THE NEBRASKA INDEPENDENT April 23, 1896. Nebraska 3nfcpcn5cnt 3 WtAlTH MAZSRS m4 LINCOLN I HfDSMffDMlfT. :lished every Thursday BY TBI .spsijdsijt Publtehiijg So. AtUSOKItrMt, ' ICOLN, . - NEBRASKA. TELEPHONE 538. .00 per Year in advance ddress all communication! to, and mkt all ts, on; orders, etc., p ayabls to THB INDEPENDENT PUB, CO., Lihooli, Mia. PULlST STATE CONVENTION. !LV UVIVd IrW WUVUVav v www vujiw dependent party of Nebraska will ba Id in the city of Grand Island, on ednesday, July 15, 180(5, at 2 o'clock m., for the purpose of electing fifty ven delegates, and fifty -seven alternates the people's party national conven on to be held in St. Louis, July 22, 396. I Each county will be entitled to one de bate at large and one' additional dele- ate for each one nun area votes, or ajority fraction thereof, cast at the meral election of leva for Samuel Max ell, for supreme judge, which gives the llowing representation by counties: dams.... 14 Jefferson 8 ntalopa. 11 Johnson 7 Mannar..... J Kearney, 11 Ulatne 1 Keith , X Boon IS Keya Paha S Box Botto 6 Kimball 3 Boyd Knox .' IS Brown 8 Lancaster 97 Bnffalo 19 Lincoln 11 , t Logan..... 1 14 Lonp 3 14 Madison 11 McPherion 1 8 Merrick , t Nance 9 Bart Bntler.... Ca ; Oedar.... (Chase.... vuvrrj . . . Cheyenne, 4 Nemaha 18 Clay 14 Nnckolli 13 13 oollax oto Coming 7 Pawnee 8 Coater 18 Perkins 8 Dakota 0 Phelps 13 Dawes I Pierce l Dawson ,14 I'lotte. 13 Denel 1 Polk 18 Dixon Red Willow Dodge 18 Ktchardsoa 7 DouKlas ...4 Rock 8 Dnndy 4 Saline 10 Fillmore 14 Sarpy 6 Franklin 9 Saunders 31 FronMer.' B Scotta Bluff 1 Furnas... ,.11 Seward. 10 Gaice .......14 Sheridan 8 Garfield 8 Sherman 7 Gosper. 8 Slonx 3 Grant 3 Stanton 4 Greeley t Thayer 8 Hall 14 Thomas 1 Hamilton 18 Thurston 3 Harlan 10 Valley 8 Haven 8 Washington 8 Hitchcock. a Waynn ,,,,, S Holt 13 Webster ,.,.10 Hooker 1 Wheeler 8 Howard York 14 It is recommended that primaries for selecting delegates to county conventions be held on Thursday, July 0; and that county conventions torseiectingdeiegates to Btate convention be held on Saturday, July 11. It is also recommended that the cre dentials from each county be banded in to the state central committee, prior to the meeting of the state convention, so that a full list of delegates can be made out and the tedious delay occasioned by a committee on credentials avoided. It is also recommended, in accordance with a resolution passed by the state central committee, that in the state con vention, the following plan of selecting delegates to the national convention be adopted: That nine delegates and nine alternates be selected from each con gressional district by the delegates present; and that three delegates and three alternates be elected at large. ' It is urgently requested that every member of the party, who possibly can do so, attend the primaries, so that those selected as delegates may represent the wishes of the entire party. Every voter in Nebraska, who favors an American system of finance and is opposed to the gold standard, bond issuing policy of the present administra tion; who favors the free and unlimited coinage of gold and silver at 16 to 1: who favors reform in our systems of money, land and transportation; who favors more economical administration of national and Btate governments; who is opposed to the further domination of Corporations in our legislation; who be ' lieves that the government should be who is ready to cast aside prejudice and Tote for the common prosperity of all; every such voter is cordially invited to participate in our primaries and assist in the selection of our delegates. By order ot the state central com mittee. J. A. Edgerton, F. D. Eager, Chairman. Sec'y. Notice. This edition of the In dependent is not printed for the edification of populists who are well informed on such subjects as "intrinsic value" "scientific money," etc. etc., but with the hope that subscribes . after reading it, will hand it to men who have had no opportunity of studying the primary principles of political economy as taught by the great scholars and the standard writers on that science. The next issue of the Independent will be a red hot one. Look out for it. There was a lot ot mighty good edi torial matter in the Platte County Argus last week. The State Journal has joined the pau per's and is taking tips from the Wall street banker's fund. Wednesday it printed one of the free gold bug cartoons. It will make little difference whether gold bugs conquer the silver men, or the silver men conquer the gold men at Chicago, for the populist will conquer tho conqueror, whichever it is. The Independent is for peace. It wil endure almost anything for peace, but i anyone comes around this office telling as we must repudiate any of the princi. plea of the populist party he'll get kicked down the back stairs. After that there downt wilybe wilybe peace, for awhile at least, in this PRIMARY PRIMARY PRINCIPLES. , First of all money is a unit of account. Some of the older economists illustrated it n this way. An English traveler explor Dg the eountry around the bead waters of the Nile, located himself for sometime with an Arab tribe. He found that they estimated the value of everything in something they called a macute. But he never saw a macute. lie inquired and investigated, but he could not find a macute. At last it dawned upon him that tbey had no material substance of any kind, which they called a macute. They would say a cow was worth twenty macutes, a goat ten macutes, a chicken two macutes, but the macute was an ideal thing. It was simply a unit of account. It must be plain therefore that this function of money can exist withoutbeing attached to any material substance. Another function of money is its use as a medium of exchange. A farmer brings to town a load of wheat. He sells it for ten dollars. When he receives the ten dollars be is not paid for his wheat. The money given to him Is of no "use" to him. It will neither satisfy his hunger or quench his thirst. With it he cannot shelter himself, cloth himself, or warm himself. The transfer of trie wheat to the wheat buyer, and of the money to the farmer, was only half of the transaction. When the farmer takes the money to the clothier and gives it to him for a suit of clothes, when he receives the suit of clothes, and not till then, is the farmer paid for his wheat. The function that money performs here is a medium of exchange. It enabled the farmer in a direct -ec. way to exchange his I it of clothes. wheat for a suit Money is often called a measure of value, this Is manifestly an error. One can take a yard stick and accurately measure the "length" of a piece of cloth. But he cannot take a quantity of gold and with it measure the "value" of the clpth. To arrive at the value he examines the texture of the cloth. Value is "measured'' if we may use the term at all in relation to value, with brains. Money has but one kind of value, and that is power in exchange. It is desired not for any quality in it, but simply and solely for its purchasing power. "When we speak of the value," says Prof. F. A- Walker, "of either gold or silver, we mean the power it has to purchase other commodities including the one element of money besides itself." Prof. Sidgwick says, 'That the value of money is the purchasing power ofmoner, or its exchange value measured in com modities. With these definitions every staudard writer on political economy agrees. To speak of any unit of money as a unit of value is man ifestly an error, and the proposi tion is really unthinkable. How can value be divided into units? The term unit of value has been used for a purpose, pnd that purpose evidently was to con fuse thought. What then is value? The definition of Senator John P. Jones is, in my opinion, as simple and comprehen sive as any found in the English language He says: "Human estimation placed upon desirable objects whose quantity is limited." " Value, then, cannot be an inherent quality of anything. A thing to have value must not exist by itself alone, but evidently there must also be in existence other things. Nothing has value with out the presence of population. Besides the thing called valuable you must have a man or men. That those who have thought on this subject may fully comprehend the defini tion of value here set forth, let me illus trate it by the following incident. I went into a bank in the city of Wash ington and presented a draft on New York for f 100.00. The banker counted out to me $95.00 in greenbacks, and then laid down a five dollar gold piece with the remark, "That paper money has no value in itself, but this piece of gold has the value in it. I replied, "will you treat to an oyster supper if I prove to you that there is no value in that piece of gold," and he said, "I certainly will I then took the five dollar gold piece to n. aiMantmr, OI national reuuiouuu, a chemist by profession, and I said to him I want you to analyze this piece of gold I want you to give me a certificate over your own name of everything there is "in it," and further certify after you have made a thorough analysis that you ha. ttP1 "all" that was "in it" and that there was nothing else "in it." The certificate that the chemist gave me was to tne enect. ma mem nno ninety parts of gold "in it," Beven parts of copper "in it". three parts of silver in i on thorn wrs nothing else " in it. Then I took the certificate to the banker and said to him "you said there mn .ulna "in it." Here is a man of science who has analyzed it, and he certi He tho r tho ir old "in it. silver in it." copper "in it," and nothing else "in it." Now where is that value that you said was "in it?" What's the color of it? What's its weight? What does it amoll like? What does it taste like? Where, and what is it. The position taken by the banker is an old one. and has often been refuted by standard writers upon political economy, McLeod "Theory and Practice of Bank ing, p.'48.," clearly explodes the fallacy of value being in things, or as it is com monly called, intrinsic value, lie says PRINCIPLES OF POLITICAL ECONOMY. "How can anything have intrinsic value unless it has tho things it will exchange for inside itself?" Further on, p. 50, he says. "Moreover we see on considering tha term value, that it is nonsense to speak of the representative ot value." To a, thinking man these terms, re presentative value," "intrinsic value," etc., constantly used by the bankers and the daily press must be as McLeod says simply nonsense, and with McLeod stands today every standard authority on economics in the whole world. THE PROFESSORS AND POPULISTS. Every position taken by the populists is sustained by the writings of the great scholars and thinkers in all parts of the world. There is no writer of standard au thority or economist, who on the money question is not a populist. We have the scholarship and the learning of the world all on our side. That this is not a vain boast, we give a few extracts from what some of these scholars and economists say on a few points of populist belief. WHAT IS MONEY? Money exists not by nature but by law." Aristotle. "Money is that which passes freely from hand tohand throughoutthecommunity in final discharge of debts and full pay ment for commodities, being accepted equally without reference to the charac ter or credit of the person who offers it, and without the intention of the person who receives it to consume it or enjoy it, or to apply it to any other use than, in turn, to tender it to others in discharge AaVAa nr full rvnvment, for- commodi- tie8pro. Franci8 A Walker. , "There is no such thing as intrinsic value." Prof. Stanley Jevons, "Value, like utility, is no intrinsicqual- ity of a thing; it is an extrinsic accident or relation. "Value implies, in fact, a relation; but if so, it cannot possibly be some other thing. A student of economy has no hope of ever being clear and correct in his ideas of the science if hethinksof value as at all a thing or object, or even as anything which lies in a thing or object" Prof, Jevons The Theory of Polntical Economy, page 82. "Value, then, is not a quality of single things belonging to them as if by nature, as hardness is a quality of a rock or gravity is an attribute of goldjbecause all physical qualities in physical things, all that which makes or helps to make any thing such as it is, may be learned by a study of the things themselves, by them selves. A careful examination and analysis of the mechanical and chemical properties of any physical thing will discover all its distinguishing charac teristics, all that makes it that particu lar thing in distinction from all other things; but it is plain already that the value of anything (if it have value) can not be found out by studying that par ticular thing by itself alone; the question ing of the senses, however minute, the test of the laboratory, however delicatei can never determine how much anything worth, because that always implies a comparison Deiween two wings or more strictly a comparison between two renderings in exchange. V alue is not an attribute of single things; not even if the things be physical and tangible." Prof A. L. Perry of Williams College. Principles of Political economy, page 35. BOUNTY TO SILVER STANDARD COUNTRIES. The necessary effect of a depreciation of silver as against gold is to give a bounty on exports from India and the other silver using countries to England. An English merchant can now buy many more rupees than he formerly could with the same number of sovereigns, and therefore he can import from India, though prices at Calcntta are not at a level at which it would have paid him to operate if he had not had that novel fa cility in getting rupees." Mr. Bagehot Depreciation of silver. "Now, it seems to me probable if the price of silver rose to its old level wheat cauld not be profitably exported from India until prices rose in a correspond- ingdegree. For India, being asiiver coun try, the price ol wheat there is indepen dent of the tho relative value of gold and silver. An exporter to England at pres ent will give the Indian price in silver, and he can buy his silver for less gold, and thus competition will lower the price. If the price of silver rose the exporter from India must get more gold. Thus a rise of silver would.on this view, raise the price of wheat to acorresponding degree." Prof. Nicholson. THE QUANTITATIVE THEORY. "In whatever degree, therefore, the quantity of money is increased or dimin ished, other things remaining the same, in the same proportion tho value of the whole and every part is recriprocally diminished or increased." John Stuart Mill. "The value of money in any country is determined by the amount existing. That commodities would rise or Jail in price in proportion to the increase or diminution of money I assume as a fact that is incontrovertible." Ricardo, Re ply to Bosauquet. If the quantity of gold in a country whose currency consists of gold should be increased in anygiven proportion, the quantity of other articles and the de mand for them remaining the same, the value of any given commodity measured In the coin of thkt country would be in- creased inthesame proportion. William Huskinson. Depreciation of the Cur rency. . If the value of all other commodities, in relation to gold, ' rises and falls as their quantities diminish or increase, the value of of gold in relation to com modities mustriseandfallas its quantity is diminished or increased. Torrens Po litical Economy, The rates at which money exchanges lor other things is determined by its quantity. Prof. De Colange in American Cyclopedia of Commerce. The exchange value of any particular coin will vary in exactly inverse ratio to the variations in the quantity of the ag" gregate. Prof. Sedgwick of Cambridge University Eng. Principles of Political Economy page 251. PAPER MONEY. There is plenty of evidence to prove that an inconvertible paper money, if carefully limited in quantity, can retain its full value. Such was the case of the bank of England notes for several years after the suspension of specie payments in1797, and such is the case with the present notes of the bank of France." Prof. Stanly Jevons. "A well regulated paper currency is so great an improvement in commerce that I should greatly regret if prejudice should induce us to return to a system of less utility. The introduction of the precious metals for the purposes of moneymay with truth be considered as one of the most im portant steps toward the improvement of commerce ana toe arts oi tne civwzea life; but it is no less true, that with the advancement of kuowledgeand science, we discover that it would be another im provement to banish them again from the employment to which, during a less enlightened period, they had been so ad vantageously applied." Ricardo. If in a country which wants and pos sesses a metallic currency of seventy mil lions of dollars, a paper currency to the same amount should be substituted, the seventy millions in gold and silver, being no longer wanted for that purpose, will be exported, and the returns may be converted into a productive capital and add an equal amount to the wealth o' the country." Albert Galletin Sec, of D. S. Teasury 1801 to 1813. It is only fair to add that the only au thority on the other side of all these questions is Hon. G. M. Lambertson of Lincoln, Nebraska who thinks that a redundancy of money makes low prices and produces panics. SCIENTIFIC MONEY. 1 The injustice of a variable money unit has at various times led to suggestions for the remedy of the evil. As early as 1822 an English writer named Lowe proposed that authoritative returns should be collected, from a variety of localities, showing the prices of com modities of most general consumption, and that from those a table of reference be constructed, having regard to the comparative quantities consumed in an average household. By following, he said, the .ourse of prices as shown by such returns all contracts which by their terms were payable in money could, ac cording as they mature, be adjusted in accordance with the principles of equity, and the value of money thus be kept con stant. Some eleven years later a scheme some what similar was proposed by another English writer, named Scrope, the author of a work on political economy. In 1838 G. R. Porter, author of The Progress of the Nation, gave publication to another plan involving the same general features, with tables of prices of fifty leading com modities, showing their average monthly fluctuations for a period of years. Commenting on those plans, Prof. Jevons, who himself fully recognized the evil of the varying value of money, writ ing so late as 1875, sayB: Such schemes for a tabular or aver age standard of value appear to be per fectly sound and highly valuable in a theoretical point of view, and the prac tical difficulties are not of a serious char acter. To carry Lowe's and Scrope's plans into effect a permanent commission would have to be created and endowed with a kind of judicial power. The officers of the department would collect, the current prices of commodities in all the principal markets of the kingdom, and by a well-defined system of calcula tions would compute from these data the average variations in the purchasing power of gold. (The goldites in the United States say that gold never varies in value.) "The 'decision of this commission would be published monthly, and pay ments would be adjusted in accordance with them. Thus, suppose that a debt of 100 was incurred upon the 1st of July, 1875, and was to be paid back on the 1st of July 1878, that the value of gold had fallen in the ratio of 106 to 100 in the intervening years And in passing let me remind Senators that instead of falling the value of gold has risen at an average rate of 2)4 per cent per annnm as shown by the fall in the general level of wholesale prices for the past twenty years, ever - ince the year when the UnitedStates demonetized silver. Prof. Jevons, however, for good reasons, suggested the idea of a fall, and speaking of such fall, he adds "then the creditor would claim an in crease of 6 per cent in the nominal amount of the debt." There is not a doubt that in the case of a fall in the value of gold as supposed by Prof. Jevons, the creditor would in sist on equitable compensation for the fall; he wonld insist on being made whole to the full extent of the increase of prices of commodities for that is what is meant by a ''fall" of gold money or any other kind of money. But in the case which more immediately comes home to the great producing masses the persis tent and ruinous fall in the prices of the products of farm and factory for the past twenty years, and the consequent and ruinous increase of the burden of debt, the creditor sees no equity to be asserted by the debtor and denies that this persistent and extraordinary fall of prices is an injury to men who have bor rowed money with which to buy homes or to enter upon business enterprises in the hope and expectation that the prices of their products would enable them to pay interest and to repay the loan with out depriving them of their entire pro perty. Extract from a speech of John P. Jones. Of the inequity of the single gold standard, no standard economist ex-. presses any doubt. Prof. Alfred Mar, shall.of Cambridge University, England than whom there is no higher authority, writing on this subject of scientific money "When traders are rejoicing in high prices, bond and mortgage-holders and other creditors are depressed, and when the pendulum swings the other way traders,- already depressed, are kept un der water by baring to pay an excep tionally heavy toll to their creditors. "This serious evilcanbe muchdimished by a plan which economists have long advocated. In proposing: this remedy I want government to help business. It should publish tables showing as closely as may be the changes in the purchasing power of gold, and should facilitate con tracts for payments to be made in terms of units of fixed purchasing power. "On this plan it A lends B 1,000 at i per cent, interest and after some years the purchasing power of money had risen by an eighth, B would have to pay asinteresttoot 45, but a sum that had the same purchasing power as 45 had at the time of borrowing, that is, 40. And so on, The plau would have to win its way into general use, but when once it had become familiar none but gamblers would lend or borrow upon any other terms, at all events for long periods." Of course all populists, know that the object sought to be accomplished by the economists justice and equity between aeDtor ana creditor, tax payer and office holders, interest receiver and in terest payer, can be arrived at, though not so quickly, by increasing or dimish ing the amount of money in circulation. That is the idea most favored by the economists of the United States and treat ed at some length in Senator Stewarts speech. "Silver and the Science of Money." PAYING TRIBUTE TO THE RICH. Few people comprehend the vast differ ence to the prosperity, of the people re sulting from the government issue of, free coinage of money, and the furnish ing of the circulating medium by the banks. To get bank money into circula tion, interest must be paid on bonds and interest must be paid on the money itself, before it can be used as a medium of ex change, but in the case of free coinage or government issue, the money goes into circulation without theenormous tribute which the users of it are forced to pay to the "idle rich." If a farmer sells f 100 worth of wheat and is paid for it in bank money, the purchaser has to deduct this tribute to the "idle rich" from the price he would otherwise pay to the farmer, or he could not do business at all. This tribute is entirely unnecessary, and if it were not for "the dense igno rance on economic subjects which prevails among the people," it would not be sub mitted to for a day. The present prosperity of France large ly results from the fact that the people of that republic do not pay this tribute to the "idle rich," while- the people of this republic do pay it. It is a good sign to find a writer here and there drawing attention to the awful drain that bank money makes upon the resources oi the people. Mr. S. W. Powell of Minnesota calls at tention to it in the Representative as follows: "There is another reason, and a great one why all citizens of this republic, ex cept those engaged in banking or loan ing money, should stand for free coinage of silver, and that is the difference in cost of silver coin and national bank notes. If a miner has $1000 worth of silver bullion, under free comage he can have it coined or exchange it for stan dard dollars. The dollars he receives be long to him if he gives 100 of them to a farmer for a horse they belong to the farmer. Thus they pass from hand to hand and complete hundreds of transac tions, each time buying something the holder wants or liquidating a debt, with no other cost to the people than the miner's exertion; while a national bank note cannot exist as a medium of ex change until someone borrows it and pays interest. All the people pay 4 per cent on the bonds deposited in the United States treasury to secure the bank's circulation. The individual who borrows it pays 8 per cent discount for 90 days, the longest time the bank loan for. Ninety days is about one-fourth of a year, so that portion of their circulation that is loaned for 90 days is compounded four times a year, and that portion loaned for 30 days is compouded 12' times a year, or about 33 per cent per annum, a rate of interest that will bank rupt any legitimate business." ALWAYS REMEMBER. Always remember that there is very little silver bullion in the world. No man can point where there is, all told, 5,000, 000 ounces. Always remember that coined silver that is now in circulation in foreign countries is worth f 1.33 an ounce where it is coined at the ratio of 15. to 1; and is worth $1.37 an ounce where it is coined at the rate of 15 to 1; and it ia not coming to the United States to be coined at $ 1.29 an ounce. Always rememper that when the gold jte predicts a flood of silver that they are predicting an impossibility. There is no fountain from which such a flood cam flow. GOLDITE LOGIC. 1. Free coinage of silver would double the value of the silver baron's silver bullion. 2. Free coinage of silver would put us on a silver basis and the dollars with which we would do business and pay debts wonld only be worth fifty cents. ' 3. The bullion in a silver dollar is worth 67 cents now. 4. If we have free coinage the bullion in a fifty cent dollar will only be worth 67 cents, You cannot create value by law. 5. Nevertheless the free coinage of silver would only benefit the mine owner and he would get twice what he gets now for his silver. 6. If you cannot understand that fifty cents is twice as much as sixty-sever cents, you have wheels in your head- WHICH SHALL IT BE"? Populists must decide now whether the organization of the peoples party is to be kept up as an economic and philo sophical society for the discussion ot certain theories of government, and compel their incorporation into law by forcing some other political party to take them up and enact them, or whether from this on, it is to.be strictly a politi cal party and do the enacting itself. The agitation which the populist party has carried on has already forced the enactmant of many of its principles into law in various places, notably the muni cipal ownership of gas plants, electric lighting, city water etc., etc. In none of these cases has this been done by t he peoples party, acting as a political or., ganization. One or the other of the old parties has been forced to do it and got the credit for it. Populist principles are becoming such, a force in public affairs, that even the State Journal is compelled to take some of them up and give them editorial ap proval. Last week it was advocating; the public ownership of patent rights. Populists may go on, if they will, ad vocating their principles, educating the public, and one of the old parties will enact their principles, one by one into law, and thereby live, and the populist party.as a party cease to exist. This was the history of the Chartists in England. About two years ago, the last one of the demands of the Chartists,, was enacted into law by the British, parliament, but the Chartist party died long years ago. The conducting of a philosophical and economic society is entirely a different thing from managing a political party. The success of a party depends upon get ting a majority of voters. You may convince a man of the correctness of an economic proposition but you may en tirely fail to get him to vote with your party. The whole force must now be directed, to getting men to vote the populist ticket. That is practical politics. The affairs of the party must be always con ducted with that end in view. The ob ject of a political party is to get votes enough to put it in control of the govern ment. The object of an economic society is entirely different. It don't want to. get control of the government and legis late. It simply wants to teach the truth and let some other organization do the legislating. Which shall it be? If civilization and free government are to endure, populist principles must be enacted into law. If the populists get in to power, it will be done speedily. If we continue on as an educating force only, forcing a little this year and a little next year, a generation or two of suffering must be endured, before final relief and prosperity will come. Which shall it be? Shall we so manage as to get votes enough to win, or shall we just go on writing and talking? We want a railroad system in this country that will make the diamond shirted banker, the republican boss, the democratic boss, the members of legisla tures, the members of congress,, the judges, the big merchants and the law yers pay just the same fare as the farmer and workingman. Under the present system the former classes ride free, and', the farmer and workingman man pay double what they ought to pay. If you read this paper and1 like it, send your subscription at once to the Indb pkndent Pub. Co., Lincoln,. Neb. thkt 1 leader. i OU Uvuia.