Omaha daily bee. (Omaha [Neb.]) 187?-1922, June 16, 1885, Image 4
DAILY BEE. OMAHA Qrnca No. 014 AND 016 FAHNAU ST. NRW YORK Orrioi , Koou G5 TBIBDNI BUILD- 1SNO. erery mornlrg , except Runday. Tha only Monday morning dalljr yubllihM Inlh - elite. l TRUS tr MAit > Ont Yc . . , . , , , . , . ; aM IThrte Monthi t SM 'KlxJIonlhj ' 6.00 | On Month 1.00 The Weekly Boo , Published every Wednesday naxs , rosrMiD. OnoYekr , with premium. . . . I t CO On Y r , without premium. , , . . , . 1 S * nix Months , without premium V * On * Month , on trt t , 10 CORBUrOXDI.fCI i All Communlfitloni relating to N wj nd EJIlorIM mitten should tx iddrcued to the Emtot or mi IJM. iroswm Lirmu. All Duilneu Letter * and Itemlttancet ihould ha uldrctsed to Tni DKI roBUimxd CourAirr , OHAIII. prtftt.Checki and Port offloocrdtn to U nude pay * ixble to the order of the company. THE BEE PUBLISHING CO , , Props , E. R03EWATER , Enron. A. IT. Fitch , Manager Daily Circulation , I * . O. Box , 488 Onuhn , Nab. TIJ.B probability la that Freddy's anil ngninst Mr. James Orolghton will prove a rale fit. KEEP it before the city council thai the oldowalka of Omnhi ore a dlsgrficolo n well-p vod city , IK Gladatono had taken moro to budge , and lots to budget , ho might not have boon consigned to his political bior. ' ' OMAHA is ahead of Kansas Olty in the f matter of manufacture * , bnt there is a f great deal of room for improvement in * this respect. 11 THE Pokin treaty hns bean ratified. The frog-oators of Franco and the rat- cntora of China can now shako hands and swap dishes. Tun fact that democratic editors nro to bo specially favored frith federal pat ronage , is raptdly producing an abnndant crop of democratic papers In Nebraska. THE French admiral , Ocnrbot , who nmashed considerable Ohinavraro during the recent unpleasantness , has surren dered to the conqueror of all men. Ho dlodon board of his ship , his death being caused by prostration from ovcrrrork and mental anxiety. AMONG the witnesses named by Sena tor Mandorson to appear before the inter- atato commerce committee In Omaha next week , arc the members of the Nebraska railway commission. The cammltteo will noir find out what a railway commission does not know about railways. THE Iron workers nro making headway elowly bnt severely in their effort to In duce the mill owners to accede to their acnlo. The latest aignaturo to the scale la that of Oliver Brothers & Phillips , in Plttsburg , employing 3000 men , who ro snmed work to-day. A conference is to bo hold on Tnosday , and it is believed that within fonr or five days all the mllla will bo running aiain. TIIE sanato committee on commerce will reach Omaha next Monday or Tnes day , and hold a session hero for the pur pose of investigating the management of railways and ascertaining the views of business men and shippers generally con- ; corning their relations to public carriers , 1 : - > and the necessity of legislation by con gress to regulate railway traffic , and to | ; encourage the improvement of the wat < ways. Senator Onllom , chairman of this sub-committee , has requested Senator ' Mandorsan to furnish to the committee the names of prominent parties who would bo likely to afford the desired in formation. The committee has already hold sessions in Now York , Boston , Philadelphia and Chicago. It will prob v ably find Omaha ai good a field for in formation as any it has so ia visited. MAYOR BOYD , In his Chicago Inter view , told a reporter that the Omaha gambling houses are fined $30 a month , the fine operating as a kind of license ; that the number of houeea had been reduced ducod to five slnoo ho became mayor , and that they are kept under strict survoll- jj ; lance. The fact is that slnco Mr. Bojd I' became mayor there has been bnt ono house cloned , and that was ono In which a brace game was being rnn. That ia all the reduction that has been made in the number of gambling houses in this city , and no stricter surveillance is kept over them now th&n there has boon hereto fore. The fine that is Impotod upon them , if Mayor Boyd considers it in the light of a llaouBo carrying with It u sort of protection , is entirely too small. So long aa gambling houses are permitted to run in this city the fines Imposed should bo made much heavier than they now are. THE moss-backs and obstructionists are etlll growling about reckless outlays of money for public Improvements , If it had not been for the expenditure of about ono million dollars In paving , grading and sewerage last year , Omaha wonld have almost collapsed , but as it turned out this oily weathered the terrible de pression and in the most trying crisis ehot ahead of all other western towns. To atop now would simply bo suicidal. Wo want moro pavements and more sewers , and wo want to filvo employment to workingmen In leveling the hills and filling the gulleys. Wo want to spend as much money In brick , mortar and utono as wo can conveniently raise under our restrictive charier. Omaha can be made a city of one hundred then- sand people by 1890 , every foot of real estate can bo tripled in value , if wo pursue a policy of enterprise and public spirit. Wo must bridge over ( ho hard times by pushing ahead every nterpriso that we can safely carry , Wo want to exhibit to all comers on abiding confidence in ocr future greatness. Lst iho croakera and mots-backa howl. This la a live city. I OMAHA AS A LIVE STOCK MARKET Some interesting figures , relating to cattle shipments from various parts of Nebraska direct to Chicago , are furnished us by a correspondent writing from Crete. According to hia statement 300 cars of corn-fed cattle were shipped from Crete to Chicago over the Burlington road during the month of April , SCO cars during the month of May , and 100 so far this month. It Is estimated that since January 1st 1,000 cara of live stock have been forwarded from Crete , the valno footing up to about one million dollars , Thesa are figures for the bnst- notfl men of Omaha , and particularly for thosa interested in our sleek yards and slaughter houses , to carefully study. Why should all these cattle along the line of the B. & M. bo permitted to go direct to Chicago , as well as those along the Nebraska lines of the Chicago & Northwestern ? Is It not evident that the Burlington and the Northwestern are do * ing everything in their power to discrim inate ngninst Omaha simply In order to got the long haul ? It is certainly high tlmo that some stops l > a taken to put an end to a discrimination that Is not only unjust but seriously damaging to ono of the most imriorrant Interests of this city. The products of Nebraska that naturally should como to thla city will contlnuo to bo hauled direct to Chicago unless our business men take oomo decisive action cither by a vigorous protest , or building local lines of railways , terminating at this point , and acting aa feeders from the beat Eoctlons of the state , Ono of the first steps to bo taken Is for our business men and shippers to patronlzo only those roads that are not inimical to our inter- cstj. This should bo followed by some action towards building a local road to northern and northwestern Nebraska. There Is no doubt that such a road would not only pay , but It would put an end to the discriminations of the Northwestern. A road to the south nnd southwest would have a nlmllar e fleet upon the Burlington. It would aaem that Omaha Is now of eufQclcnt Import ance to command fair treatment at the hauda of the railroads , but if It cannot bo obtained In any other way then it can bo secured by the building of such roads as wo have suggested. Such enterprises would , of course , involve the Investment of considerable capital at first , bub that would in the near future return a profit able Interest. Wo believe that acch enterprises on the part of Omaha would bo substantially endorsed and aided by tie- people of this atato who must naturally take pride In the metropolis of Nebraska , which , with properly di rooted efforts , is destined to become at no distant day , ono of the great cltios of thla continent. Meantime , the live stock buyers and shippers of Omaha should offer ovcry inducement to the producers to ship to this city , which now possess commodious dockyards , an extensive baef slaughtering establish ment , and large pork packing houses , all of which are contributing to the building up of a market In which prices are of fered that are equal to those of Chi cago. It should bo remembered that by shipping to Omaha and soiling here the haul of 500 miles to Chicago Is avoided , resulting In a great swing in the weight of animals. That Omaha will become como a great livestock market if the proper facilities aro'offorded there can bo no question , and that her fnture greatness depends largely upon her be coming such a market ia a fact that no ono will dispute. No time , therefore , should bo lost in shaping matters with view of making the eutiro state tributary to this city. THE CROW CREEK FRAUDS. Secretary Lamar , who fs engaged in Investigating frauds relative to the Crow Crcok reservation , has already been re warded with some rather startling dlscov- orlce. It had been suspected that per sona connected with the interior depart ment were In collusion with outsider * , and suiliclent ovldcnco has been obtained to confirm the cusplcion. The fraudulent methods practiced in obtaining locations by speculators BO as to defeat the honcot settler out cf a fair show In selecting lauds is thus described in a apodal Waehington dispatch to the St. Louis Globe-Demo crat : Last February a lank president at Cham- berllu , D , T. , went to the land offioi at Mitchell nnd aald that he had received from Washington advance Information of tbo opening - ing of the reservation , and that an order di rotting It was then awaiting Fxesident Arthur's signature , and that It would bo pro mulgated tbo following week. He wanted to know from the register how to obtain certain valuable lands adjacent in the town under such an order , but the register refused to give him any information , At the eamo time a party composed of a rail road attorney and certain government em ploy es , ono of n horn was discharged to-day , started west and arrived at Mitchell In due tlmo. The attorney Bought the regiiter and unfolded a plan for taking advantage of the expected order of President Arthur. The register denounced this scheme and would do nothing to help It on. Finally the Washing ton patty , acting on telegraphic Informa tion , offered a lot of securities and scrip for certain lauds , but the register rejected their entiles. The next day the news that tbo president had signed the order was publicly announced , Tha Crow Creek order took effect immediately , but under the NIobrara and Santee order , issued at the same time , patties were given thirty days to make a bona fide residence. Ic will bo foen th&t the dill'orenco in time gftvu those operating in advance through iquatteia the advantage over honest settlers , Other developments are expected at the interior department in connection with thla operation. The tame ring , it ii said , id now trying to get possession cf the locil land cilice having jurisdiction of thoto grants , but now that its plans are known the probability Is that It will not succeed. Whatever else may bj said about Secretary Lamar , It h but filr to ray that up to the present time ho hai conducted the affairs of hii department in a businesslike , honest aud impartial manner. It is probable his Intention to weed out all the fraudulent * , land-grabbers on the Crow Creek reservation , BO that justice may be done to the honest settlers tlors , President Cleveland has mean time riitually suspended his' order com manding the settlers to vacate , this step no doubt being taken to glvo Secretary Lamar tlmo to fully investigate the Crow Creek difficulty , so that when congress moots the matter can be intelligently and satisfactorily acted upon. THE OHIO CAMPAIGN. In the nomination of Jndgo Forakcr the republicans of Ohio think that they have pnt forward the strongest and most available man that they could have se lected as a candidate for governor. His nomination on the first ballot Is an indi cation of confidence in his ability to draw the full party vote. The fact that ho was defeated two yoara ago by Hoad- ly has not weakened htm in the least In the estimation of his supporters , who will strain ovcry nerro to elect him. The republicans in this campaign start out with some advantage in their favor owing to the annullmont of the Scott liquor law , from which the state derived an annual income of over $2,000,000. This law , which had been pntsad by n republican legislature , nnd which was proving satisfactory to the mass of the tax-paying people whoso burdens It materially lightened , was declared un constitutional by the supreme court , and the responsibility for bringing nbout such a result haa boon shouldered upon the democrats. The defeat of the Scott law will probably figure largely In the cam paign in favor of the republicans in splto of any representation ! ] that may bo made by the democrats. In a presidential year Ohio can bo counted upon as n republi can state , but in an oil-year it is an liable to go ono way on the ether , &a the local Issues are brought to bear in every pojsl- bio manner. It Is asserted that there are now no factional divisions In the parly in Ohio , which la Indeed a fortunate condi tion of affalra. This Is berne out by the unanimity of feeling displayed In the state convention , whilj the earnestness exhibited in the platform planks Is evi dence of a determined spirit to make a meat vigorous fight for the principles of republicanism and loyalty. It baa already boon called a bloody shirt platform , but perhaps the waving of the bloody shirt in Ohio at this time will cvisa moro en thusiasm and unitad action in the repub lican ranks than could bo created in any other way. DURING the trial of Olaus Spreckles for shooting M. H. De Young , of the San Francleco Chronicle , the defendant's counsel endeavored to make a point upon the fact that the Chronicle had republished - published an editorial from a Chicago paper relating to the case , and ho tried to make it appear that It was a contempt of court. The judge , however , did not sustain him , but simply cautioned the jury not to read articles bearing on the case. Thereupon an honest juryman admitted that ho read the dally papers , This naturally created some- surprise , as a not generally the case that news paper readers are allowed to act as jury men in this Intelligent ago. Now thht it has been proven by the Kansas City Timea that ono of the most eminent ministers in that city was once a burglar , there is como encouragement oven for Frank James. The Kansas city minister admits the charge , but cays that ho called upon a bishop and asked him if hia crime would be a bar to his entering the min istry if he was thoroughly repentant , and was told it would not. This Is a hint to Mr. James. IF Charles A. Dtna'a recent article on Abraham Lincoln had been signed anonymously It would have attracted little or no attention. It Is clumsily constructed , and Is not by any moons equal to what people wonld expect from the editor of the un. Mr. Dana , like many an old actor who has eozn his best days , ia evidently living on his pant reputation. \ { SEOUETARY BAYARD soya that during his recent weetorn trip ho endeavored wholly to banish partisan politics , and that hia tour was olmply a visit to the educational centers of the west. As the secretary is now making explanations wo would like to know , in the face of this statement , how ho came to overlook the city of Lincoln and the Nebraska state university ] THE city of St , Lonls cares not a straw how many of her eminent democrats got loft in regard to cilices If she can aocuro the ftst mail. St. Lonls will never bo happy until she Is given better mail facilities and put on an equal /acting with Chicago. She proposes to leave no stone unturned or ncive unstrained In her effort to bring about such a result. Miss CLEVJ LAND has an eye to bnii ness , and knows a good opportunity whoa aho sees it. Her book , it la predicted , will reach a sale of 50,000 copies. If her brother were not the president of this great American republic , her work would probably not have a sale of over 500. THE mcdlcil colleges , like all other educational Institutions , are now turning out ohcopaklns by tbo wholetalo , The overproduction of doctors could readily bo dlipoeod of In Spain , josi about thi * time , A RUMOR was sot afloat a few days igo that a newspaper was to b- started in New York with acapital cf $1,000,000 for ( ho eiprets purpose of crushing the Her ald and World. Such a papoc might prove & EUCCOIS within Itself , but as n crusher of oldcstabllthed journals It would prove a failure , no matter how much capital it might have at its back. TIIE government entomologist haa given a list Of the localities which the locust Is likely to vlalt thla season. Wo are happy to see that no olaco in Nebraska ia men tioned in it. GENERAL JAMES S , Butsnix will teen be with us again. Ho ban been ordcrd to rejoin his regiment , the Second cav alry , In thla department. llMhvny Gossip. The following Items , culled from the Omabn correspondence of the Des Moinei Hallway Times , will ba found of interest to local train men : "Business on the line IB not very rushing , but there nro GO many of them laying off that nil the extra conductors have been rnnmng. nnd "Set-end Conductors" Catton. Miller nml Leonard promoted to extra conductors , Of course you know what ft "second conductor" is. As I heard It told once , the first conduc tor starts the train , and the "second cunduc tor" stopi it , Conductor llogerr , of tbo Lincoln pnsscn ger , haa gone out on a six weeks' visit. Con ductor George Gordon Is running for him , Passenger Conductor llosa' little girl , abou three months old , mot with n sad incident. The nurse girl had her out ia her little car riage nnd went to puin the top up , when Mils baby got her little firmer in Uio gearing and cut it off at the fmt joint. While Hots was off , Conductor Frank Kushon wora thi blue clothes and gold bands. Conductor M. Farrell , who 1ms tfoen hav ing n tumor taken off his neck and h&s no ! been running for ( ho post three months , hat resumed business ngain us good M now. Goorpo Miller , our dude conductor , ( but fine n boy as over totm a way car , ) is out with thn signal tram putting up tbo now train order elgnalt , Conductor Morohomo is off on n pleasun trip , and that prince of good fellows , Kber II Smith , batter kcown as Smithy , ia ofliclattug with the punch and bell-cord in hia absence , Too O'liyrne is running Btnlth'fl crew on tin Columbus local , If you want to know a dandy , right up-and > up fallow and n first cla > s railroad man , get acquainted with Joe The old reliable "Old Man Perrigo" Is run ning Gortlon'd crew on the other local , Koboit Lumpklne. one of the oldest men In the Omaha yard , end fireman of engine 010 , has taken n sixty days' leave of absence ti visit Mexico' " < liilclrcn's Pay , Children's day was was very npproprl atoly observed at the So ward street M , E. church Sunday. In the morning the pastor preached a children's sermon from the text , "And let the beauty o ; the Lord our God bo upon us. " Severa' ' lossona were taught by objects. Two flowefa were exhibited ono a beautiful well developed fuschla , the other f ided crushed ono , and an application made to character. Aho a rose was ahown , the beauty and life of which bad been con aumed by a worm , hidden among the loaves. Near the oloaj of the dli ODUKO two hearts were ehown , ono pure ana white , the other discolored with stains , to illustrate the natural heart and one purlfiud by grace. The church was crowded to its utmost capacity in the evening , and many could not find sojxts. The children's concert was carried out successfully and to the delight of the andlcneo , although the programme was curtailed somewhat , because - cause of the storm which coemcd immi neut. The church was beautifully decorated with plants and cut flowers , which wore arranged with unusually good taste and effect. Several singing birds added to the joyonsness of the day. The cer vices will bo long remembered by the Sabbath school children. Gen. HtrntiRo'd Adversary. Big Bear Is a plain Oreo , a native of the Oarloton region , and about sixty years of ago , says the Toronto Mall. He Is of short alaturo , thin and old looking His appearance Is anything bnt impres slvo. Ho speaks with a loud voice , but Is short of breath , and is not an orator by any moans. About twenty years ago ho removed from Carleton to Pitt , and became the head man of a small band of his relatives wno resided at Pitt , num bering about twelve tents or perhaps twenty men. Ho never Ti as recognized as a chief until after treaty six was made and ho removed to Cyprcai hill ; . At Fort Pitt be was frequently employed by the Hudson Biy company as a buffalo hunter , and ho had the reputation of being a good Indian. His bind , howovcr , wore generally raicals , thn greatest being his nephew named Little Poplar. During a famine which occurred thirteen years ago , caused by the buffalo leaving for the south and the Indians being unable to follow them , they began to kill the H B. cattb , but wore prevented from con tinuing the practice through , the efforts of Big Bear. Ho nnd his band seldom engaged In war , bnt they were notorious for etualing horses from the Blackfeot. Ho waa thought to bo rather cor/ardly. On one occasion four Crcos were a ! ticked nppoeito Fort Pitt by a largo band of Blackfoot , while Big Bear wes in the fort with eight men. Ho refused to go to their assistance. The four Croes , however , succeeding In cscsplng , On several other oos&sloDB his actions showed that his courage woo not of the highest order. At the making of treaty No. G , In 1875 , Big Bear refused to tc- ccpt thn terms offered to and ac cepted by the rest. Ho wanted to see first how the promises made by tbo gov ernment would be carried out , PendIng < Ing a decision ho removed to Cypress hills , whore ho remained for alx or seven yeors , gathering a larger number of dis contented spirits t round him each year. Between frequent spats with the Black- feet and excursions Into the states , his men became much moro export than formerly morly in the art of-jvrar , and ho came to bo looked upon aa a big chief , equsl In importance to Ple-a-pot. At last circumstances , in the shape of few buffalo and many United Statoj troops , coupled with profuse premises from the Indian department , Induced Bit : Bear to return to hfaoldstamping ground near Pitt eoruo two yean ago. Although ho took treaty money he refused to go oo a reserve , always having an tscuoo roidjr , During the winter before last ho freighted ono trip from Pitt to Edmonton , He alwaja kept moving about , and foment lag discontent wherever ho went , which the management of the Indian depart ment made easy , especially among the Fort Pitt Indians , who never had a gooa reputation , and of whom ho seems to have secured control. IlarrJgau I'miiilncs to Keforin , 8r. Louis , Mo , , June 1C. It appears that the violation of rules of the polios dcpatt- ment of which Chief of Police llarrfgau wa > Saturday nislit found guilty by the board oi pollen commissioners WBJ purely tech nlcal , as tlie chiei retains the § 10 in question with the sanction of the 'ex ecutive officer of the then fritting board , anr in accordance , as the chief alleges , wllli * custom which has long { ire-railed CMU llarricen has been reinstated and iiai pledget himself to the strictest observance of all the 1 m'ej oftia department boteafter. AN APPEAL TO TRUTH. TiicCoDYinclDg Atoss of tbe M. Jam'csf , Savage to the Jniy in me Libel Snit , Malioious Slano era"of " "Political Enemies Effectually Kofuted. ACnlnt , DlspntslotiAto Ilovlcw of the Testimony In the Case Iho Itccotil or a llusy Lllo In "Wnr and 1'onco. lion. J.V. . Savage said : May it please the court , Gentlemen of the jury ; When tbo court Adjourned last evening , you ware fresh from the enjoyment of ono of the most elo quent speeches I hAve over had the good for tune to listen to. That it had nothing to do with the cnio is a matter of minor importance. It was an admirableaddresi , I have hoard nothing but compliments of it since I left the court room yesterday aud I feel nothing but Rratlttulo towards n man who can excite my admiration ns Mr. Thurston does , I may say that If It were not for nn occasional nasal twang in his volco which I think ho must have learned at eomo camp meeting during his youth , I ihould consider him the finest orate that has over appeared in this etato , Ihnvoti follow him ns best I can , To mo those grace. of oratory nnd beauties of expression are un fortunately denied ; but if I had them ; if were able to appeal to ycur prejudices as my friend did , I would not do it , It was hli cue to do it. On hia side of the case if I had possessed that power I would linv exercised it. But I choose In my argument t confine myself simply to the evidence in tb caeo'nntt the law which bears upon it , I trus I thall not go beyond It. And if I , gcntlo men , on my part and you on yours confini ourselves to the pleadings nnd the testimony far the facts , nnd take the law from his honoi who sits upon the bench , I shall retire fron this court room with the consciousness tha icy client has succeeded in getting a verdict. It may eeem a truism nnd platitude to com rnonco an address to n jury In a causeof this character by saying that the love of countrj is Innate in every animate thing , nnd yet lion closely that consideration bears upon thi case. Every animal lovns iho homo where I. was reared , The domestic cat , driven from its habitation , will return miles In search cf it. Tbe cony , says Shakespeare , "dwells where eho is kindled , " and wo see the Enmo instinct in the dog , the cow nnd thelhorso. Hieing from these animals Into thi scale of human being ? , what do you sec. 32very man loving the country which gave him biith , the homo of bli boyhood aud the res'denco of his maturer years. The Irish man , obliged by oppression to leave tbo land which ho loves , may como to this country , but ho never forgets the green island which is washed by the warm and [ pleasant waters of the gulf stream. The Swiss soldlor , It ia said , carried into foreign lands , has Bomotimes been fotblddeu to listen to tbe songs which the herdsmen of the Alpine mountains sung , bo- caueo it excites Buchn longing for his moun tain home ns to produce disease. Prlsomrs have died of homesickness In foreign lands. The greatest of German poets , and ono of the greatest poets in the world , has expressed this feeling in a poem to plaintive and beautiful and touching that the strongest man can bardly read it without emotion. If we BO love our country then , gentlemen , with what horror do we Icok upon tbo man who can bo guilty of treason to the land that gave him birth. It is a crime which stands at the head of the calendar of crimes. Call n man thief , murderer , or villain as much ns you chooEo , but deny not his love for hia country. If you do , indignation starts In every heart. If the accusation Is believed it is indignation rgairst tbe traitor ; if it is not believed , it ; s indigna tion against the slanderer nnd libeler and fal sifier who gives birth to so Infamous n. charge. There Is no appellation so odious as that of n traitor , and if in the whole catalogue of moan epithets there is ono worse than "spy , " I beg to bo lemindcd of it. Spy and traitor ; two of tbo wont names that can be applied to a man. Spy and traitor ; traitor , tbe first and t licet ; spy the mcancet and lowest and most degrad ed ; and when n man is called by a responsible party "traitor and spy , " if ho bas never been n traitor , if ho haa never been a spy , if he Is an honorable and upright nran , every good citizen applauds him when ho cays I will take veng.'nca upon tbe man or the set of men who have foUoded this scheme upon my character. If ha is n ] aw-ablditg citizen , be comes be fore a jury of his countrymen nnd soya to them , "I am entitled to have nt your handa this cutrnre redrCBfed. I ojl ) on you to soy whether 1 have beau trailer n nnd a spy or not. " There cornea befoio you thi * nornlng , gen tlemen , n man who lias been the victim of inora abuse ; moro slander , moro hatred and mora venom than any other man in the state of Nebraska , I care- not who be ia or where he is ; nnd I will go one step further and nav that in this whole itate there la cot a man who deserves it less , At tha outbreak of tbo war the p'aintlff In this cction was a boy of nineteen or twenty years of age , dependent upon hia own personal exertions for his support. His early poverty had prevented hia acquiring any of tha higher brunches of education beyond those which were sufficient to make of him n competent telegraph operator , An such In 1859 ho sought tbo employment of a telegraph company. It wes tbon owned nnd In the bands of men part ly belonging to tbo northern toctlon of this country and partly to the southern , Secession bad not been declared , War had not yet oomo. TUOJO who were who enough could see tbe cloud no larger than a man's hind In tbo distance , but tbo great majority believed that it would pats away ; that tbero would be no war ; that wise counsel would prevail and that tbo efforts of the true lovers of their country would at hat provo successful , No body believed oven when Suinter waa fired upon that the war wss tfoiug to last any great length of time. Ono of the wicest statesmen that we had declared that ninety daya would jee the whole thing ceded , Secession found my client in the itato of Alabama , n state which seceded if hia recollection Is correct , in the mouth of December. 18G7 , and I pretnmo that was tha tlmo , To Mr. Kouewnter , boy aa he VIM , it eeeiced thut war waa Imminent between between some of tbe utatea and tbo general government , to lie determined to leave Alabama for Tennessee. Mr. Thuriton seems ts take preonal ofTenim at the fact timt bo did not leave at once for the north. Where wan the north J Who cpuld then tell what northern btates would bo ongueed , or what outbern states In this sontest ? It W B thought by many that the west would improve tbo opportunity to secede. It waa thought that tome great nation might lisa which nUhtboiouthorn confederacy wculd nlljr claim the wettanu sprntn over tno east nd malce new nation. Others laid that there would bo no secession at nil ; that hot headed Alabama , and vindictive South C.\r- ollnix might attempt to withdraw , bnt they wonld be btought into the union again by means such ni Jackion employed in 1832 , So It was difficult for Mr. Kosewnter to say where ho should go , but ho went Into n ttato which had refused to pass nny ordinance of secession , and ho adhered as you or I wonld have done to the employer who had given him his brood nnd batter. As n skilful nnd efficient operator lie devoted hlmtelf to the telegraph company ; ns a patriot ho adhered herod to the cnuso of his native land ; to the CSURO of the union ; and so openly that they called him an abolitionist , nnd the governor of Tonncaeo , threatened him and said that sen timents sucli ns ho was spreading abroad would not bo permitted , An operator In i Maryland oflico sent over the wires n tolo grnm "HcnraU for Lincoln nnd the Union. They said , "this won't do. Wo won't ha * such sentiments as that spread abroad In oui land ; you have got to keep your mouthoi shut , " nnd that operator was instantly dis charged from the service. Before Kosowat know It , before Tenncsco hndi gone out _ . the union Nashville was surrounded by robe soldiery , although moro than ons-lmlf of ho inhabitants were strong union men nnd I bo Hove n larger portion of them remained tinio until the close of the wnr. The homes northern Alabama and eastern Tonuesaavcr unionist ; , men only who took arms nm fought for the union , but the men also in thol homes remained peaceful If po alblo , awaiting events , hoping nnd prayln that the union might bq ro-optabhthcd , Who within the sound of my voice , tried to otcap during the war from the rebel prison at Sails bury nnd reach the union linca ? If there i ono who did It ho will remember how as h approached tbo borders of eastern Tennease or western North Carolina ho found &t cvcrj crossroads some Samaritan who would giv him food , drink and shelter , bind up bid lacer Mod feet and eend htm forward two or thrc or ten miles to tbo uext , union man , until nl last ho came in safety within our lines. Before fore Mr. llosewater know that wnr had como almost all of tlo state of Tennessee wa : surrounded. It was impossible- for him then to get out of it. Ho rcmainet up to the time of tbe riots continuing to per form bis duties as an honest , mnn , nnd ns nny man who , when bo makes a contract with nn employer , regards that contract aa a sacrc obligation , The riota in Nashville catno an be waa obliged to cease bis nctlvo service but waited until the stars nnd stripes ehoul appear in sight of the city of Nashville , There came n day when across the Cumber land liver they looked , and there flo&tod one mors tha flag of tbo nnlon , Tbcro xven troopa from the north , tjioro were tbe guard ! ana of the union. The troops of tbo eoutl bad departed , and Mr. Rosownter Immodt ately crossed the river and sought tbo cam ] of the commanding general. That this wni douo so scon , that ho oven took a ekiff nnd crossed tbe river nnd hurried when ho saw tbe old flag to bo once moro beneath the pro tection of its folds , is charged against him na nnj evidence of disloyalty. "Why , " aayajlMr. Thuraton , "ho Etartcd at once , bo could not wait , ho had to takea skill , " but how he could have got across that stream without n skill Mr. Thuraton does not inform us. Ho did take n skill , and If that ia against him , gentlemen , if you punish him because you think that he ought to bavo waited larger , because when he saw the flag which had last floated over him in Cleveland , Ohio , ho wanted to see it onca more and hastened to it , then wo must submit ; but you won't do it. I do not euro what your political sentiments are or have bosn. I don't cam whether you nre republicans or democrats , whether you were during the war of the union , union men or rebels , you won't blame- him for hastening onca moro to place himself beneath thr protec tion of the union arms. He avowed himself a nnlou man , then as now , as a man who from the time when ho could distinguish between right niid wrong , between the lore of country and disloyalty , had be lieved in the union and sought to perpetuate it when he ( aid to Gc-n. Mitchell , "I am n union man , and I have been a union man over since tbo commencement of these troubles , " ho wns believed. There waa no venomour , vindic tive and lying spirit to acy , "because you bavo been within the confederate lines , and because you did not 'tkln out of there , ' ( I be lieve that was the elegant expression that Thuruton used ) , because you did not 'akin out of there' months rgo , wo believe you lied when yen told us that you wore loyal nnd had been true to the flag. " Gen. Mitchell was too bonorablo n man for that. Ho took him by tha hand and said , "como into our service , nnd rebuild the telegraph lines across the river ; " and waa Mr. llosewater slow to do it ? That very day ( I believe the testimony is ) bo commenced work , and from that time uulil the cloeo of the war , OB bad been the c.iso before . fore , every heart-beat of his , every sentiment of that bosom , then nnd now , waa for the union , and for our ccmmon country. Soon after ha made n brief viiit to his homo , and this visit ia made a charge against him bymy friend Tbunton , No not in bla life seems right in Thurston'a oyea nnd tbo woret net that bo over committed , nccoirilcg to Thuiatou , was the net of being born. Thuistou did not eay that bo went east. Thurjton'u languaga was that ho "aklnned out" for Cincinnati where he was not known , and where be could hide himaoff , Aa there it no testimony whatever tint ho went to Cin cinnati , I will in charity presume that Mr. Thurston meant Cleveland when ho aald Cin cinnati , because tbo testimony was that bo went to Cleveland where ho was known , not , where ha waa not known , That bo went there to visit bla family , bnd friends and to renew those aesociationa which were BO plemnt , so cheering , nnd to Udlohtful during the four years of war. There are men within tbe sound of my voice who can remember how cbaiming it was to have a Httlo document which j ou tout out in fear and trepidation weeks befoio , asking that you might go homo and too year mother , nnd then como back ecdornad "tbla application is approved , " Wo did not think then that it would be brought cgnlnst ua ns evidence of disloyalty that wa wanted to too bister , mother or wife , once more before we were engaged in some battle which in IK lit take us off or before they bad yielded t ) the advance of ago or disease , No body blamed . us then , bnt now , when over the whole coun try peace smiles oncu more ; when tha flag Is borne fiom tba east to tbo wcit , and from tbe norto to the acufh. It IB now that they soy , "KoBCV/ater waaditloyal because be wanted to H9B fami y " I nanicUod rs c ucli feeling existed then , for Mr , llonownter did eee hia family and aj most immediately "indo ap. llcitlon to ba re- jiivod Into the telegraph aerviceof the United 3tatoJi , Ho vr&t so receiver ] and served tbero ! He served honwtly. Ho waa no spy In the service of the United States. lie was loyal to the Government. Ho regarded nnd ob served the oath which bo bad taken. Hut Mr. Thuraton denies this and nays that the [ net that Kcsewater WAS in the tervico of th United States explain * why the daily order * cf the secretary of war were known In the rebel camp as soon M thny were known In Washington. Now , in the first place , Tlmrs- ton has drnwn upon his Imagination for that statement. There is no truth In it I have too much regard for my friend Thuriton to charge him with stating n wilful fftltehood. But it in far from the truth , In foot , tbo shrewdness , care nnd wntchfulnesi of our gov ernment In that regard precluded the possi bility of inch treachery. True , there was hardly n week Hint wo ( ltd not hear that n projected attack upon tuch and inch n point rmd boon frustrated by intclli- gou.'o sent Into the robot army. But this meant that the government b d no Intention of attacking that spot andtiever had hnd , nnd nny information that wns sent into tha rebel lines wns cent there with the design to blind thorn when the real attack WAS to b ) made seine where else. Tbcro is not nn liut.tnco nl nny Inforinntion Rotting into the robot linen from the secretary of wnr nt Washington , un less it may IIATO boon by tbo capture of some ntdo-do-cnrnp who may bavo been curving ' orders on the field or from ono plnco to an other. So I say that it Is not true thnt Hone- water disclosed secrets of the government in Wruhtngton. Hero wns this boy 21 or 22 yonrs of ngo at thnt time , ono among fifty or 100 operators in Washington , ono of twelve or fourteen In Iho wnr dcpattmont , ono of 1,200 in tbo union nriny , and my friend enya that information ) oak d into the rabol lines and that out of thoio 1,200 men Hoaowatcr waa the * only man that disclosed thoiecrots of the gov- . eminent. It la preposterous. I will not in sult your Intelligence- dwelling upon it. It waa not boliovcd at the time , or Mr. Koso- wntcr would not came before you with this document yellow with the stains of time , bearing still upon it the mnrka of the oflico from which It omnnnted nnd bearing the aig- , nnturo of Thomas T. Eckcrt , whom you nil heard of , whoso reputation ti not confined to * nny ono town or ntato , but ia known nil over , the whole country. What docs ho say ? Ho ( * cays that Mr. KosowAter wai not only n good t operator , but that ho had "fulfilled every duty 4 , with entire satisfaction to Iho government , " Does that mean what It sayt ? Is it trut ? Is It a fact that ho aixtlaflnd the government ia tbo sfrvico in which ho wns employed ? doea Mr , Eckert lie , or do toeso slanderers and fnlsifiera lie when they nay llmt ho was disloyal , n rpy , nnd violated the confidence placed In him by the government ? But wade do not need the toslimc .y of Eckert nlono. Wo have other testimony. Wo have in the ' first pl.ico tbo books which have been pro duced in ovidoncp , nnd which my friend Thuriton says show only that ho waa em ployed in the Ecrvico of the government ; that ho ouco nppllcd for nn increase of pay , nnd thnt bo wni once obliged to ' 'skin out. " leav ing hia clothing bthiuJ bin ) , thus trying to * * make you belief o that Edward llosowntoris " n coward. You will never believe that gen- " tlomnn , you may bolicvo that bo ia n slanderer - x derer , n villain , or what you like , but yen will never , if you know anything nbout him , any that Edward Ilosewnter is a coward. And yet Tburston trioa to make yon believe that ho waa a coward , when the fact la that every body olio had "ekinned out" but tbo operat or ? , nnd ono train of cars , nnd thv were di reeled to remain until the enemy should nppenr in eight. Mr. Uosewaler need not , however , hnvo loft bla clothing. Ho could have got away with It but when thpy were about to bo captured , Hosowater jumped on to the trn'n nnd went off , Tbo reason why bo lost his clothes was that he waa attending to the dutica of the . .j government. Why was it thnt ho hnd't time 4 ( w to look out for a few shirts , or n pair of boots ? It waa because tno interests of the govern ment were at stnke , and though Thuriton chooses to say bo "skinned out , " I any th&t bo didn't ekln out until the Inat man bad left the place , nnd tbo rebels were on the point of taking it. It was true that Iloaowater wore no shoulder straps. He waa not n high officer. Theao two volumes nre not filled with the courageoua nnd skillful exploits of Rosewater , bnt ho Ia ono of thnt great nrmy of more than n million men wboao names are unknown nt large ; some of wnich nro Bleeping In southern cemeteries , Dome of whom hnvo never been taken from their dreamlars repose by tbo wnytido ; some of whom still remain irnonp ua , with their deeds untold ( whether brave or cowardly , nnd of thosa Hosowater ia contented to bo one. Wo any that these booka provo that wherever ho waa / Abe bo did bis duty Ilka n man , boy thoagh ho " nay have been in years , nnd it ia nil wo can lakof nny man ; nod it ia all bo neks of you to day. I must hniry moro rapidly over the reat of ny argument ; but wo now como to his llfo in .Ills state , aud that IB where Thurston ia nt ilj beet. Hero la where Thurston elilnon ; here a vi here he consents to do tbo work whlt/b hia imployora have put upon him with a zeal nnd : nergy and eloquence which leads mo to think .hat perhaps ho baa eomo piivato piiovanco to lir , and that it ia not merely nt the bcheat of ila makers nnd employers that bo utters his jitter language. I say that Itoeowater cnmo icro at or Immediately after tbo cloao cf the var , nnd has lived from llmt tlmo to this ns lancet , ns pure , no reputable , aa good and ns nofitnblo n life an nny man in the stale of tfebrnskn. No man cm ray ono wrrd against ilm except those that hive been hired by so- icrioroflicsra to crush him. No ono heard ono vcrd ngninot him during the years ho remained n the cervices of tha telegraph company toro , that telegraph company trusted him ; bo fas well bnorfri na nn nctiro end akillful cm- iloyo cf that company , rising from day to lay , accumulating money nnd making hlia- elf tieeful in nil these vnrloua ways in which zealous employe can nid nn employer , rhut he waa not satisfied with the limited leld which the science of telegraphy affords , think ia not against him. He was nnjdoua o better hia condition. lie citabllthod Ilia ) mabft Evening BEB. It irna cot , however , mill bo bad received moro than ono mark of onfidence , not only from hia employers , but rom the people of the stato. Ho had served a tha legislature. Ho had baon appointed o offices of trust in vnilous departments , nd under various circumstances. Tbo BBK , iiJcrhia cara , bsoimoin tliu course of yearn y his tnurgy , hia perseverance , hi ) induitry nd IIB ! peculiar tnlenta and qualifications for mblUhicg and editing n nourupaper In tbia ountry , n power In the state. Just there ho iaJo hi < ) grant mistake. Ju t when .0 became Influential nnd powerful , ho ared to uphold the cause of the worklngman nd of labor against monopolies and oorporato real tli. Thereupon the fiat went forth from no of tbo firent corporations which ho was Iwava ready to attack und chow up in its me light , to cruth him. Whether bo Is rushed or not will depend tomowhat upon our vodict to-dny. Wo HO employee of bnt great corporation , won who have been onnected ulih It almost tince its icceptlon , icro BB defendant * , hero ua counsel , and here , was going to eoy , as witnesses , Lut I am tot certain nbout that , end wo 'never can be. t is B part of the sarno ring that was organ- zed ten or fifteen years ago to cruth Edward ioiuwater , and baa over since been worllcg usldkuj nnd rutblees nltempU to dfciticy