THE OMAHA DAILY BEE. ESTABLISHED JUNE 19 , ] 871. OMAHA , WEDNESDAY MORNING , DECEMBER 20 , 1893. SINGLE COPY FIVE CENTS SQUALLY FOR A TIME Excitement Took PoEssiion of the House of Representative * Yesterday , REFULICANS : IN A FIGHTING MOOD The" Start the Bow Ovortho Affair in tlio Sandwich Islands , EXCITING SCENES IMMEDIATELY FOLLOW Mr. Boutello Lends the Onslaught Against the Administration. URGENT DEFICIENCY BILL CONSIDERED I.rtjlMiUlon I'.ivoriililn to I'oiitliinon 1'iiHicd l > y the Homo An Appropriation to l'ny Menitirrii l.xtr.i All c ifr Wll- inn llunilR In lilt Kill. "WASHINGTON , Doc. 19. The house was In An ugly frame of mind today. The rcpubll- cnns wore In n fighting temper over the Hawaiian situation \vlicn the house met and the row opened immcdlately. Mr. Cookran's resolution of yesterday was presented and hurriedly referred to the committee on rules. Then came the sharp skirmish on the lloutello resolution. By moans of this reso lution Mr. Uoulollo suceeoJod hi celling an opportunity to address the house , hut his philippic against the government was cut short by the action of the spanker In de ciding the point of order to which Mr. Houlcllo was speaking In his favor , and re ferred the resolution to the committee under the rules. The consideration of the urgent deficiency hill WAS then resumed and some very ex citing scenes were enacted before it was finally passed. The Item appropriating J20li,000 for special examiners was amended so us to prevent the suspension of any pen sion without giving the pensioner notice , with opportunity to furnish testimony In rebuttal. Amendments wcro also adopted appropriating $180,000 for extra mileage for members and senators , * 10,000 for stationery and about $23,000 to pay employes of the liouso and senate an extra month's pay. The most bitter opposition existed to each of these propositions , the llrst of which was denominated on the lloor a proceeding whoso scandalous character had not been approached preached slnco the clays of the famous Ealary grab. led Iiy IHHiiil nml Holiunn. Mr. Bland and Mr. Hoiinan led the fight ngnlnii. these propositions , with a. view to placing tl.o members on record with n yea and nay vole , but they wcro not numerically Btronp enough and the committee on rules ultimately brought in a special order , by the terms of which the lllibusleriii ! ; was stopped without a record-making vote. Immediately after the .renting ( of the Jour nal Mr. Cockranof Now York offered the resolution elution , which ho sought to present yester day , to appoint a special committee of seven to invcstignto the alleged attempt of the lust administration to anr.ex territory to the United States without consulting the house of representatives anU to Inquire into the rlghls.of the house In the promises. The resolution had no sooner been read than a dozen men on each side of the house rushed toward the bar of the house crying for recognition. Mr. Boutolln meantime was \\ildly at tempting to offer his resolution of yesterday ns a substitute , but Mr. Cockran was recog nized to move to refer the resolution to the rommlttco on rules and , upon a motion , ho demanded the previous question. The con fusion was so great that the speaker ap pealed several limes for order. Finally Mr. ih-cchinridgo of Kentucky made the point of order that , under the rules , the resolution would go to the committee on rules without n motion. Thu speaker held in accordance with the point of order and referred the resolution. llmitrllo Uccogiilzml. Mr. Ilrecklnridgc then tried to move to go into committee of the whole to consider the urgency deficiency bill , but Mr Uoulullo de manded recognition for a privileged resolu tion and thu speaker was obliged to recog nize him. When read It proved to be the resolution Mr. Doutello sought to Introduce last night , declaring the prerogatives of con gress had been invaded by the policy of the administration , and declaring that policy Inconsistent with the spirit of the constitu tion and the traditions of the country. The row was now fully under way. Mr. MeCrcary , chairman of iho foreign affairs rommlttuc , made the point that thn resolu tion was not privilcBedand after snmosharp words from each side Mr. Boutello got the flour to discuss the question as 10 whether the resolution was privileged. "The message of the president. roaO yes- torday. indicates thlo country may bo In volved In war with a friendly power for all wo know , " said ho , In n loud voice. Ilo held that it was the imperative duty of congress , reluctantly recognized by thu president , to disavow , discredit and repro- bale a policy designed to bring the country Into discredit In the eyes of the civilized world. [ Great npiilauso on the republican tine , ] ' 'I care not whence this policy ema nates , " continued Mr. lloutelle , "whether from a republican president or a democratic jsurpcr , " c ; on fin t n n The confusion that followed the \vord "usurper" drowned the rest of Iho ( sentence. Ha continued lo talk amid loud cries lor nrdor and the speaker at last , with tlio aid of his gavel , brought tlio house to a stand still , llcfore Iho gentleman from .Maine had fairly launched Ids next philippic Sneaker CH p suddenly swept the ground from under him by deciding the point of order In accord ance with thu contention of Mr. MeCroary nnd referred the resolution directly to the committee on foreign affairs. Mr , Houtcllo and Mr. Dlngley then at tempted to argue the question relating to the decision of the chair , bin iho speaker was , obdurate. Amid great excitement ho ordered all pentlemen to bo seated , declar ing ho would hear no ccntlcuian until lie had formally discharged Ins duty upon the point nt Issue. Speaker Crisp then delivered his decision in a calm , quiet tone , though he was cvl- denlly laboring under iho general oxcllo- incut prnr.ilcnt in the house , and referred thu resolution to the committee on foreign n If airs. Mr. lloutclle immediately appealed from the decision of the chair and Mr. McL'reary moved to lay the appeal on the table. Till , * motion pii'vullodlbO lo b9. During Ihc call of committees for reports. whi"h lolloucd , tlio Nicaragua canal bill wafc fnvorablj reported from tne committed cm commerce. Uclli'lrnry . \ ) > prui > r'.iitlon , i The house nt the conclusion of the call went Into committee of the whole for the further consideration of the urgent dc- ndoiu'V bill , Thu item appropriating I''OO.OOO for special examiners was r.galn antler lire. IK/lmnu's amendment , lU-bluiuil to prevent lh < ? pension pfhYo from employing persons , "other than pciiblon examiners , " as spies mil secret agents to liounu union to'.dlcrs ' , ras defeated , and Mr Martin offered the following : "Provided that any pension heretofore , or that may hereafter be granted to any applicant therefor , under any laws of lue united States authorizing the gruutliig and payment of pensions on application made nnd adjudicated upon , shall bo deemed nnd held by all officers of the United States to bo n vested right in the grantee to that extent ; that payment thereof shall not bo withheld or sus | > cnde < l untn aftcr duo notice to the crantco of not less than thirty days j the commissioner of pensions , aftcr hearing nil the evidence , shall decide to annul , va cate , modify or net nsl'iu thn decision upon which such pension was granted. Such notice tocranteo must contain a full nnd true state ment of any charges or allegations upon which sucli decision granting such pension shall besought to bo in any manner dis turbed. " This was adopted by a vote of 104 to 45. 45.Mr. Mr. Hayes of lows offered nn amendment appropriating (10.1.030 for mileage for mom- bora of the liouso for the present session and f 15.000 for mileage for senators , and $4 : , < KK ) for stationery for the house and 311,000 for thn senate. The members showed a peculiar and per sonal interest In the Ion ; ; discussion which followed , crowding about the speaker's desk nnd listening to every word. To some of them from thn far-off Pacific its determina tion involved as high as $1,200. , \viiB ii ami in < t.iuic inn. During the debate Chairman Wilson of the ways and means committee rose In his place with the long looked for tariff bill in hand , and th'i committee nrosn Informally to receive the hill. There was no demonstra tion. Mr. Wilson simply reported from the wavs nnd means committee "A Bill to Kcduco Taxation , Provide Revenue and for CHher Purposes. " The discussion of the Hayes amendment was continued at some length and was finally adopted by a vote of 143 to 49. Mr. Curtis of Kansas then offered an amendment to pay the employes of the house and senate , including the capltol police , who were on the roll November II , when the extra "csjion adjourned , an extra month's pay , The amount involved was $113,000. Aftcr some debate the Curtis amendment carried by a vote of IflU to18. . No further amendments were adopted and the committee reported the bill to the house. A separate vote was demanded ov Mr. Bland on the mileage amendment , and by Mr. Brcchinridpo on the amendment for an extra month's pay for employes of iho house nnd senate. Mr.ells of Wisconsin called for the yeas nnd nays on thu mileage nmondmcnt , but the members wcro not anxious to go on record. Itlunil starts n Flllbiutcr. Mr. Bland of Missouri immediately inau gurated a filibustering movement. He ex plained that all ho wanted was n record- making vote. That's lust what rou don't cet. " cried a dozen voices. Mr. Holman and Mr. Bland insisted that they were entitled to a yea and nay vote , nnd Mr. Biuloy of Texas testified to the Jus tice of the demand , hut the house would not apree to it , nnd Mr. Bland went on mak ing filibustering motions to adjourn , to take a. recess , adjourn to a certain day , ntc. Meantime the speaker had retired from the chair , ami the committee on rules had held a meeting. A special order was prepared. The gog was invoked. General Catchings' appearance with the rule was greeted with loud cheers. Successively the order was ndoptcd , the motion to adjourn was defeated , the mileage amendment , the amendment for a month's extra pav to house and senate employes was agreed to , and shortly there- alter the house adjourned. JN TUB SENATIJ. Kxpcctril Debate on the I'reililont'i Ha- watlun MesnuRG Averted. WASHINGTON , Dec. 10. The debate which was expected In the senate today on the president's message ns to Hawaii was averted by Mr. Hoar of Massachusetts , whose motion to refer the message and ac companying documents to the coaimitteo on foreign relations is the pending question before the senate , yielding to Senator Berry of Arkansas and to Senator Peffor of Kan sas. The first named addressed the senate in advocacy of the bill to repeal the federal elections law , while Senator Pcfl'er argued in favor of the bill introduced by him yesterday appropriating money for immedi ate use in relieving want and destitution throughout the country. Mr. Hoar stated , however , that on tomorrow he would call up his moiIon to refer the president's message and accompanying documents to the commit tee on foreign relations , nntl in all proba bility ho will address the senate at that time upon the Hawaiian situation generally. Among the bills Introduced was one by Mr. Mundcrson of Nebraska , to dispose of the discriminating duty imposed on tea fro n this side of the Capo of Good Ilopo ; referred to the linanc committee. DUciiHxIni ; a Trench .Monopoly. During the transaction of moraine busi ness Mr. Fryc , republican from Maine , arose and said : "About t\vo \ years ago a French cable company made triplication to our sec retary of state , Mr. Blainc , for permission to land its cable from Brazil on the const of the United States. Our secretary of state investigated the matter and found thu com pany had , by authority of law of Brazil , a monopoly , and that no company while that power was iifoxlslcnco , and it was in per- po'.ully. would bo permitted to land a cable on the Brazilian coast. So our secretary of state refused to grant tno permission. "I am informed , whether true or not I cannot say , that that company has recently appeared before the secretary of itale , and that ho has granted to this company the right it asked. Ifithotrno and there is no remedy to be had for it , then the United States will be perpetually kept out from landing any cubic on ihcconst of Brazil. " In view of these facts ha offered a resolu tion making inquiry of the secretary of state as to whether this was true. Mr. Ilunton , democrat , of Virginia I oh- Joct to the present consideration of that res olution. 1 think the senator is mistaken in his statement. Mr. Hun ton was linn in his objection to the present consideration of the resolution , and it wont ever under iho rule , liouso Dill authorizing the fourth assistant postmaster general to approve postmasters' bonds was passed. I'mlcni ! Kluctlon * l.iiw. The bill to repeal the fcdor.il elections law was then taken up and Mr. Berry , demo crat , of Arkansas , addressed the sonata thereon , Ho believes these l-iws were base in principle and bad in pollr.y. They wore part and parcel of the reronstruuUon laws. They had been passed at a time of great po litical excitement and for the purpose of securing the supremacy of an ignorant race In the south. If there had over hoen any excuse for their passage there was nona for their retention. In conclusion Mr. Berry said republicans should remember the south was now in the union , and that some south ern men were ready to defend It , to speak for it. to work for it , and , if need be , to light for It. 1'iilfor ' . on 1'ovtTly. Mr , Poffor , populist , of Kansas , then ad dressed ihe semite in favor of the bill Intro duced by him yesterday , appropriating 10,300,000 for Immediate use , in relieving want nnd destitution throughout iho coun try , Never before In the history of the country , ho suld. had there been so much want nnd destitution among tin ) poor and unemployed. Indeed , it was stifu In estimate that one-fourth of the population of tills country at this hour was affected more or less by the present distress. The news papers of thn country , especially ihoso sometimes called great , and which were sometimes criticised the most harshly , had been doing a great bcrvlee in relieving distress. Ho ox-plained that bj a clerical error the amount proposed to be appropriated was stated in the bill as { 4,800,000 , lie intended to insert $03.300,000. The money proposed to bo appropriated was money for which no one hail use , thu silver dollars in the treasury not covered by certificates , At Ihc cud of Mr. Puffer's remarks Iho bill was referred to the committee on eJu- cation and labor. The Bonatu then went Into executive session. The doom wcro re opened at 8 : SO and Mr C'ocxrcll , democrat of Missouri , moved to taUo up the bill amending iliu laws BO as to ivqulve original receipts for deposits of post mat torn to bo sent direct to the fourth nudUor of thu Postofllco department. Aftcr debate ttic bill went over. Thcicimteat4:20iidourueu. ] TARIFF REFORM ON AGAIN Another Phase of t'ao Bill as Reported by Prof. Wilson's ' Committee. NEW MEASURE REPORTED 10 THE HOUSE Some Clinncen Mnilo by tlio Mnjurltjoftlio Committee Itcrnrm .Mint Cumo Gradually I'rotcctlonum Al- aji Asultic I r More. WASHINGTON , Dec. 10. The following is Iho majority report of the ways and means corn ice : The American people , after the full and most thorough debate ever given by any people ple to their ilscal policy , have deliberately and rlphtly decided that the exist ing tariff is wrong in princi ple and grievously unjust in operation. They have decided , as free men must always decide , that tno power of taxation has no lawful or constitutional exercise except for providing revenue for the support of the gov ernment. Every departure from this princi ple Is n dcparlurc from Iho fundamental principles of frco institutions and Inevitably works out a gross Inequality in the citizen ship of u country. For moro tnan thirty years wo have levied the largest part of our federal taxes In violation lation of this vllnl Irulh , until we have In the existine tariff an extreme nnd volumi nous system of class legislation to which hls- lory may be challenged lo furnish any paral lel. So many private enterprises have been taucminto partnership with the government , so many private enterprises now share in the rich prerogative of taxing 70.030,000 of people that any attempt to dissolve this illegal union Is necessarily encountered by an opposition that rallies behind the intelli gence of monopoly the powc"0f concentrated wealth , the Inertia of llxed habits and the honest errors of a generation of lalsc teach ing. Must Go Slowly nt I'lnt. The bill on which thu committee has ex pended much patient and anxious labor is not offered as a complete response to the mandate of the American ueoplo. It no more professes to bo purged of all protection than to ho free of all error In Its complex and manifold details. The committee , however , may deny the existence of any executive pledge or the right of congress to make such pledge for the continuance of such duties that contain with thorn more or less acknowledged protection. Wo may recognize that great industries exist whoso interest and prosperity it is no uart of our reform either to imperllor to cur tail. Wo believe , and we have the warrant of our own past experience for believing that reduction of duties will not injure , hut give moro abundant life to all our great manufacturing industries , however much they may dread the change. In dealing with the tariff question , as with every long standing abuse that has interwoven itself with our social or indus trial system , the legislator must always remember - member lhat. in the beginning , temperate reform is safest , having in itself the prin ciple of growth. I'rotRctlnn Fallacy Proven. A glance nt the tariff legislation of our own country ought to satisfy every intelli gent student that protection has always shown its falsity ns n system of economy by its absolute failure to Insure houlluy nnd stable prosperity to manufacturers. It teaches men to depend on artlllciai help ; on laws taxing their countrymen for prosperity In business , rather lhanupon tholr own skill and effort. It throws business out of its natural channels into artificial channels , In which there must always be fluctuation and uncertainty , and is mattes n tariff sys tem the font ball of party politics und tno stability of large business interests tnostatie of every popular election. None have recognized this truth moro fully tnan tne wiser men wiio from time lo lime Have engaged in the so-called protected industries , ifears ngo Mr. Edward Everett stilted in an oration at Lowell that the sa gacious men who founded the manufactures of Now England were never friends of a high tariff policy. I'rotoclluii ItroiiRlit Unrertnlnty. Hon. Amos Walker , a former member of this huuso from Massachusetts and ouc of our foremost writers on economic questions , declared it to bo within his own personal knowledge thai when the proposal was made to impose the protective tariff of 1810 , the leading manufacturers of Hhodo Island , among whom was Mr. Slaler , Iho father of cotton spinning In tills country , met at the counting room of one of their number and after dolibcrato consultation came unanimously lo Iho con- clunlon thut they had rather bo let alone , ns their business had grown up naturally alone and succeeded well und they felt confident of Ils conllnued prosperity If lot alone by the government. They arcued that by layIng - Ing a protective tariff their business would he thrown out of Its natural channels and bo subjected to Humiliations nnd uncertainty. But , aa usual , the clamor of selllsh and less far sighted men and the ambition of law makers lo usurp Iho place of provi dence prevailed. The country nntcrod on a nrniecttvo policy with the unfailing result that the government begot a violent demand for more government help. The moderate tariff of 1810 rapidly grow into the "tariff of abominations" that carried the country to the verge of civil discoru nnd provoked n natural revulsion. Protection lias run a like course slnco 1S01. Protection Kvcr Urlitf > * Morn rrnUwtlno. When congress began to repeal war bur dens anil to relieve manufacturers of internal taxes which thev had Hood tci securnfoninnn. sating duties on foreign products , thcro arose a demand throughout the country without resncct to party for a reduction of the war tariff , Unable to resist this do- iimnil' the protected Industries thus affected thwarto.-i any reduction by substituting a scnatu hill which curried a horizontal cut of 10 per cent. As soon , however , at the election of 1874 gave the next house to the democratic party that bill was repealed by tno outgoing republicans nnd the rates restored to what they were before 1872 , and although iho demand for tariff reform and for reduction of taxes has over slnco been a burning und growing ono In the country , the protecicd Industries nave exacted and ro- ceivcd from every republican congress elected since 1H74 nn increase of their pro- tcclion , occasionally permitting the repeal or the lessoning of a tax that was paid In the treasury In order to keep away from or to Increase duties levied for their oenellt , Protection , lett to Its natural momentum never stops short of prohibitionand prohibitory walls are always needing lo bo rebuilt higher or to bo patched and strengthened. A protective tariff never hus ami never can KVU ! stability and satisfaction - faction lo Its own benelichries. Even if Its victims are too weak and too scallorod lo agitate for itu decrease these bsnellclarlcs are sure to udvocato for an increase , l.oner Turin * uiui Incron ? ( \Vue . When iho reform lariff of 1840 was before congress iho air was full of prophecies that it would destroy our manufacturing In dustries , throw labor out of employment , or compel it to work at pauper wages and dwarf nnd arrest Uiu prosperous growth of lliu country , Every representative of four greai manuraclurlnpo , tales of New England voted asfuin.-1 It with gloomy forebodings of its blighting effect. The rate of duties pro vided In that tariff was much lower than those of Ihu bill wo hero offer. U'hatwis theresulll Instead of practically killing the Indii stries and pauperizing tha l.-.bor of Now " England" the rest of the country t .o tariff of 1810 gave Immanso vigor lo man- ufaiturcs with steady employ lucnt and Increasing Wages to labor , sa tint , after elovjn years expericnes unJor it , the longest period of &taollliy we have ever enjoioil under any lariff , the repre- icutatlvcs of tueie tame state * , wlvh practi cal unanimity , volcdifprn further reduction of 20 per cent , and by a two-thlnls vote sus tained ! the tariff of 1857. which made a re duction of 23 per c nt * Now prosperity fol lowed with that-foe iho manufacturers of that and other soctliinfe'Of the country under the low tariff of 18. " > 7 o that when the. Mer rill tariff bill of 1801 took the first backward step there was n general protest against It. lion. Alexander Itico of Massachusetts said In the house : "Tho manufacturer asks no additional protection , Ho has learned among other things that the greatest evil , next to n ruinous competition from foreign sources , is an excessive protection which stimulates a llko ruinous and Irresponsible competition at'homn. " ( Congressional Globe , 1850. CO pagd , 107) ) . Mr. Sherman of Ohio said : "When Mr. Htanton say ? the manufacturers are urging nnd pressing the bill , he says what ho must certainly know Is not correct ; the manu facturers have asked over and over ncn In to bo lot alone. " ( luld. 2O.V1) ) . Mr. Morril himself has slnco said that the tariff of 1801 was not asked for and but coldly welcomed by manufacturers. ( Con gressional Globe , lb(19-70 ( , page ! l,2V.ri ) . Senator H. M. Hunter of Virginia , then chairman of the senate finance comtnitlee , said : "Have any of the manufacturers como hero to complain or USK for now duties ! It is notorious if wo were to leave It to them ( the manufacturers of Now England ) to the manufacturers of hardware , textile fabrics , etc. , there would bo a largo majority ngnlnst any change. Do wo not know that the woolen manufacture dates its revival from the tariff of ltd" , which altered the duties on woolt" The history of American industries shows that during no other period lias there boon a moro healthy and rapid , development of our manufacturing Industry than during the fifteen years ot low tariff from 1840 to IM'd , nor moro healthy or harmonious growth of agriculture and all other industries of the country. No chapter in our present experience car , rlcs with It more salulory lessons than this- and none could appeal moro Htronply to law makers to establish n Just and rational sys tem of public iovenuoneithoroxiiaustingng- rlculturo by constant blood letting , nor keeping manufacturers alternating between cnllls and fuver by nrllllclal pampering. In this direction alone lies stability , concord of sections and of great industries. Krror * Will Ho Mniln. Wo have already said that the public dis cussion may disclose errors of minor detail in the schedules of the bill. To escape such errors would require so thorough ami minute n knowledge of dlvislbns , subdivisions , com plex and manifold mazes und involutions of our chemical , texllio , motnl and other in dustries , that no committee of congress , no matter how extended the range of tholr per sonal knowledge , or how laborious and painstaking their efforts , could over hope lo possess. Wo have not forgotten that wo represent the peonlc.iwho are many , as well us the protected interests , who arc the few , and while we have dealt with the latter in no spirit of unfriendliness , wo have felt that it was our duty-and not their privilege to make the tariff .schedules. These who concede the right of bonollclaries to llx their bounties must necessarily commit to them the framing and wording of Iho laws by which these bonntles nro secured to them. A committee of .congress thus becomes merely the arnamiunsis of the protected Interests. It bat been showiisso clearly and so often In the dobatoes in 'this , house that nearly every Important schedule of the existing law was mtido.ip ita.very words and llgurcs by ronresentatlvea'ot the Inturesls it was framed to protec'/.thnt ' it ia unnecessary , in cur report , to present 'tho ' record proof of this fact : but it may not be 'amiss ' to cita further evidence to.Show that this is not only the necessary' rule , but the open and avowed method qffrariling protective tariffs. How SlcIiluley'sOllllVnJT Mnilc. When the senate substitute for the bill passed by this hoiiso in the Fiftieth congress which substitute Is the real basis of the existing law was-belnp prepared. Senator Hoar of Massachusetts appeared before the senate subcommittee and used this languairc : "Instead of coining before your subcom mittee for a formal hearing on our Massachusetts industries , 1 thought the best way was to prepare a table of all the various industries , per haps some sixty or seventy in all , and nsk Brother AM rich to go over them with mo and ascertain what the people wanted in each case , und if tlicru wcro any cases in which the committee had not already done what the petitioners desired , or had not in flexibly passed u'uon the question , I could have a hearing before you. But 1 llnd in every instance the action of the committee , us Mr. Aldricu thinks it likely to be. is en tirely satisfactory1 to the interests I repre sent , with the exception of one. or two. and the papers in regard to tUeso cases 1 have handed to Mr. Aldrlch. " C No stronger indictment of ttin whole pro tective system could ho. made than that which Is unconsciously carried in these words of a United Sidles senator Hint luw which impose taxes on the great masses must bo written in language so technical that the most intelligent citizen cannot fully understand them , an'rt that the rates of taxation must bo dlctatcd'by the selfishness nnd greed of ihoso'who ore to receive the taxes. We have believed that the first stop toward reform of the tariff should bo a release - lease of taxes 'on the materials of industry. There can bo no substantial and bencllcial reduction upon tno necessary clothing and other comforts of the American people , or any substantial nnd beneficial enlargement of the Hold of Ameri can labor , so long as wo tax materials and processes of production. tlvcry tax upon tlio producer falls with in creased torco on the consumer. Every tax on Iho producer in this country is a protec tion to his competitors in nil other countries , nnd BO narrows , his market as to limit the number aid lesson the wages of these to whorri ho can plvo employment. Every cheapening in the cost or enlargement of the supply of his raw matprlals , while primarily inuring to the 'jcnelit of the manufacturer himself passes under free competition Imme diately. Iron anil Htcel Schedule , Wo have made n mlurtlion of about one- third in the iron and steel schedule , begin ning with free ore and a duty of 21 * < f per cent on pic iron. Wo have reported n ucalo of duties considerably below these of the ex isting law , graduated according to Iho de gree of manufacture , which should brUg benefit to the consumer without calling for any halt In the projr.e.&s of tlml great In dustry in our country.- ' The duty on iteel rails has been reduced r > per centum , which , according to the reports of our Department of Labor , n'ulto.compensates for alt difference In the cost of proJuctlon In this country nr.d abroad , Thcro scorns to bean an authentic report ( bat the pool of Ameri can railmakers , which , under the shelter of the present duty of f 1U.4-1 per ion hus kept up prices to the Auieclcan consumer far beyond ibo cost of prtxliic.tion and lejrltlmuto prolils , has beenreorganized , to contui'io the regulation oftll'elr prices above the proper market rates , As all' sblppors , nnd espe cially American Bhlppers , arq vitally Inter ested In cheapening t6otost'of transporta tion , rates of duty upon steel rails should bo adjusted so as lo protect them from mo nop- ol.v prices and monopoly conditions. Upon tin plato the duty has been gauged witn reference to the- revenue it will bring Into the trcauurv , and Iho difference be tween this duty and that upon the black plate has 'icon ' lessened with a view to not t .scourago what may not unjustly bo caied , tlio Industry ol making American tin plato by the mere dipping in this country of the imported black plato. ' Tlio Suur llounty. I In the sugar schedule we should have pro- rroa to'wlpeout ' at tTilngle legislative stroke the existing bounty sysiem. We bcliovo It to be contrary to the splr.it of.'our institu tions , and can conceive of no'circiimstnncc ! under which wo should have advocated or approved Us introduction into out I ; uvs. Wo have found it ex is ) in ; : there , as we llnd It virtually existing In every oilier schedule of oui tariff , and dealing with this more offensive form , as wo have dealt with other schedules where largo property interests are at btako wo have reported a provision for Its ropen ox SKOO.NIJ HOPKINS ON THE SURFACE Chicago's Democrats llavj Scored Another Triumph nt the Polls , REPUBLICANS WILL MAKE A CONTEST supporter. * of Swift Secure Ampin rvlclcnco of Orem I'riiuil unit Will IMnli tlio iiectlonTlirntili : tlio Courts llnloro < Julltln . CiiiCAno , Dec. ID. [ Special Telegram to Unn. ] Hopkins' rooters were ringing cow bells , blowing kar.oos or making some sort of noisu soon aftcr dinner time tonight , f they were not attempting to drink all the iquor in town , because the hottest nunlclpul election the city has passed through in years had gone their way. Ac cording to Ihc face of Uio returns the lemocratlc candidate has a plurality of 1,895 , which , with a change of ono vote in each of iho cliy's ' 7M > pre cincts , would elect George II. Swift to the mayoralty. The result effected , ns it un doubtedly was by fraud at the polls In many nslances , Is too close for the republicans to ol It go by default. Persona having small bets up on tho. result need bo in no hurry to settle , because there Is going lo be n contest , and Mayor Swift does not Intend to relin quish the ofllco to which ho claims he has been rightfully elocled , unless the supreme court so decrees it. The republican party callers nro agreed upon fighting it out to the ast ditch. ( Inoil nn n Victory. Whether the outcome Is favorable to their candidate or not the election is almost as ; oed as a victory lo the republicans. Cleveland - land carried the city last year by a plurality of 42.000. This election was ns squarely upon party lines ns the presidential canvass , ind the democratic plurality has therefore at least been reduced ovcr40,000 , If not wiped out altogether , as evidence said to ba In possession of the republican campaign com- inillco is likely to snow. The early figures furnished by the police returns nro now shown to err quite materially , and nt 10 o'clock several wards had been corrected so ns to show cains for Swift , though they nro ikely to affect the result. The Tribune igurcs Hopkins' plurality 1,20'J , and the Inter Ocean gives It 1,305. Will Mnko n Contort. The republican city executive committee was in session until n late hour lonight. Ex- Corporation Counsel John S. Miller met with the committee and when it adjourned at 11 o'clock ho expressed the opinion that there was sufficient ground for a contest. The committee is agreed to make a light all along the line. The results ns an nounced by the judges in each precinct according to law show a'.plurality for Swift , according to republican authority , while the police returns , doubtless lii&scd , show that Hopkins has about 1HX ! ) plurality. The claim Is made that in a number of strongly democratic wards fraud of the worst kind was prncliced colonization , repeating and throwing out of republican votes. The com mittee claims to bo in possession of a mass of evidence which It wilt present to the can- vusslnc board. As- that body is strongly democratic ttio fight , ia alliprobabUity , ' will be carried Into the courts. ' ' " * " " I.KSS THAN TWO THOUSAND. Hopklnn , tlio Dmnocrntlu Candidate , flora In by u S in-ill Majority. CHICAGO , Dec. IS ) . John K. Hopkins , the democratic candidate for mayor , was elected over Gcorgo 13. Swift , his republican rival , by a majority of l.US'i The total vote was : Hopkins , democrat , 112,703 ; Swift , repub lican , lUil3Brltzins : ; , socialist-labor. 1.517 ; Wakoly , peoplo's-silver. ! IG7 ; total. 'J .S'J" ' . The vote , which was ono of the heaviest ever polled in the city , shows a decided republican gain. The democracy carried the city by IIO.OOO in the last presidential election ami in the county election last month sev eral of the democratic candidates had ma jorities of 4,000 in thu city , which wore only overcome by the republican vote in the county. The weather was all Hint could bo desired , and the full vote of both parlies was polled , In several of the downtown waids. where the heavy lodgitig house vote resides , the contest was very hitler and "scraps" were of Ircijucut occurrence when the police were not on hand. In all other parts of the city Iho vollng progressed without incident. The Jury in Iho Coushlin case did not vole. The jury in ihe Prcndergast trial fared a little better. Such members as cared to vote were allowed to do so , being accom panied to the polls by a bailiff. Seven of them voted , the remainder being kept at iho hotel. Tonlsht the democrats are jubilant over their victory , while the republicans are con soling themselves with iho substantial gains inndo over the last two elections und declare the city U theirs the next time. Xn\v Smmtors. HICIIMONII , Va. , Dec. 10 In the legisla ture today General Eppa ilunton was elected United States senator for the short term and Thomas M. Martin for thu long term. KIU.Kl ) Jll' 2'lt.tl.KUllllEltS. . Kxprcss Mennrnfjcr ItlcliuriUon ot New Orlenni Murdered In Cold ISIooil , Nr.w Om.KAXn , Dec. 1 ! ) . The name of the express messenger killed in the Southern Pacific -train robbery last night is John C. Richardson , id years old and married. who lives in Now Orlo.ins. From what little can bo learned , It Is apparent that the train porter on going into the car found lilchardson dead. The impression is that the robbers wanted him lo open Iho through sufo and upon his failure to comply ho was shot. The sheriff's possq which started in pur suit of the Southern I'acillo train robbers last night returned about noon today , after scouring the country between hero and Sheldon , sixteen miles away. The best In formation at hand Is that Hlchardson WIIH murdered and thn express car robbed be tween this city und Green's Dayou , the llrst station east of Houston , Two men were evi dently concerned In the affair. They loft the train when It took the siding at Green's Bayon nnd are believed to be In this city. They are not thought to have got much plunder. KOKTTlfiU J.V COIWT , rinnklntoii Hunk Cu hler' Trlnl Ilejjliis with Argument * AlMlint tliu .luilKC. MII.WAUKEU , Dec. It ) . Tno case of Castilcr ICoottimr of the wrecked Southsldo bank was called In the municipal court this morn ing. A largo crowd was In ullcndanco. Cir cuit Judge Clomentson of Grant county pre sides. Ho was called to tno case by Judge Walker , who was sworn away on the ground of prejudice. The attorneys for the defense huvo consumed the en nro day In argument * tending to disqualify Judiro Clcmcntson on the groand lhai Judge Wulbor was not le gally privileged lo call u circuit judge lo lake his place. Sccuri'il a halUfaclory Settlement. Xieuviu.u , Tonn. , Doc. 19. Comptroller Harris and Attorney General Pickle have finally secured an agreement or settlement will ) the Tennessee Coal , Iron and Railroad company that is satisfactory to the state ofllcluls. The company , which leases the state penitentiary , had fallen more than n year behind in the Icasu money and alto. t'other about (175,000 was Involved. Under the terms of tlio agreement the lessees are to pay | 75,000In cash , como down promptly on January 1 with the lease money due tncn , * i\000 , and pay tflKH ( ) additional during the coining year , besides moctinc the usual rental. j.iiLii > nut Seimntlonnl Drurlopmrnt * In tli Irxlno Ulrorrn Hull Ht Silt : l.nKr. SALT T.\KE , Doc. 111. ( Special Telegram to Tun HUE. ] In the Irvine divorce case today the clerk of the draco hotel , CMucago , testi fied that Mrs. Irvlno had registered nl Iho hotel under the name of MM. K. II. Miller , representing herself ns the sister of Mont- gomury and shn and Montgomery Insisted on occupying adjoining rooms , Kiy Cameron , keeper of a Lincoln house of Ill-fame , testified that she had seen Mrs. Irvlno often In the room of Montgomery in Lincoln without coat or hat and sue hnil partaken of wlno there. The witness had oeen her at the room with another man. She refused to give iho naino of ihe other man , who she snld is about 50 years old , and is now In Jail for her refusal. Irvine , the plaintiff , was put on the stand In the afternoon and told his slory. Several limes when referring- the scenes with his wife ho broke down completely ami sobbed for sovcral minutes. Ho said that his llrst suspicion of his wife's Inlldcllly was occa sioned by n talk with Mrs. Austin , who said Addio had done wrong i'i ' Chicago. Ho telegraphed to his wife nnd received nn answer saying she had stopped nl tlio Grand Pacific hotel. Ho found that her ntiinu was not on the register , and askcJ her to meet him at the Wellington hotel. At the meeting she con fessed that she and MonUomery had stopped at the Grace hotel in Chicago as brother and sister , in adjoining rooms , and that Montgomery visited bur several times during the afternoon and Rvonlmr. The witness said that HUlo Flossie had protested ncalnst the presence of Mont gomery in the room and had made such > i fuss that her mother was compelled lo lake her homo Ihe next day. On cross-examination he ndmiltcd that his wife had protested to him during the con versation at the \Vollinirton hotel lhat she was not guilty of anything criminal in her relations with Montgomery. As to the binrpy rides and other matters supposedly happening in Lincoln not much was adduced. The plaintiff testttlou to efforts made by Mrs. Irvine's mother to have him take her back nnd said ho was assured Addle would r.ot do wrong again. The coircspondcncc between Irvlno nnd his wife through the medium of Flossie was brought forward for the purpose of showing lhat ho endeavored to got a confession lo clear himself. .iL. Wltuctics for tlio Doroimn Claim that the Munlprnr Is Iiiouiif. CHICAGO , Don. 10. The rnembars of Iho jury in the Prcndergast case today wcro taken out by bailiffs und allowed lo vole on a successor lo the man for whoso murder they were trying the prisoner. Then the court was convened and Dr. DJWC.V , ono of the witnesses who had boon culled by the state , was put on the stand by the defense. Ho testified that the prisoner appeared to bo insane. During the examination Prendergast created ' ated a'sensation by excited objections to questions put by Ihe attorneys for the de fense. A bailiff took his arm to force him into his scat , when tlio prisoner tore loose from the oftlcer's grasp and , quivering with rage , screamed i " .Let go ot me ; my life is at stake hero. They are going to prejudice the jury' " Ifo was llnally quieted and thu examination proceeded. ' Dr.- Dewey proved a poor witness for 'the defense and staled th'nt in his opinion Prcn- dcrgastUnow thedlfforenco 'between right and'wrong nt the time of the murder. Dr. W. L. Bain testified that ho thought the prisoner insane , und stated that hit bollcvcd Prendergast thought ho was doint right when he committed the crime. Dr. F. H. "Wall , nssistanlcounty physician , nlso tcsliticd lhat in his opinion Ihc prisoner was insane when he did iho shooting. William H. Wcston , ca liier of the Unity building , wliii-h is owned by Governor Alt- geld , testified thai on iho afternoon of Uio day Mayor Harrison wtis killed. Prcnder gast CAlled loses Governor Altgcld , hut was refused permission by the witness , who did not like the general appearance nf the caller. Several men employed on different papers with which Prendergast hud business deal ings were called for the prosecution and tes tified they considered him s.ine. The de fense gained a possible point when thu jury was allowed to separate for the purpose c-f allowing several of Us members to voto. as the jury law directs that tint jury sh.ill bo kept together. IIVI.1 G'M.S// * . Olympli Would Hitve IJrru n l.oin lo tier ISnltilnrM Hut for Ilfi' llonim. SAX I'IIAXCISCO , Dec. 1'J. An ofllcial of the Union Iron works , in an interview , states tliat up to the lima Uio now cruiser Olympia left port on the llrst attempt at a trial rim the cruiser had cost the builders Jl00 : ; above the contract price , fI,79iiOUi , ) , and tliero still remained over SUM.OOO for the contractors to ovnund for furniture , deck- smoothing , mounting turrets and guns and giving final touches. Then , too , the break in the center pump bolt on thu llrst ofllcial trip caused an expenditure of ? . " > 0K)0 ( ) moro by the builders , as Iho Kovcrnmonl pays the expenses only of tliu trial on which accept ance Is based. The builders now estimate , however , that the cruiser's remarkable speed In excess of Ihoconlr.ict require men Is has won a premium of probably * 400,0M ( ) , so Itint there will really bo a handsome profit. Ktl.Ll.fll . > 0 MU Milt ItnvU lol aiuil on tlio Jury Finding HlH Dooil , IHHiHUIlr. ST. Louis , DJC. 19 , A special to the Post Dispatch from liristol , Tonn. . nays lhat al ihe inquest on Ihu bodies of Waller Shannon and Mrs. Ann D.ivis , fouir.l murdered In bed veslnrdav. Arit Davis , husband of the womnn , ncknowlcdi : > id that he kilted them and tlio jury juslillcd Dim under ihe circum stances in so doing , und he wax released. ° H.tfiU .l Ul./t i..l.srXH. . " American I'rilurntlon uf l. lior Acljnmin In Mcrt .Vnvt at Drnvor. CHICAGO , Doc. 19.--Tim American Federa tion of L-ibor delegates mot today and after disposing of routlno business and giving votes ol thanks to various individuals ami niyaiil/.iitlons thuy bani'Aula ; Ling S.vnct" nnd ndjournoil slno die. The next meeting will be held at Denver. s Ilium No Compromise. , Den. 19 , EJward A. Davis , the eldest , son of John A. Davis , denies in Its en tirety Iho roporlod HOtllemcnt of Ihu Jll- 000,000 will contest. Edward Davis says : "The story or a compromise uot\vien inn heirs of my father's ustato is a misstate- muni , pure nnd simple , On Iho contrary , ! declared the negotiations off last August and have done nolhln : . ' about it since , f nt- tribute thu statements about compromise to my brother , George Q , Davis , whom my father and I disowned ton yoir ; * airo Ho has c'ookud up this story for tliu sole pur pose of gelling Ills name In ihcnuv.-ftpapora , " Si'nisoni'.i.n , III. , Dec. 19. State Auditor Gore of Illinois states that the a&sots of the American DuIIding , Loan and Investment society of Chicago have been Impaired $200 , . 000 bv mismanagement und by reason of a conspiracy entered into by ofllcors of the laid company and debtor * thereof , p.nd according to law sent copioi of advertise ments to that effect to Chicago to bs adver tised In the papers. Accepted IIU Itiiilt-iuilloii , NEW YOIIK , Dec. 12. The Now York pres bytery has formally accepted the ruslgna lion of liov. Dr. Paxton , pastor of the West churcti. Movement * < > HciiiSieainur4 , Urremtirr 11) ) , At New York Arrived Auiuuia , from ON THE ICTHEROY. Rumen of Disssmious Among the Crew o ( . that Famous Slcnuicr. CAPTAIN BAKER REMOVED FROM COMMAND Hh Pia o Tnkou by Gnp.tn.5a Nunca of tb ( Brazilian Nnvy. NOT LIKED Q'f THE AMERICAN SCM1EN Many of Thm : Refuse tj Rc-Eulist Becausa of the Olituigo of Commanders. AFFAIRS ON BDARD OF THE AMERICA _ _ _ \ She Him Arrived Sitrly : nt Miirinmliu 11111 ' wall HIT Consort , Will Soon Ho 1'viiily to Ilo Some Artlto i , ; RM , dy ( he .iMnctaltit rift ! . ] i PinsA\tnri'o : , Brurll , Ueo. ill. There lins been considerable change hero today. Cap tain Baker , who loft Xew York In command' of the N'lcthcroy , Is no longer In charge ot the new Brazilian cruiser. The olllccr In charge of her now Is Captain Xune/ , who was formerly In command of thu Brazilian warship liepubllca , and who U onu of the few naval oftlccrs who remained loyal to President Peixolo. This causes u great disappointment to tha American portion of the crow of the Niethu- roy and has had u had Inlluenco on thoiu. who were Inclined to continue- the strike for an increase of wages upon regularly entering the Brazilian navy. Will itolnrii llomn , The fact that Captain Nunez has assumed command of the Mcthcro.v has caused many of thu Americans vho were still hesitating as to whether they would or would not enter the Brazilian navy at the samur.iteof wagea as agreed upon at Xew York to decide upon returning to the United Slates. They werq perfectly willing to light under Captain Baker , but they HIM not so willing undcD Captain Nunez. It is understood that stronsr inducement ! are being held out to Captain Baker to servo ns second in command , but the result is not known as thH dispatch U sent. It seems that the majority of the gun crows , which nave been so successfully trained slnco leaving Now York , will bo prevailed upon to remain with the Nlothuroy , us it seems to ba admitted on all sid.-s that it would bo ut terly impossible lo sccnro Brazilians who could man the r.ipld-tlto guns , to say noth ing'of the dynamite ( /mi , with anything likv ttio ofiioiency displayed by the Amcric.m crows. But , as Uii'nn Inj'.c no-.v. It app ar Hlccly that , Uiu ( Iromun uiui stokjr.s as well as i ( number o.f ab.lo syiiiuu and orJinAUM seamen from Nuw York will bo replaced by men of other nationalities who can ba picked up at this or other points. All U'rll nil ( lit ! America. The second iiieco of important news which the Associated piMss correspondent on board the Isictberoy has Just received is to the effect that , her consort 'tho' America has arrived safely at Maratuho , the largest , town and seaport of the state of Maranalio , in tiio northern portion of Brazil. Wo hour briefly that all Is well on board the America , but wo have no particulars regarding the acci dent which happened to her. The Kcner.il opinion exnressod hero is that the accident/ In the engine room of the America was simply the ordinary disabling of one of the air pumps and It is not believed that thcro is any truth in the stories about the liruzll- iaa insurgent agents being on board ol her or that anybody willfully did any damage to the machinery. * * However , everybody is anxiously awaiting1 the arrival of the America which Is expected tomorrow , nnd it Is announced that the two vessels will almost immodliitely aftorw.mlH sail for Bnlii.i , or snmo other port to tno south of us , when ) HIM two cruisers expect. to rccci\o dctinilo orders as lo their futuru movements. It is currently reported hero thai Admiral do Mcllo is ns well informed concerning thu movembtits of thu Nictheroy and America aa is President Peixolo. Trouble on thn Nletlinriiy. Just as 1 close this dispatch 1 hear a rumor lhat there la troublu among Ihe crow of iho X'othoroy. ' Should thU ho iho case Ihero may Do some further delay in thu de parture of the iwo cruisers southward , but wo still expccl lo see the America tomorrow or the ncn day at latest , aim wo shall feel much more confident of auccesa when out' consort Is a1 anchor near us. Throughout yesterday wo were taking on provisions. , water and coal , of a character apparently very much inferior to thut which wo shipped In Now York. In any case wo expect to ho ready to sail southward an soon an our con- son. the America , Is ready to proceed with us. As 1 have already cabled you , nil Is ijulot hero and not much is known concerning the situation of affairs nt ICio do .lanulro. I liavo been unoftlchilly Informed that U would ho advisable for me. to abstain from touching upon iho political afr.iir.-t of Brazil , but I do not ihink 1 am Inciirrm tliu Hunger of hav ing my dispatches suppressed when I ay that what little now.s lias reached hero seems to Indicate lhil : i'resldonl Pclxoto has had some successes of nn Important na ture. nnd thut ho expects his cause will eventually triumph. The people linreabouta buum sumowlm concerned as to the result. fought Ainillior News was roccivcd hut night that a oral ( ingiigwuanl betwoijn the rebel i > lil.3 | . and tno rubol forts : is begun Monday u-jrn- ; ing in the hirlwof KIo de .Innciro. The tight on both oldos is ! > : iM to have boon so- vnro , and the result of the engagement 1 not Known : is this uulno is scut. Dispatches rouoivoj hnro from Illo do . ( autilro tuluy also say that ( 'onnimndcr I'ielilm : , tlu < sonliir naval nfilcur of thu United State * ships at HU , has announced to thu merchants and Khij ) captains thcro that hndcifllnoi to ira.iraiHou i lie safety of the anchoiMKO asud by merchant vcfu-lH iiotr fordlschai jing and unlu.idlg : : cargoo * into Ughtent , A repoot lias gained circulation hero that President Pelioto and his government an > iienrly bankrupt ami that the financial strain thai ho anil his friends are subject to cani'Ot ' ondiire ni'U'li longor. This rumot * may have Us origin In Insurgent source ? , nnd i > i given for what it is worth. All cables to and from ttio south have been stopped by orJevj of thu ollldals hero oral KIo dc. Janeiro ui'J : ' the utmost anxiety Is expressed ns to the result of Uio ballln now going on belwoon t'lo Insurgunl und govurn- force * . ( 'upiuln Nillirx | n Commanil , I.atc to tuv Cantata Nunez , the new com * min < loroj the Kk'lheroy , shipped mty novr mcu and cent several of tb hw.v York crevr ,