bryan would carry South Dakota by from 4.000 to 8,000, but as election has approached their hopes have dwindled, until now 1t would be an exceedingly bold democrat who would ven ture to go upon record with the prediction that Bryan will carry the state. They prac tically have conceded the state to Taft. That Eben W. Martin and Charles H. Burke, the republican nominees for con gress, will be elected Is the confident claim of the republicans. The principal fight of the democrats is centered on the governor ship and they are making a desperate ef fort to elect Andrew EX Lee, their nominee for thla position. Mr. Lee twice served as governor, being elected each time only by a scratch, but thla was during the hard times of the latter part of the '90s. Today conditions are much different and Mr. Lee's appeals do not strike the responsive chord that they did during his former campaigns, when voters were blindly casting about fur re lief from deplorable conditions following the last democratic, national administration. Great Prosperity in Sfute. Today South Dakota la enjoying such prosperity as the itate never knew before. The people generally are contented and happy and deposits in the state and na tional banka are constantly piling up and increasing. These prosperous condition leave little ground for the democrats to wage a successful campaign and In well informed quarters It Is fully believed that at the election next Tuesday the repub lican congressional and state tickets will be elected from top to bottom. The fight over the office of governor Is an Interesting one. Andrew B. Lee, It is admitted, will secure some republican votes, chiefly those of German-Americans, who are opposed to Robert S. Vessey, the republican nominee, because he Is a tern perate man. On the other hand Mr. Vessey may receive the votes ot some old line democrata who are not in full sympathy with Mr. Lee, who Is a comparatively re cent recruit to the democratic ranks. On both occasions when elected governor be fore Mr. Lee was a populist and had little use for tho average democrat. Much dependa, so far as the struggle for the governorship ia concerned, on how the Scandinavian vote of the state will be cast,. At the June primaries the Scandinavian vote waa almost solidly cast for the insur gent republican ticket, as that wing of the party more nearly represented the prin ciples of Scandinavian voters than any other party In existence in the state. They supported Mr. Vessey and by their votes (Continued on Second Page.) Where DO You Stand Mr. Shallenberger? To Ash ton C. Shalleuberger : In Tecutuseh you promised a couoty-optiou democrat that you would sign a county-option bill if passed by tha legislature. In Omaha you have promJaed to veto any county-option bill the legislature may paaa, or "any bill that looks like county option." Which promise DO you Intend to ep? Which promise DO you intend to break? i ' Or will you keep either promise? it T 1 X.I M I air r V. " Til I WM aVI . W7 W T AST X' M.'llvW. lJ. ua m SB, Himself the Advance Agent of Good ANOTHER RECEIVERSHIP SUIT Bondholders of New York Slep to Preserve Rights to Cleve Innd Traction. In CLEVELAND. Oct. 28. A new suit for receivership and one which it Is expected will take precedence over all other suits was filed In the United States circuit court todny, asking that the court take charge of all of tho local street railway proerty. Both the Municipal Traction company, the operating company, and the Cleveland Ball way company, the owning company, were made parties to the suit. A temporary re straining order also was Issued by Judge Taylor enjoining the companies from pay ing out any money or contracting any new obligations other than paying for lajior and the actual maintenance of the property. The suit was filed by the Central Trust company of New York, trustee for the bondholders. The company has a mort gage for S,276.0TO upon the property, which was given as security for the bonds. Th a tlon is the result of the lerent referendum vote, which practically left tho car com pany without a franchise. It Is stated that the receiver was asked for so as to throw the whole situation In the hands of the court that the creditors, bondholders and all others may have their Interests fully protected during the reconstruction, days now to Mlow, as an aftermath of the loss of the franchise. The relation of the franchise left the property In a chaotic con dition, with contending Interests claiming rights, possession and ownership. The new court action, it Is said, will Insure the pub lic adequate street railway service, while the affairs of the organisation will be straightened out. The hearing Is set for next Monday. YAQUIS LURED INTO AMBUSH Forty Killed by Pspsgo Indiana Who Were Armed by Government for Purpose. EL VASO, Texas. Oct. 28. News reached here today from various sources that a battle between l'apago and Yaqul Indians has taken place north of Altar, Sonoru, and that forty Yaquls were killed. According to reports, the Mexican government armed tha Tapagos, who lured the Yaquls Into ambush and slaughtered them. The reports have not been .officially confirmed. BISBEE, Ariz.. Oct. 28. Following a skir mish coiitlipsst nf Ilermoslllo. Mexico, in which It is reported that Bule. chief of tho hostile Yaqul Indians, waa killed, thirty-four Yaqul warrtore came Into Ilermo slllo and surrendered. Governor Torres of Sonon arrived from Europe yesterday and It Is expected that a treaty favorable to the Yaqula will be signed this week and permanent peace established. BAIL FOR RUSSIAN PATRIOT Public Subscription Sufficient to Bring- About Heleaae of Tarhl kovsky from Prison. 8T. PETERSBURG, Oct. 2S.-Nlcholaa Tschalkovskl, the aged Russian patriot who has been Imprisoned In this city for nearly a year, was released this afternoon at a quarted after 4. The fund subscribed In England to cover the bail demanded by the Russian govern ment for his release waa received here yesterday and was deposited In the im perial bank today. Tachaikovsy was Hken from the prison at 3:10 and conveyed under escort to the gendarmerie headquarters. He waa set at liberty as soon as the necessary formali ties had been completed. Times. BRYAN NOT A VOTECETTER Has Always Been Behind Others on His Own Party Ticket. OFFICIAL FIGURES PROVE THIS Jonrnnl-Nrws-Star Combination on Its Knees to Tom Allen Beg ging; Him Not to Kn force Contract for Space. TFrom a Staff Correspondent.) ' LINCOLN, Oct. 2S. (Special.) Election returns show that William J. Bryan has been the most costly experiment the dem ocratic . and populist parties of Nebraska ever tried. The returns show that he has never been the vote getter that other members of his party have been. In fact from tho time he flashed across the political horizon in ISM the democratic and populist sun has been sluicing. In tho year of 1890 there were three po litical parties In Nebraska of practically the same strength. The election returns show that the republicans cast 65.878 votes for their candidate for governor; tha dem ocrats cast 71.331 and the populists 70,187. Mr. Bryan was elected to congress that year from thla district and at once became i state figure. Two years later the demo cratic party, which he aspired to lead, cast 34,943 votes for president; tho populist csst 82,256 and the republican, which two years before waa the smallest party of the three, cast 87,213 and carried the state. Then Mr. Bryan Jumped In and Secured absolute control of the management of his party. In 16. when he was first nominated for president by both the populists and the democrats, he received 115,000 votes and the republicans cast 103,064 votes. The straight democratic party cast only 2,8&5 votes. In that name year the fusion candidate for governor received 116.415 votes and the republican candidate 94.723 votes. It re quired the populist candidate for governor to pull Mr. Bryan through that year. Gov ernor Holcomb received 10,000 more votes than did the leader of hia party, Mr. ' Bryan. In 1900 when Mr. Bryan was again the nominee of the populist and democrats for president, he received in Nebraska 114.013 votes; McKtnley received 121,835 -votes. f While Bryan lost the state by more than 7,000 votes tha populist candidate for gov ernor loat It by about 7u0 only. Governor Poynter received 113,018 and Governor Delt ricn receives. votes, foynter was a better' vote getter than Bryan. Then came the dismal failure of Bryan in 1904, when he was a candidate for the United States senate. Not a single demo crat was elected to the stale senate. Not one. In that aame year of 1904 the republicans cast 138.568 votes for president; tha demo crats cast 61,8.8 and the populists 20,518 votes. Always Brhlnd Parly. whenever Mr. Bryan was nut running for president he was rurjiing for IJnlted States senator. He haa never yet polled hla party vote in Nebratka in a state or rational contest. The records show that notwithstanding all the work of hia polltl cat organization in his behalf he waa ur. able to get the vote that other members of j his party received. Ihe explanation Is that Mr. Bryan has not Inspired confidence even in his own political party. He has been uble to at tract the crowds, get the applause and stir up the people, but when It conies to trust ing him with the affairs of the government even his own party balks and has always balked. Under Mr. Bryan's leadership from 1S90 to the present time the star of democracy haa gradualy gone down, until the memor able contest of 19u4. wherj he tried for the senate, Roosevelt carried the state by 67,10 and not a singlo democrat was elected to the state senate. of the three rrtes which started out equal in 1.V9U, when Bryan first became a stste figure, the pjpullits have disappeared, slaughtered by their supposed friend; the democrats have left a rugged remnant of that gallant band which placed James E. Boyd Irj the governor's chair. '11) e repub lican party only has remained true to Its (Continued on Second Pag ) Judge and GoYernor Speak in Madison Square Garden. GREAT STRUCTURE IS PACKED Multitude Stands in Pouring Rain , Waiting for Doors to, Open. GENERAL PORTER PRESIDES United States Senator Henry Cabot Lod;e Also Speaks. DAY OF HEAVY CAMPAIGNING Jadge Taft Speaks Fourteen Times and Governor Hughes Fifteen tilant Tarade Feature of the Evening. NEW TORK. Oct. 2S.-Th republics campaign In New York City reached It. climax tonight when William H. Taft, presidential candidate, and Charles E. Hughes, candidate for governor, spoke from the same platform at Madison Square Gar den to an audlenco flint filled the enor mous amphitheater. Their appearance at Madison Square Garden came at the end of a day which from a political atandpolnt was moet remarkable. During the day Mr. Taft addressed fourteen meetings and Gov ernor Hughes spoke fifteen times. Then tonight while the Madison Square meeting was in progress a giant parade waa wend ing Its way In a downpour of rain down through tho heart of the city. llo'irs before the doors of the garden were thrown open long lines of ticket hold ers hail formed. There Is no other struc ture in New York which can hold such an audience as Madison Square Garden, but It soon became apparent to the police that it would not have apace enough for the crowds rathered outside. At T o'clock a heavy rain set In and It was thought the throngs would dwindle, but this was a mis take. The streets for blocks around wero alive with umbrellas and few persona de serted. Excellent police regulations pre vented any unseemly crowding when the doors were- opened. By 8 o'clock tha police had to bar all except reserved seat ticket holders. General Porter Presldrs. A band of VW pieces kept the crowd from becoming Impatient during the hour or more that elapsed before General Horace Portpr. who presided, called the meeting to order. When Senator Henry Cabot Lodge ap peared on the platform the music ' was drowned out by cheering. Senator Chaun cey M. Depew, Senator W. Alden Smith and State Chairman Timothy I Woodruff were greeted with similar demonstrations. General Porter waa Introduced at S:OT o'clock and began by saying, that he had never attended such an enthusiastic meet ing. Then he attacked WjUlarn J. Bryatv suying that hs was suffering from politic p! and financial delusions. The chairman took up the Issue of guar anteeing national bank deposits and sa'd that Bryan's political economy was like trying to make tho government smoke S cent cigars when It took 10 cents worth of matches to light them. Presently General Porter prophesied the election of Mr. Taft. At the meVttlnn of the candidate's name there wns prolonged cheering, and when, a. moment later, the speaker mentioned the nsme of Governor Hughes there was an outburst that lastrd more than two minutes. Hundreds of small American flags were waved. General Por ter finally made his voice heard? and Intro duced Senator .Iodge. Rearhea IV York at Xoon. Mr. Taft left Troy In n drizzling rain a.n-1 arrived In New York Just before noon. Be ginning a meeting nt the r ver front, nenr the battery, he moved north through Man hattan Island, his program carrying him to the far end of the Bronx. He will leave after midnight to resume his work up state. His plans Included a short breath ing spell between the afternoon meetlnea and the night series, which Included tha meeting tn Madison Square garden. Judge Taft's voice plainly showed In hla early speeches today the strain to which It has been . subjected, and at Bethune street, where lie spoke for seven minutes, he was twice Interrupted by fits of cough ing. He appealed for support for the re publican ticket to the end that returning prosperity may continue to return. "We have had a panic, a period of de pression." said he, "but It did not reach west of the Mississippi river, for I have been there and they did n.;t know about It. The farmers are prosperous," he said, "and aH that la required for prosperity to be general is for those In control of capital to invest. "Now, those of you who are In corjtrol of capital to Invest, or If you have control of capital, which parly would you prefer In power to bring you an adequate return on that capital? "Would you prefer the rf'T that for ten years past has shown you tha greatest prosperity the world has ever seen, or a party whose leader has been proposing economic forms for the last twelve years only to abandon them one after the other? Who today believes in the free coinage of silver? Yet that leader for three presl dentlal campaigns advocated It aa the panacea for all our Ills." Judge Taft said the president haa tho power under the statutes practically to put the country on a silver basis, and asked If the man with capital to Invest would not hesitate before Investing h!g money if such a candidate were elected. Ileusous for Injunctions. In Uiu address st Astor Place Mr. Taft declared that no man anywhere haa mors sympathV with the man that labor with his hands than he. "They say that whan I waa on the bench I Issued Injunction! against labor," said he. "You fiever did, cama from the crowd. "Yea, I did," shouted Judge Taft. "Yes, I did. 1 Issued them against any. one against labor, against business when the plaintiff showed ha was entitled to one, and If they had not been Issued soma one would have been hurt." This retort was greeted with a tremen. dous outburst of cheering. Judge Taft said the most erlous Issue ol this campaign "Is t lie attack on the rourli being made by Urjaii and Oompers." At a meeting in I'n'on Equal- Judge Tafl denounced the democratic plan of guaran. teeing bunk deposits. He waa followed at that meeting by Gov. ernor Hughes, who paid a warm tribute t the republican candidate, whom he de scribed as "the man wf tue har, gad all tV " " 1