The Plattsmouth journal. (Plattsmouth, Nebraska) 1901-current, June 10, 1909, Image 2
Jury Finds John Clarence Cuilly (Continued from page 1.) the engine when the first was thrown. Later he was In the wagon End Earl went out. Witness was within a foot and a half of the scoop hole and (lose to the east side. The Albin's were railing one another d fools and Earl was dar ing Carter to get out of the wagon. The latter took off his coat. Thack er then came around the horses and told Carter Albin to get out of the wagon and further the witness could not remember. He could not remember what Clarence said. He was watering his mules. Thacker then picked up a stick and started toward Clarence who was 3 or 4 feet from the tank. Thacker then commenced beating Clarence over the head with the board and Clar ence fought hark with the cane, Witness then went out of the crib and ran around it he head of the horses, and saw the men grappled. Witness demonstrated before the Jury, how they were clinched. Mr. Clark laid particular emphasis on the position of Thacker's thigh. Clnrenco then reached to his left Ride and drew his gun, discharged It. The men moved along and fell In the draw to the southwest. Witness saw Clarence pull the gun and shoot. When they fell Thacker was on Clar ence, side and shoulder, his head on Clarence's shoulder. Clarence held his cane over his shoulder with both hands. When witness started for the scene of the trouble, witness heard Clarence scream, he though twice, when he was hit with the hoard. Saw the cane lying south west after Clarence got up. When the last shot was fired Clarence'B right side was on the ground and Thacker was on Clarence's left side. Lee Thacker came up and stood on Clarence's arm and tried to got the gun away. Clarence refused to give up the gun saying "You fel lows would stand around and let him kill me." He offered to let Crawford have the gun but Lee ob jected, and then he offered to give witness the gun but he refused It. Thacker was then helped up and Clarence got up and went after his pony. He wished Lop Thacker good luck and said he was going to Platts mouth to give himself up. No shots were fired until after the blows were ftnu'k. Cress-examined by Mr. Cerlng: Witness was watching the Alblns and did n'.t think of trouble with Thacker and Albin. Karl Alliln nsk fj witness to thrown corn at Carter. The first corn was thrown at Carter when ht was on the engine. Could not tell how far Carter was from Earl when the corn was thrown. CcuH not remember about corn hitting Carter. Did not remember' who Mrst used the expression "fool" between the two Alliln.s. Karl shook nis mi nana nt Carter. Did not know whether Earl was right handed or not. Earl's right hand was in his pocket. Could not remember wnnt was done next. Witness was looking through the l'.th crnck, Face quite close part of the time Could not tell whether the camera was placed In the exact spot he had occupied when gazing through the track. Could not any whether stud- dings were the same distance apart Witness said he couldn't look south If his head was against the studding Could not swear whether he could see a point three feet east and six feet south of the horses heads. Wit iiess looking through the crack could not see Clarence's hand on nls enne and did no so testify at Union. He could not bco defendant's revolver around his waist. Witness Indicat ed on State's Exhibit No. 2. where the men fell. Did not see Thacker pick up the stick nor Clarence move toward Thacker. First saw Thncker between the horses and tho , crib, At that time no one had said any tiling except the Alblns. Witness stated he did not have his eye at the crack when he trouble started inarm r struck Clarence with the board and this board was handed over to Mr. Ramsey. Shown piece of board, he Identified It as the Until which ho had given Mr. Ham y and claimed It was the board Thacker had used. Witness admit ted this. Clarence.- had hold of the smaller end of the cane when he rain.J It to strike Thacker. Did not the ihnp before. Witness re rerint'd M sitlons during the melee. Wltn't (I'luotiMra'cd how the men v.re climbed, using Mr. Ramsey as a mobl ,f Clarence and be repre nMnc the lute Mr. Thacker. A d monMratlcn by th us of the re volver that tin shot which p-tn-i rated tli l.g could net have In n 11 red by defendant while In he posltl-n wit-m--K ( cctipe, wn mad" before Jury. A il niui.-tr.itleii vim :il. mad" nhowlng the (m. jin. ii tir ' he two tn"., mi Hiey lay on tin ground with Th:uker's hand gripping (inn im-i-'h right hand v.lileh he the gun. Tie third Mint which- pi-mtrat-d the breast was 11 red us the men Ml f Hi" ground. The stl'k glvi-n r. rtrnnsey vnn found nt tli" sn-ii" of th" KtrupKl". An old board wan also found wlililu 3 or 4 feet of the place . Witness did not appreciate gravity of ihaikers wounas. me hot which penetrated the breast was !.red rs the men had almost j hit the ground. Witness thought the gun some six or eight Inches from the breast but not one foot. Witness could see all the shots. Two shots were fired very close together and the third shot when the men were almost in the act of falling. By Mr. Clark on re-direct: Wit ness did not pretend to give Mr. Thacker's position on Mr. Clarence's body. Witness stood on the corn In the crib. Distance to the ground was 6 to 9 inches. By Mr. Gerlng: Questioned wit ness as to his testimony before the coroners Jury at the inquest at Un ion. This showed a variance be tween witness testimony then and his testimony: now. Mr. Clark examined: Witness had seen Clarence breaking horses at his home. He buckled on a re volver and holster while the boys harnessed the horse. By Mr. Gerlng: Witness was in wagon with Clarence. Witness held the double rope and the western horse while Clarence drove. Wit ness and Crawford had read over their testimony on Tuesday and Fri day In Mr. Clark's office. By Mr. Clark: Witness had heard other, pe-ople say his testimony was different at this trial than at the Inquest. Clark made another excellent wit ness for the defense and materially strengthened their case. His an swers Were uniformly dear and given without apparent study or any equivocation. On the whole, the main strength of the defense seems to be in the testimony of Redmon, Crawford and Clark. A short recess was taken at 3:30 to enable attorneys, the Jury and the court to get a spell of rest. Len Crawford called by Mr. Ger lng for further cross-examination. Knew Floyd Saxon. Talked with him in April, he thought. "I didn't see anything of it. Johnny butted In where he had no business and got himself in trouble." Witness denied saying thfs to Saxon. John Clarence took the stand. Age 29 years. Lived at Union. Single man. Lived here in I'lntts niouth, at Union lived with his fath er. Lived on Jan. 15th near Union on his own place. Had lived in neighborhood and known John Thacker all his life. Homes 1-2 mile apart. Relations had been pleasant. Used a cane 7 or 8 years. Witness shown defendants exhibit No. 14, n photograph of himself taken two weeks ago or so. Also exhibit No lb, also of himself. One standing and the other sitting with legs bare. Photographs were shown to the Jury who scrutinized them closely. Had a enne with him on Jan. 13, 1900, producing It. Length about 3 feet and one Inch In diameter at the end and one and one-quarter inches at the largest place, a hickory cane. Cannot walk without a cane nnd has scarcely any use for the left leg using-a brace attached to heel of slice and strengthening ankle. The brace had strap iron over the thigh and also one running half way up the leg. Went to Dnrough's farm In the forenoon of the 15th. Knew Walter Thacker nnd saw him about 9 a. in. that day. With Ed. Mldklff ho was going to borrow a wagon to haul corn with. Thncker told him that John had asked him to get wit ness over to his place to beat him. Witness did not believe John Thack er Intended to do so. First saw John Thacker when he came back from watering his horses. Next saw Thncker at Darrough's. Witness at the water tank, Thacker hollowed and attracted his attention. Wit ness standing at tank, witness had gotten a load before this which he had pulled from tho east side of crib. Had two mares and two mules to It. Did not notice anything go ing on at the crib. Did not notice what tho hollow was. Looked around and saw Thacker. He was 6 or 8 feet from witness north, and walk ing west. Nothing passed between them. Thacker went to the west side of the wagon and hollowed to Carter Albin to get out and slap harl. Itne-sa told him to come back and keep his mouth out of It, It was none of his fuss. Thncker picked up n board a little southeast of the team and came toward witness. Wit ness had stepped a little north when Thncker first hollowed but no more. Thncker struck the first blow when within reach. Witness had on n sheeps skin lined second coat and also n gun (examined gun and Identi fied It.) Tut gun on that morning. Witness was here shown defendant's exhibit 13 which he Identified as the lie lie wore on Jan. 15 when Mr. Thinker was striking him. Cap was delivered to Sheriff Qulnton ami had not been in Witness possession since. Couldn't say how many times Thnck er si rui k It I m. Witness . xhlblted to Jury how he raised his e-ane, the (inn he was holding el tin, away. Witness struck Thacker on the nlM. Could net sey what Thinker did with the can". Witness then reach ed for his gun. Thacker was I -hind and nt one side of witness with his arms around him someway. Thr.ek r was behind and to the left slle of him. When he lost the caae, he made up his mind to shoot and ave his life. Witness did notl b'lieve Walt Thacker statement. until John commenced beating him. He fired no shots until John com menced to beat him nor did he shoot Mm as he stooped to pick up the stick. He did not tell him to come back or he'd shoot him. The men clinched and fell very quickly. He pulled the gun with his right hand and fired as-quick as he could. He took no aim (witness demonstrated the position of the gun in his belt and how he handled it.) He was shooting as they fell. When "they struck the ground Thacker was lay ing on witness; sideband breast. , On the left side. Witness left arm "was over his. breast with Thacker's neck over his elbow and his head below witness chin. After they got up wit ness was handed his cane and went to the barn and saddled his pony, starting to town. Spoke to Lee Thacker, wished him good luck. Then came to town and gave him self up to Policeman Cory. Witness did not know when he left Dar rough's. lie came in over the tele graph road. Witness had on no overcoat. Shown a coat marked "ex hibit No. 17, Identified as the coat he had on that day. Wool on coat had black on it after he shot Mr. Thacker, which was powder burns. Coat offered in evidence and exhibit ed to the Jury. When they clinch ed he came from the north and wit ness turned as he struck at him. They fell to the southwest. His coat was down over the gun when they clinched. Witness had no ther Intention than to protect his life and body when they fell. Witness' height 5 feet 6 Inches, weight 160 pounds. Had had no business or other re lations with J. C. Petersen prior to Jan. 15. Mr. Gerlng cross-examined: Wit ness required to put on his coat Just as he wore It that day and also the revolver and belt. Witness demon strated how he handled the gun. At the first shot Clarence's hand was below the navel. Powder mark could have been made on coat when the cartridge exploded but no bul let hole made. Witness demonstrat ed where he would have to hold the revolver to shcot Thacker in the "Mali. Revolver was a little highe when the second shot was fired. Third shot, fired as they struck the ground. Thacker's head was som? lower than before. Witness pointed out the powder marks. Witness pur pose In shouting was to make Thack er stop beating him. He was not beating or Injuring him when he fired the first shot. He had hurt his knee when the second shot was fired. The third shot was fired when they struck the ground and Thacker had made no attempt to strike wit ness hetwen tho first and last shots All he tried to do was to get wit ness down. It looked to hir.i like his life was In danger when Thacker had him by the wrist and was asking the boys to take the gun away from him. Lee Thncker never offered to strike him with the monkey wrench nor hud he Pepped on his bund with undue force or violence. Witness had heard Crawford had pulled a gun out on Thncker. The witness exhibited to the Jury the spots on his head where Thacker had bruised him. Walt Thacker wanted him to sign a petition for a road through John Thacker's land. At that time he had been made acquainted with John's thre-ats. He did not believe Walt Thacker. Notwithstand ing these threats made in August, 1907, their relation had been t.lendly and Thncker had never offered him violence or anything of that kind Walt had feeling against John. The teams hauling the corn were gentle, witness demonstrated how he was holding the lines and the rope of the team which he was holding at the time of tho trouble'. Mr. Gerlng closely questioned the witness con cernlng his movements about the Darrough premises on the day of the trouble, and his actions with the team etc. Mr. Clark on re-dlrect: Thacker tried to bite witness as they lay on the ground, biting nt his chin. Mr. Gerlng: Witness had already fired the third shot when the at tempt at biting took place. Heard Mr. Thacker order the doctor. .Mr. luring w antra to exam. tie several witnesses to relievo them from having to stay. Judge ruled that If the wltne-sse-s could be fur nihil! d within an hour they might proceed. It was decided that the state would call their wlinessea oirt of thelc turn. The state called D. W. Foster g" i.i year. Lived In Libert pivclmt 35 years, Knew Mr Thinker's reputation t-i be n pence' nbl" nan. By Mr. Clark: l.hcd :. miles from Mr. Thacker. Trad, d i't Union. W. D. Wheeler called: Aue .-, years. Lived miles south of liattsiimutli Ha l lived there about on" year. Sheriff and roin.tv treasurer. Had known .! hn 1 1 Hacker for years. Witness not well in n-ialiited with his rcpu'n Hon. Geo. LaRue called: 65 years of age. Lived at Union 40 years. In Cas county 41 years. Had known John Thacker 35 years. Mr. Thacker's reputation peaceable. Ey Mr. Clark: Had never seen Mr Thacker having quarrels with a Mrs. Quail Johnson. Had heard of some little quarrels in which Mr. Thacker was the aggressor. Wm. Chalfant called: 43 years old. Lived in Liberty precinct 11 years. Knew Mr. Thacker 11 years. He was a peaceable man. Mr Clark cross-examined: Until this trouble he had not heard Mr. Thacker's reputation as to being peaceable questioned. Had not heard of quarrels with his neigh bors. Had never heard of Frank Albin moving away on account of trouble with Mr. Thacker. Crede Harris called: 43 " years old. Lived In Liberty precinct 30 years. Lived within 2 miles of John P. Thacker. His reputation was peaceable. Byron Clark cross-examined: His knowledge was from his person al relations. Winfleld Swan called: Name T. W. Swan, aged 4 6. Lived in Liber ty precinct all his life. Had known Mr. Thacker since boyhood. Knew his reputation as peaceable. By Mr. Clark Lived Z'a miles from Mr. Thacker. Had borrowed and loaned things. Thacker passed his place on his way to town. Had never heard his reputation dis cussed until this trouble came up. Jesse Pell called: Jesse L.Pell,37 years old. Brother Mrs. Ed. Mld klff. Lived in Liberty precinct all his life and was a boy with Mr. Thacker. Lived within 2 miles of him. His reputation was peaceable. Mr. Clark cross-examined. Had not heard of him ever having much trouble He did not remember of much trouble. A few rows. Wit ness lived west and south of Mr. Thacker. Dan Cox called: Mr. Ramsey ex amined: Lived at Nebraska City. Knew Len Crawford. Was In Ne braska City about February 16. Re membered a conversation with Crawford on thnt elite. John Mc-Carrc-1 present. Crawford said: "I didn't see any of" th.? shooting. I was In the crib a'-d D glad of t John McCarrel called: Corre.Lo- iV.nl the witness Dan Co. Lived In l.ibi rty preer.i.-, 22 years. He ;iid ' didn't see- a 1) thing of It. I was In the corn crib and D glad "of It." Mi'. Clark ciost-txair.iiied: Was not e-ertaln whether Crawford said he didn't see it cr the shooting. Floyd Saxon called. Examined by Mr. Ramsey: Lived at Union all his life. Knew Sam Crawford. Had a conversation with him in which he snid "I didn't see anything of it." Thought referred to the affair. Crawford said h was In the eiib ani didn'i see anything of it. E. E. Smith called: Mr. Ramsey examined. Lived in Liberty pro duct nil his life. Knew Orln Ervln and l rawrord. Uomembered a con versation with Cdawford on Jan uary it Crawford said "I don't know anything about It, 1 knew what h? was and 1 got down out of sight." Orrln Erwln called, Mr. Ramsey examined: Lived near Union in Liberty pre'einct. Corroborated E. E. Smith on conversation testified to above. Geo Saxon called, Mr. Ramsey ex amined: Knew Sam Redmon. Was with County Attorney Ramsey at the Darrough farm at his request. Re called conversation with Redmon at that time and place when he said he was at the telephone In the house at the time and did not know any thing about It. Mr. Clark cross-examined: Con versation held Just south of the house. Did not see Mr. Redmon point out where he stood nt the time1. Had conversation In the house and at tho barn but could not re-call them. Redmon had pointed out where the men fell. Gt-orge Hill cnlled. Mr. Ramsey examined: Recalled a conversa tlon with Sam Redmon a short time after the shooting. Redmon said he didn't know anything about It, he was In the house getting a team. By Mr. Clark: Witness hnd asked Redmon about the shooting and he said he didn't know any thing about it. Ir. (ierrans cnlle-d. Examined by Mr. Clark: Lived nt Union. Had se-e n defendant getting ready to break and breaking horses about one ear ng';. !! had rnedver on him. i ouri iiiijiMinnM until :i tn. Tuesday. Tiii-.elii.v Morning-. At nlii" o'i In k this morning when m-,:rt was to recoim-ne for what pioinli.'d to be th- final stretch of the tinted (iiilenee i use, there was Kcarci'ty a corporal's guard ft vis Itois and t-peitators in tli rnoin. As I In s'-ssl- n wore- on the numbers In-ct-'iiied until n fairly good sljed irowd wis in t!i room. The do, f iidie' Imoye.i up ),y tli" favorabl" day f yeterd.iv, seemed quite ile-erfiil, Alongside him and bach of his counsel his aged father and ! niothtr as well as his brother held seats, just as they had done through out the trial. Several ladies were also seated beside the aged Mrs. Clarence. The widow of the late Mr. Thack er with her stalwart son Lee. and her two charming little daughters. occupied seats inside the bar Just back of County Attorney Ramsey John P. Thacker, tho Murdered Man I and Mr. Gerlng, the special coun sel. The day was dark and disa greeable and the gas lights over the clerk's and reporter's dsks were early lighted to dispell the ' gloom and darkness. Court was late In assembling. Judge Travis and counsel being en gaged in preparing their instruc tions for the Jury and it was 9:20 before court opened. Jas. Robertson called by the de fense: Mr. Clark examined. Clerk of the court. Had measured de fendant, height 5 feet, 10 U Inches, Knew John P. Thacker. Witness a member of the county Insane com mission. An attempt by Mr. Clark to show that witness had observed Mr. Thacker exhibit a hasty and high temper while witness was sit ting as a member of the commission, was ruled out. Peter Clarence called: Mr. Clark examined: shown photographs marked defendant exhibits Nos. 5, 7. 9, 10, 11 and 12 showing a wagon owned by defendant. Wit ness with Sam Smith had meas ured this wagon. It was 5 feet 2V2 Inches In height. Sam Smith recalled: He corro borated the measurements of Mr. Clarence. Witness had taken charge of defendant's horse which locked as if it had been rode very hard, as it was warm and sweaty. Jos. Darrough called: Examined by Mr. Clark. Owned farm where trouble took place since 1893. Lived within a mile and a half of Mr. Thacker. Knew reputation of John P Thacker and hardly knew what to say as to his being peaceable or quamisome. Couldn't say what It was, . Sheriff Quinton called, examined by Mr. Clark: Sheriff of Cass coun ty. At the inquest on death of John P. Thacker; heard witnesses, Ira Clark, Len Crawford and Earl Albin called and sworn at request of county attorney. By Mr. Gerlng: Witness summon ed the coroner's Jury at coroner's request. Defense rested at 9:40 a. m. The state offered the iranscript of the testimony of Ira Clark before the( coroner's Jury to show a vari ance in his testimony then, and what It was at this trial in which he had changed his evidence as to how the shots were fired and as to what he saw Clarence. This was for Im peachment purposes. A similar offer was made In re gard to the testimony of Len Craw ford. This, also was for Impeach ment purposes.. Mr. Clark offered several que-stlons and answers ofthls SPECIAL EXCURSION RATES EAST: Daily low round trip rates, with tbirty days limit, in clTect early in June to New York, Jersey Coast Resorts, Boston, Montreal, Portland, Me., and other prominent eastern resorts. Somewhat higher round trip rates daily, with all Summer limits, to New Mnglanrl, St. Lawrence River, Atlantic Coast and New England Resorts Also desirable round trip rates ' Wisconsin, Michigan, etc., including Like Journeys from Chicago to 1'ulTalo and return. Kates, details, destinations, etc., may lo had of your nearest ticktt agent. EXCURSION RATES WEST: Seattle Imposition, California, Pacific Coast Tours, Denver and Colorado Resorts, lllack Hills, Hig Horn mountains, Utah, Yellowstone Park circuit through scenic Colorado and Yellowstone and dardim-r gateways. Ilomcseekers rates first and third Tuesdays. You can reacu all western Sur.nr.er resorts on very desirali'e rates this Summer. Call on nearest ticket agent for special tT. , . nnblir.it ieit-.s rnviriiif nnv ui strin tour. wmm KtUT. 0. f. witness to explain some of the dis crepancies in his testimony.' Lee Thacker called: Examined by "Mr. Gerlng. Knew Len Crawford. Mr. Gerlng sought to show by this witness that his father never used vile language and epithets but the court ruled this out. W. C. Ramsey called: Is county attorney and as such had looked up the evidence in this case. Was with George Saxon at the Darrough farm. At that time Sam Redmon said he did not know anything about it that he was in the house telephoning. The witness also met Redmon In front of Donat's saloon in Platts mouth and after shaking hands with him, asked what Redmon was do ing back here and he said he was to testify for Clarence. Witness said "I thought you knew nothing about it, and Redmon answered "That time I was not under oath." John Vanhorn called. Examined by Mr. Gerlng: Lived near Union for 26 years. Knew Sam Redmon about three months. Redmon talked to witness about six hours after the trouble. Redmon said he was in the house and didn't see it. By Mr. Clark: He didn't say he didn't see the shooting. Fred H. Black called. Exam ined by Mr Gerlng: Lived in Plattsmouth 40 years. Had been sent by Messrs. Ramsey and Ger lng to the Darrough farm on Sat urday afternoon with Messrs. Ram sey, Gerlng and McCulIough. Saw the crib In question. Looked through 13th and 14th cracks. Studding about a foot and a half or two foot apart. Size 2x4 inches. The closer one got to the studding the more the view would be obstructed. Looked through cracks on both sides of the opening about about 4 or five feet each side. Mr. Ramsey near the water tank also Asa McCulIough. Through the crack he could see Mr. Ramsey north of the tank, but only about to his elbow when he was west of the tank. Could not see the belt. Witness also testified as to other experiments with bodies pn the ground in the position Clarence and Thacker occupied. Other ex periments were also made to- show that witnesses for the defense could not have seen the things they claim ed to have seen through the cracks In the corn crib. Mr. Clark cross-examined: 15th crack not measured. The 14th and 15th boards were off but were put on while there. There was no corn In the crib. Witness did not experi ment away and back from the crack. Mr. Clark moved to strike out all ditions were not the same as at the the testimony of the witness as conditions were not the same as at the time of the affray and not con tradictory to any witness. Over ruled. Asa McCulIough swern. Mr. Ger lng examined: This witness was 6 foot 1 Inch high. He testified to various experiments made at the Darrough farm on Sunday, June 6. The object being to show witnesses, for defendant could not have seen what they claimed at the time of the trouble. Ills testimony was to rebut that of Sam Redmon partic ularly. Mr. Clark made no cross-examination of this witness Lee ThacKer called: Mr. Gerlng examined. He sought to show the height of the corn sheller. A fight on this was made by Mr. Clark and a warm argument followed. The state sought to discredit and rebut Redmon'8 testimony by this testi mony. Judge Travis ruled out any testimony regarding the height of the sheller. The case dosed at 10:45 a. m. County Attorney Ramsey opened the arguments at the close of the taking of testimony and after a short recess. He spoke during the remainder of the morning session, taking one hour and a quarter for (Continued oon Page 3.) SUMMER W, L. PICKETT, Ticket Agent. , Ocira. (tel.