NO. 8. KMTOK'S TAltliK 1HII amused lo find the principle feature of the lust number an oration entitled, ".Man Die Monarch I" And In their oxlravogant praises tliey wore supremely indifferent to llieir own sex. The Niagara hulax is at hand wiih its brimming budget of opprobious opithoK With malice aforethought the exchange editor attacks all the new papers and the old ones get only a sprinkling of his wrath. If the labor and time spent in abusing the exchanges were only turned upon the Index itself, the result would ho beneficial for all concerned. The painful oIlbrtH of the Dickinson Lib eral to secure a reputation for originality by the publication of the essay entitled, "IJotes: Three scenes with variations" is both ludicrous and eminently criticisable. It was evidently written lor tragical ell'cct by some student who is weakly imitating the groat French dramatist, Alexander Dumas. The J)ickinsoni editorials were unusually poor and the locals simply exec rable. The Liberal in our opinion de serves criticism, as other exchanges, for going beyond the especial province of col lego journalism, by the publication of cur. rent gossip after the manner tof newspa pers. Ii may be very interesting to know that tho 2;5rd of November is the wedding day of King Alfonso and the Archduchess Marie Christina; or, that the cx-Khcdivo's breakfast and dinner service cost 01,51)0: or, that Cctowajo had only twenty three followers when captured. Hut all this is very much out of place in a college paper, which is supposed to bo largely devoted to college litoraturo and college affairs in general. Tho Gollego Videtto from Oskaloosa is one of the poorest of our exchanges, not withstanding the fact that their main con tributed article was copied, and that a Prof, is editor-in-chief. It is not, strictly speaking, a student's paper and can scarce ly lie said to repiesent the college proper. The "Funny Man" could better have been omitted, for he was any thing but funny, and only impressed us with his stupidity and Imbecility. Tho chief editorial, giv ing advice to students, is worthy the at. tenllou of us all. The ArieV "Fragment from Dickens" was most readable and written in a style closoly resembling tlio great author him soil". The editorials of iw Ariel are very short and very discoursivo with respect to doings at the University. The locals arc very meagre, and considering the quality perhaps it i3 well thoro are so few of thorn. The Ariel devotes only a third of a col umn to exchanges, and fills that small space with praise. Tho llnbart Horald for September con tained no contributed articles and tho cd torials which opened tho number were many and uninteresting. Some space was devoted to a review of a Mother Goose exhibition, which according to the Jferald, was the great event of tho season In dramatic circles. The exchange noti ces were Hat and pointless, csbecially the would-be-witty fling at the Niagara Index. Tho Packer Quarterly contained agrace ful little poem in pleasing contrast to the miserably distorted prose, callod poetry, of many of our exchanges, and we quote it entire; A TIIOUIUIT. Only n cluster of punplos Purplo nml ilowoy mid niro, Laid with u touch of caressing. 'Mill tlio brown whvob ol'hur hair. Slmpln tho tokon, lint never Kloworn that wore costly mid fine, Horn such a mosi-ago of sweetness Itronthed Hiich u fragrance divine. Toll mo, 0 magical panslos, What In tho clinnn that yon hold, That to this fanciful nialdcn, Scorn you a treasure untold. LiBton, O velvoty panslcs, Stnco you will answer mo naught, All tho raro spoil of your magic Ltos In the charm of a thought. TUuAsbury Monthly bears upor. its title pago its claim to be recognized as emanat ing from a very religious Institution. Two of the ossays in the October number were eminently pious and savored of the t tf 'i fr JHJJ