Daily
, WEATHF.R F0BCAST.
Tor Nobrnska- l ir nfi-1 wginer.
l or Lnvn - ("otwH ; wanner
I'or weather trpott bo pnna 2.
NEWS SECTION
PAGES 0!TE TO EIGHT
VOL. XL NO. 204.
OMAHA. SATURDAY MOIINI.Mi. FKUKTAl, Y 11, 1!H 1 - SIXTKKX IWtiKN.
Sl.Nf5I.l-: nl'Y TWO (-KNTS.
The Omaha
13 EE
Y
T AFT TO FARMERS
FOR RLWROCITY
.President Explains Treaty in Address
it National Corn Expoiition Agri
culture Will Be Benefitted.
"ALL WILL BE THE GAINERS''
.Resources of Northwest to Be Made
Available to People.
GREETED WITH GREAT APPLAUSE
American Tiller of the Soil Will Re
main King.
NOT A MERE POPULAR APPEAL
President Delves lato Fig-are In Half
tantlatloa of Definite (.rnrnl
Working Agree
ment Clnnif.
COLlMBt'fl. O.. Kelt. H -Carrying for
ward his campaign for Canadian reciproc
ity. President Taft today made a direct ap
peal vi me American mrmer on msi issue,
lie declared that the Impression which had ,
gone abroad that reciprocity with the j
dominion would Injure the farmer whs en-1
tlrely without foundation and bv statistics '
and argument he sought to lend actual j
proof to his assertion". I
Mr. Taft declared without reservation i
that the reciprocal agreemeiit with Camilla
would be a benefit rather hn a detriment
to the agricultural Interest of this country,
lie aald he stated this in answer to the
criticism which bad been directed ugainn
the measure presumably on the part of the
farmer.
As for himself, the president said he felt
thnt the undoubted general benefit of the I
pending agreement would entirely vindicate I
those who are responsible fqr It. The great
est reason tor the adoption of the agree
ment, he argued. Is the fact that It will
unite two countries with kindred people Most of the daily papers eulogized the ad
and lying together across a wide continent nilral's notable career. The radical press
In a commercial and social union to the criticised his political activities,
great advantage of both ! When Admiral lord Charles Beresford
"Such a result," added the president.
f "duea nut need to be justified by a nice
balancing of a pecuniary profit to each.
Talks to Farmers.
Mr. Taft'i address, the first of hla pres
ent trip Into the middle west, was drliv
eied at the National Corn exposition In the
auditorium at the state fair grounds. It
waa because of the agricultural character
of hla surroundings and the presence of a
great many of the Influential farmers of
this section that the president chose to
take up arguments In behalf of the pro
posed agreement front the standpoint of
the agriculturalist.
The auditorium, which has a seating
capacity of mora than 4,000, waa crowded
to overflowing. The crush about the doors
was so great that (he services of a soore
Of policemen were called for.
Mr. Tuft's aililreas tuui listened to with
the leeKt lliert a rut he waa warmly
applauded at Intervals. The presidents
.peech wa. not framed merely a. a ppt-1
lar appeal to a class, but consisted In
large part of figures In substantiation of!
definite general claims.
For instance, ao far aa lh corn raisers
are concerned, Mr. Taft showed that the
total Canadian yield was but six -tenths of J
l per cents ol the total production in tha
United States.
American Com King.
"Certainly, with resiiect to corn." he
added, ' the American farmer la king and
will remain so, reciprocity or no reelp-
roclty."
This ttatement elicited
quick restmnse
from tha big audience and the demonstra-
tton was repeated when the president. In
clovlng. aald:
"Let the agreement be adopted and go
Into operation und In six mouths the farm-
era on the border, who now have fears,
will rejoice In this great step toward, a holiday In observance of Lincoln a birth
closer business and social relations with! day.
our neighbor. The whole country, farmer,
manufacturer, railroad compa.iy, middle
man,' warehouse man, all will ' bu the
gainers."
"I am a republican, aald the preai-
dent.
"and the republican party has
alway advocated and pursued
a pulley
of protection to A
and manufacturers.
Fr :n7r.:!Tw6 Hundred True
the policy had little or no limita
tion. It wa thought that tariff on pro
tected produces could not be too high,
that If all foreign product were excluded
competition would stimulate production
and reduce It cost and It price.
Prateetloa Modified.
"The temptation to deatroy competition
by combination became ao great, however,
that the party In It platform modified It
policy and Imposed the limitation that tha
tariff should be limited for purpose of pro-
tectum to the difference between the cot
of production in this country and the cost
of production abroad with an allowance
for a reasonable profit to the American
producer.
The principle of production thus staled
.takes away the Justification for any tariff! N Brker. vlnA Tr. , ..
whatever by way of protection of articles mmd Kilt,.Thr Mts
Imported from a country where the comll- Urlvea Oat to Hrm'.
tton as to labtr and other circumstance j
aro the r.ame . and thus make the VIRORCI. Finland: Feb. 10 -The Ice break
cost of production m'.'lani.aily the same. Ulg veste returned today after a fruitless
Canada it our
tor on the north
for J.UQ s ll )r.iilatlon Is F.ngltsh.
rVutrh .in.'. Frt ... '' soil ia like ours,
it traditiiiii t- same a our. Its
language la u'Jit. It climate la temperate
like our, except that It growing season
are shorter and It cannot raise corn In any
great quantities,
it ha a free populur government with
g wage earning clavs a Intelligent and aa 1
well paid as our, it I difficult to see In
what respect Its farmer have any ad
vanlaga over our own except a virgin soil
In the far northwest. I
W III Not Hart Farmer. I
"How U the farmer to be hurt?" he
asked. He then took up the effect It would
have on corn and wh ai prices. In value of
farm land In thl country and milling In
dustries In thla country.
He declared that "In respect to corn the
A me Heart farmer I king and will remain
ao. reciprocity or no reciprocity
As in w heat, he said the domestic Driea
1. governed by to world price and that '
the ..nling of any part of Canada', sur- ,
plu. through our country Instead of
through Canada to be milled or to be ex-
ported without milling will not perceptibly!
vr materially affect the price of wheat for
our fr...er. I
The v.lu. ef farm lands, he ld. I. af-
fectcd by the pronlmlty to market more
than by any other elemvnt ar.d he main
tained the American farmer would atlll
hae the advantage In thl respect. II I
iCouunued on Fourth Pag )
Eleven Dead and
Six Missing in
Mine Disaster
aaaaaaaaaaaBBaB)
Explosion Wrecks Lower Workings of
Cokedale Colliery Near Trinidad
Rescuers Apshyxiated.
TRINIDAP. Colo.. Feb. 10 -To the lift
of nine known dead and s'x missing In
I the Cokedale mine at the time of the ex-
, plosion last tilgut, today were added the
' names of K. . Sutton. assistant supcrln-
tendent of the mine, anil Robert Meek, a
Colorado Fuel and Iron volunteer rescuer,
I who lout their Uvea while trying- to roach
the missing men.
Sutton overestimated the amount of I
oxygen In his helmet and fell a vlct'm to
the black damp.
Meek fell unconscious nfler venturing
ahead of the air circuit and died a few
minute after being carried out.
Five bodies were located this morning
and will be brought out anon. A number
of recner have been overcome by the
black damp.
Ir. T. J. Forham of Soprla wan seriously
Injured near the mouth of the. mine early
today when he fell off a high trestle In
the darknrsa. Oood order Is mulntHlned
about the mouth of the mine and In the
camp, avoiding the harrowing scenes so
frequently enacted about mines following
s disaster.
Admiral Beresford
Retires from Navy
He Entered the Service Fifty-Two
Years Ago at the Age of
Thirteen.
LONDON, Feb. 10. Admiral Iord Charles
William Lie l.a IJoer Beresford 1m 65 yeais
old today, and by virtue of the, age limit
clause is retired from the active Hat of
the British navy. He has held no appoint
ment since Ida surrender on March 21. I'.HJD,
of the command of the channel fleet.
hauled down hla flag as commander of the
channel fleet he had rounded out fifty
years of service in a career diKtlngulshed
for professional ability and personal gal
lantry which made him one of the most
popular men of England and a figure of
world Importance.
His retirement was credited generally to
friction with the admiralty board. He had
been a severe critic of the management of
the navy when he was serving In parlia
ment. I-ord Beresford entered the navy at the
age of 13 and waa In command of the Con
dor at the bombardment of Alexandria and
ervd on Lord Wolseley' staff In the Nile
expedition of 1SS4-5.
Two New Names in
T,AT vl flAn
W A 111 rV Utlll I,r,L
. ..
slight Variation in Monotony of Bal-
. ,. '
' loting for Senator at
Albany.
ALBA NT, N. Y.. Feb. lO.-The monotony
f the tlajy ,Bllot for United states sena-
lor waa varied today by the Injection of
,t - o new names Into the contest. One
I vote was shifted from John 1. Kernan to
; tleorge L. Klves and another from Mor-
Kan J. O Krlen to J. Hampden Dougherty.
I Mr. Rives Is a former corporation coun-
tt rt Keu. Viti-lf lilv VI r I InnirliAptv mra.
! a member of the Ivln's commission, ap-
Pointed a revise the charter of the city
of New York. There was no quorum at
today's session, which marked the twenty
first Joint ballot since the deadlock began.
There will be no quorum tomorrow and
possibly none on Monday, which will be
The twenty-first ballot follows:
Democrats Hheehan. 8: Hhopard, 4; Ker
nan. S; Littleton, 2; Kulzcr, 1; Glynn, 1;
O'Brien, 1; I'arker, 1: George L. Rives, 1;
J. Hamden Dougherty, 1. Republican I
' pew, 4. Total vote cast,
No quorum.
Bills at Danville
Grand Jury in Vote Buying Inquiry
Makes Partial Report
to Court.
DANVIIJ.E. III.. Feb. 10. This afternoon
, the Vermillion county grand Jury, which
' has been Investigating vote selling In the
j county, presented a partial report In court
; The report contalna 219 true bills and lx-
ten no-bllt. Jt 1 stated a large number
of the bills are for vote selling and perjury.
FINNISH FISHERMEN LOST
I ,..rch for the Ice floes upon which 15S fish
mini have been adrift for several days.
It Is believed that all have perished, one
hundred men belonging to the same fishing
party were rescued after the Ice floe broke
away In a gale, but their companions, be
lieving that they were In no immediate
danger, refused assistance.
I Dog Gives Police
Trousers Worn by a Robber
Uetectlves are seeking for the perpetrator
of a daylight robbery at the Burlington
station on a clue brought In by a dog.
Teddy, common cur, who for meritorious
service has been made mascot for the bag-
f acvlci
room, force, at the Burlington .tatlon.
brought In the clue. The clue consul, of
the m.Jor portion of the west one-half of
robber trouer.
A tattered tramp entered the baggage
room, of the depot Friday morning and
made mi) with small trunk In his arm.
! Teddy, the pip. much on the qui vlve.
up the pur.utt with a loud c.n.n. vo-
1 calitatton. lie aiiaccea miuwi tu mi
' neinr down the railroad vards.
The dog persisted in the attachment until
part of lb trousers of the tramp parted
company with tha wearer.
HOUSE MEM15EI!S,J
A
DELAY MEAST
failure or Committee vvv , nd
Means to Report Reef, ,.ty Bill
May Be Significant.
ACTION EXPECTED DURING DAY
Body Will Meet This Morning to
Agree on Report.
REPRESENTATIVES INSTRUCTED
Slightest Mishap at This Late Stage
Will Be Vital to Plans.
GOES TO THE SENATE NEXT WEEK
Friend Klrrtlng Kf r Kffort to All
iance It Hapldl Insurgents
In Drnat Likely til lie
Opposed.
(From a Stuff Correspondent.)
WASHINGTON, Feb. 10. (Special Tele- J
gram ) The friends of Canadian reciprocity :
In the administration rank and in con- !
grcss met with another diappolntmcnt to
day when the house ways and means com
mittee postponed action until tomorrow.
This course of the committee was .some
thing of a puzzle to the open advoca'o of
the hill. The confusing problem came when
democratic members of the committee, wnu
had been Instructed by the party caucus to
vote for the measure, assented to a lurthcr
postponement.
To reach some sort of comprehension of
the Intricacies that Involve the fate of this
measure It must lx borne In mind ih.it a
majority of the ways and means committee
la openly and publicly committed to Its
support, vet In the face of this majority a
motion to further delay action for one dr.y
j Is carried. Thla may mean much or It may
mean little, but when It la remembered that
only three weeks remain to this congress
It is a fair Inference that some of the pro
fessed aupportera of the bill are not 1-ea.lly
enthusiastic In Its behalf. Every day of
delay In sending the bill to the scnata Itli
the favorable endorsement of the holme
means another nail in the coffin, of
reciprocity.
Favorable Action Expected.
The ways and means committee will
meet tomorrow morning and McCall and
the other members who stand with him
for the bill expect to get a favorable re
port ordered, but as It will be the last day
of the week they can hardly expect to get
the bill before the house until next week;
then It must take the routine course of
legislation and It may be several days mora
before It get to the senate.
I
In the senate the measure must take Its
tegular course ot reference to the finance
committee and there undergo due con
sideration. Then, should It cotno from the I
finance committee with a favorable report, j
ithe b' """ '"nM d'rwt competition.
a a matterO .uomsMw-atlon.- witlL-voguUir i
appropriation bill actually leipilred for
tho support of the government. To say
nothing of the active and aggressive op
position, these contingencies must all be
considered In estimating the ultimate fate
of the bill. While the Insurgent republi
cans of the senate, with two exceptions,
refuse to declare their fixed purpose to
vote against the hill, it Is believed they
will array thomaelvea against the measure.
Action In Committer.
The committee had the McCall bill
embracing the term of the agreement
under consideration for more than one
hour today. Mr. Mann, who favored the
wood pulp and print paper provision, dis
cussed these features In detail. The vote
In the committee tomorrow will be close,
but advocate of the agreement ussert
confidently that the bill will be ordered
favorably reported.
Mr. Faync, chairman of the committee,
waa too III today to be present and Mr.
Uttln of West Virginia wa detained by
other d ii tie and at their request action
wua deferred.
At the conference of democratic senator
today, no action wa taken In regard to
the Canadian reciprocity agreement. It
wa decided to adjourn to meet again
Tuesday. There was no discussion of the
tariff board measure, but a revolution was
adopted calling upon the committee on
rulea to provide more commodious quarter
for the minority conference.
Senator Young Will Be
Candidate Next Year
Iowa Senator Issues Statement
Which He Says He Will Begin
Campaign Soon.
in
DES MOINES. Feb. 10. Senator Lafay
ette Young today Issued thla statement:
"Believing that tha political Issues now
engaging the attention of the country
should be thoroughly discussed In
Iowa and the thirty-fourth general as
sembly having ao far refused to submit
the short term senatorshlp to the people, I
hereby announce myself aa a candidate for
United State senator at the primary to be
held In June, 1912. I further announce that
I shall canvass the state, beginning al
most Immediately.".
Today'a ballot follow:
Kenyon. 45; Young, 16; Funk. 19; Garst, 1;
George W. Clarke. 2; Henry Wallace, 1;
Porter (dm ), (4; absent, 2. Necessary to
elect, 79.
Sample of
The thief set down the trunk. The lack
of trousers handiclpped him in the pursuit
of his design.
While the tramp disappeared among the
boxcars Teddy returned to the bay sate
room, waving the captured section of
trousers. Then he led a friendly baggage
man to the purloined trunk a block away.
The police have only to match the sample
brought In by Teddy and the thief will be
In their hand
Teddy' heroic work In the recovery of the
trunk 1 but the latest of his demonstra
tions of canln wisdom. He guards the bag
gag room office with care, barring all In
truders. At 11 ) o'cluek each morning he
goea to the cafe door und barks for lunch
In return for this favir he allows "Bosn"
of the culinary dtp Iment to enter the
baggage rooto.
A S
,,,,1 l i!J'J;MHvip? iP J
. til .1 i ,.k ? ! ll
I III! II II H.ll ! I "'B ill, ' I ' ' ,i 1 i 1 . - '". w. r 1 II III! I I 'I. I ,
, if .IN .ifi mmm J
From the New York Herald
MEXICAN TROOPS DEFEATED
, .
Assault On IllSUrrCCtOS Position at
, Mulata Unsuccessful.' "
BATTLE LASTS FIVE HOURS
American Troop on Opposite Side of
Hirer Frrejarntlr fader. Klre .
Charge that (isssrra Fired
on Women aad Children.
MULATA. Mm., Feb. ll (Via' Presldo
and Mai fa. Tex. Feb. 1M -Mexican force,
under General Luqe have sustained an
other defeat In the attack on Insurrectos
whom they have been fighting In this vi
cinity for the last week. Today the fed
erals assaulted the lnsuneclo force enk
trenched about Mulata. They were re
pulsed after a battle lasting five hour.
Frequently during the assault American
troops on the oppoalte side of the Rio
Grande were under fire. Shells from field
guns used by the federals crossed the river,
bursting dangerously close to the men of
Troop H. of the Third United State cav
alry, which patroled the river bank. Jt I
declared by witnesses that frequently the
federals, chagrined at the frultleasness of
their assault deliberately turned their gun
at group of women and children, who had
sought refuge on the American side of the
stream. One shell from the federal' fire
burst near Captain William ef the cavalry,
killing an Insurrerto. who wa watching
tha battle from tha American aide.
Federals Forced to Withdraw.
The federal withdrew aJter fierce fight
ing. It I expecleo that despite their losses
they will renew the attack tomorrow (Fri
day). The Insurrecto had been warned that
federal soldier were coming. They took
post on a hill near the town, In ths adob
houses and behind the bank of an Irriga
tion ditch. The federal approached In bat
tle Una with Infantry next to the river,
cavalry on tha right aid and artillery In
the center.
After ahelllng the town at long range the
soldier advanced and tha Insurrectos
opened fire. The hotteet fight took place
along the ditch. Twice the federala cap
tured the ditch, but each time were driven
out by the rebel. In the last charge the
Insurrecto were led by a Scot, F. 8. Mc
Combs, and an American. Seven Mauser
rifle were captured In thl charge.
The federal numbered 226. according to
their own announcement. The Insurrectos
had 200 men in Mulata. The Mexican ol
dler. were commanded, by General Luqu
and Colonel Dorante. the Insurrecto. by
Torrlbo Ortega and Kmllio Salgado.
krvrral Killed aad Woaadrd.
It is Impossible to estimate tha number
of killed today. The bodies of eight sol
dier have been atrlpped of their weapon,
but many more were carried off the field.
Only one insurrecto, Ernlllo Lopes, wa
killed.
Custom Inspector Tom Herrlnee and Lee
GrtgMby were fired upon by Mexican sol
dier and their pack horses were shot.
During the fight Deputy Marshal Eugene
Warren disarmed several refugee. Cap
tain William has notified General Luqu
that there must be no more firing aero
the river.
More Troop to Gaard Border.
EL PASO, Tex.. Feb. 10. -Colonel Sharpel,
commanding the Cnlted State troop, wa
advised today that additional troops would
b sent here at one to guard the border,
NOG ALES, Art., Feb. 10. Fund in the
Mexican bank In Nogale. Sonora, have
been transferred to the bank here.
WATERLOO TKtl IIKH IS M El)
Pareal Charges that Whipping H e
eelted aased Death of Boa.
WATERLOO, la., Feb. 10 A civil suit
asking UOXi damages wa. filed here today
against J. K Hrenlser, a school teacher, by
A. E. Canfleld. who charge that hi 12-year-old
son. Samuel, died a a result of a
whipping admlalatarad by th Instructor.
McKinley's Legacy
illU.Vr1.!!
I ' i .. i it 1 I 1 1 .': il i iK'tiiitli
' , r i iV! H i f L LLUl-LliUillU
..HlliJVi II
mm
Andrew Carnegie
r Gives Advice to Girls
, i
a .i
Steel King Says Maa May Make Gaud
. Husband Even if He is a
Millionaire.
, NEW YORK, Feb. 10. "Don't refuse a
man simply because he Is a millionaire,"
was a bit of matrimonial advice 'which
Andrettr-Carnegle gave to a group of work
ing girls , employed on a magazine which
the steelmaker was inspecting . Mr. Carne
gie made hla little talk on the doubtful
advantage of being born rich and the young
women told today what Mr. Carnegie said.
'Moat millionaire' wives are not happy,"
declared Mr. Carnegie. "They have too
many luxuries nd have no mental re
sources to fall back on. Borne of iny part
ners have been unjustly criticised for what
was not their fault, but the fault of their
wives. Don't refuse a man simply because
ha is a millionaire. I would rather be born
poor than a millionaire. I have had some
experience In both directions. 1 have in.nie
forty-two or forty-three millionaires In my
time, but 1 want to say that the only right
a man ha to wealth lies In his acquiring
it by some useful labor.
"The great trouble with the wealth of
today I that the sons of nillllonalre do
nnf realise the necessity of being of use
to the community."
Body of Miss McColluin
Found in Other Orypt
Purpose of Robbery Apparently Was
to Secure Costly Medals from
Some of the Caskets.
ERIE, Pa., Feb. 10. It wa discovered
late this afternoon that tha body of Mrs.
Anna M. McColluin had not been removed
from the Scott mausoleum In tha Erie cem
etery. Tha vault contain twenty-four
compartment and the body waa found in
one of these unmolested. It Is now be
lieved the robbery of the mausoleum wsa
perpetrated for the sole purpose of secur
ing tha costly metal on
caskets.
lomi of the
BATHTUB COMBINE LOSES
Judge DrslMs Orerrole Demarrrr Bon1 lK udde of Omaha arrived in
f Individual Uefeadant I Washington today to attend the wedding
to alt. jof hla sister. Margaret R. Geddea, to W.
DKTROIT, Mich . Feb. 10. Federal Judge A- Johnston, an attorney-at-law of thla
Denlson today overruled th demurrer of city. The wedding will take place Febru
the individual defendants in the uit of the rv 1; t noon at the residence of Mr,
government against th so-called bath tub O. W. Smith on Columbia road north
tru.t. t.
Timothy Healy Wins Contest
for Seat in House of Commons
DUBLIN, Feb. 10 Timothy Healy's con
test to nullify th election of Richard
Hasleton, who at the' last election turned
out "tha Isnmael of nationalism politic."
from the aebt for th north dlvl.ion of
lAuth. whlc he had held for eighteen
years, proved ucceasful today.
Th case ha been befor the court at
Dundalk for several days, during which
Healy presented evidence of much Intimida
tion and rioting at tha polling. Hasleton'
attorney consented to having th election mon the independent candidate declared
declared void without offering a defense. h wouid proteat ths election, alleging
Th matter ha not ended, however, a , gross corruption and intimidation, ilazle
Healy asserted his right to introduce all i ton ws returned unopposed foi the north
hi evidence In aupport of hi charges, division of Gal was .
which Includi. bribery, and the court d- i Ilrly d.e not claim the seat now de
cided t hear, IL ! clared vacant and a new election will b
Tb fight In Ui Louth constituency wa I ncry.
MAY GET HEADQUARTERS
New Postal Division Includes Ne
brtuka, .Wyoming and Colorado.
CHANCE TO FURTHER CLAIMS
feconrt Assistant Poatmasfer (rneral
Who Will Make Recommendation
Kay Omaha Will Re Heard
Gladly.
, (From a Staff Correspondent.)
WASHINGTON. Feb. 10. (Special Tele
gram. ) I'nder the potofflce bill a new
postal dlvlHlon Is created embracing . the
states of Nebraska, Wyoming and Colorado
and should the bill become a law, un
doubtedly Omaha, , Denver and Cheyenne
will be after the headquarter.
Assistant Postmaster General Stewart
assured Victor Rosewater of The Bee to
day, who Is actively interested In the mat
ter, that the location of headquarter,
would be muHt largely decided on postof
fice efficiency, but that the subject would
not be taken up until after congress ad
journs. ,
Mr. Kosewatcr wa Informed that If
Omaha desired to be heard consideration
would be given either city or commercial
club and that every effort would be made
to locale the new headquarter satisfac
torily. Tho findings of second assistant
postmaster general will be sibject to re
view by the postmaster general.
Victor Hosewater took luncheon today
with Postmaster General Hitchcock and
Victor .Mason, aNHlstant aecretary of the j
national republican committee, at the
Metropolitan club.
Praia for Borglam's Work.
The pedestal for a sculptured head of
Abraham Lincoln, which has had a promi
nent place In the rotunda of the capltol
for a year or more, wa delivered today
from the studio of Gutzon Borglum, now
of New York, formerly of Omaha.
Borglum' Lincoln head la considered by
all who knew th civil war president to be
among the very atrongeat studies by thla
distinguished artist, and since it ha been
on public view the artist ha received let
ters of commendation on bl work from
uch men aa Speaker Cannon and Senator
Cullotn, both of whom were personally ac
quainted with the martyred president. The
pedestal was presented to congress by
Fugene Meyer, Jr., of New York.
one of the most bitter In the recent cam
paign. The Redmoudlte brought all their
forces to bear against O'Brien's chief lieu
tenant, mil Hie tfui i.t iL.iu
j BhadoW(.u ,h, tha(rln , th. H,dlnon
camp at William Redmond failure to oust
o ill ien In Cork City.
j Kxclling ene marked th polling free
fight were freouent. and Ilealv hi.n.,.i
at time required police protection. When
It wa announced that Hazleton had se
wurwi nraij mr-tt i m in House or Com-
iMXCMiX WINS IN
15EM0VAL FIGiiT
' House Rejects Capital Bill uii Tin-v'.
Passage by Vote of Fifty-Eight
to Thirty-Eight.
SEVERAL CHAKOL P0SHI0N3
Nine Members Explain Rtascrt for
Position.
! UNFAIRNESS TO LINCOLN URGEL
I Another Measure Framed to Mot
' This Objecticn.
Minn ihnt tMvlslon rn Illll ItM
Come Aiwa at " ',rr
Hnrtos. Tashea Inaae.
a nee BUI.
i From A Staff Correspondents
LINCOLN. Feb. 10. (Special.! Capital
removal was defeated on the final vote In
ithe house today In spite of Wednesday
decision In the committee of the whole t
pass It. The vote w as firt -eight to thirty
eight. It Is the general opinion that the
activity of the Lancaster delegation and
Lincoln cltlKcn during the last few day
in persuading members. aaliiflt till speci
fic measure on the ground that It Is un
fair to Lincoln and the growing belief
among the members that It Is unfair,
caused the downfall of the hill. Nina
members explained their votes In writing,
and Taylor of Hitchcock, tjuackenbush.
Hushce, F.vans, stehblns. Baker. Coltou.
Walte and I '.asset t Rave the unfairness to
Lincoln an a reason.
Hardin said that his constituents In Har
lan county do not want the capital re
move!. H. It. 'MK. the bill defeated. Intro
duced by Bailey and twenty-six others. Th
accusation of unfairness, which, was first
brought by the Lancaster county opposi
tion. Is based upon the fact that a line
Is drawn along the ninety-seventh merl
dlan and no town east of that Is allowed
to compete for the location. The Lincoln
men have been contending that even IC
It Is decided to throw tho question of re
moval open to a vote of the people, and
they do decide for It, there should b iv
territory set aside In which the capital
cannot bo placed and that Lincoln should
have a chance to re-enter the race even
If once shut out by an affirmative vote to
remove. Thla objection has been nnswered
In various ways, but the Idea that perhaps
It waa being made Into a race between
Lincoln and the veWlo field has grown
ami the defeat of the hill was the result.
Roll call on the bill was as follows:
AYKB.
Hllr. HcIllK.r, Mi 'Kltslrk.
Partem, llnnpixtFlir, Prime,
Rimhaill, lloit, HlMll,
Hulls, Kml. - I'lln
Htie. I.asrrn, Iti'lwrt",
Tunill. I.elmsh, "Ml.
KntnmB, I.Wer, Seheele,
Iw!al, Msliser, fHiuli,
Krlrg, Meir. ptfeniskef,
Kuller. Morinrtf, Sink.
(IroMmsn, Murphy, ANfner,
ilruvhor, MrArilie, Hprskfr .
llrrlniijn, Meianli).
NAYS.
Annrn, Itsller. MrKUlt.
Raker. llHrilin, Nelaon,
tiaivlay, Hla, Niirlmi.
! ei i, llainald, Nnntgnn.
Hnlanil, Hrrr, Nillaman.
Prai-hl, lli.llliea, I'ntu,
Hunb.a. Iliiuah, Tula.
I la Inn, J"hn. Wuaraf ntiinh,
l olten. .luhnaua, Sanborn,
lal7.nl, Jiaien, SI"rtVlar,
Hurt, Klra. Fknan.
K.as?r, KuliMlc, Hnilllt.
Mamhcriier, Unitnejr. Kial.Hns,
KIIik, Mi. Kwan,
Kvan. Mali au, Tajlm
Kllly, ' Mllinr. lit Mirrlik,
Call, Mcxkeit, ' TaOor
(tanitv. Miimly, if Ullrhcixl
(Jeri1&, Mn'ire, Walte &.
dilatation, Mrtlrlland,
Halley, introducer of the measure, said
after it wa over: "Tho fight had to be
carried rlKht here Into tho enetnle' coun
try and the Lancaster people ere able
finally to defeat us by superior organl-a-tlon."
.
Prince of Hall, the strongest eupporter
of the bill, aald: "We have a new bill ihat
will eliminate every possible rhama of
complaint for unfairness ami we will ma V o
these member who have been using that'
an excuse either change their vote tr
tell a better reason for opposing It."
The iew. bill . introduced this afternoon
and signed by Bailey of Buffalo and Prince
and Sin kof Hall provide that the ques
tion of capital removal aha II 1a ubm!ttd
In a regular election and If It la curled
every town in the atate which ran get a
petition signed by 5o0 citizen can enter
the competition. Then the city tm-elvlns
a majority of the vote will get the Meat of
government.
The assertion ' that th wets were the
supporters of the capital removal bill was
discredited by an analysis of the votes on
th question. Those against It war six
teen wets and forty-two dry and for It
thirty-two dry and six wet. Tha division
does lean In that direction, however, and
that question may have had some Influence
In spite of the emphatic denials of the
western member.
Bill to atoa Coarslngr.
Thos who changed their votes today from
aupport to opposition on capital removal
were Bassett, Iloland. Hrecht. Bushee, F.g
genberger, Hardin. Holmes. Lindsay, Ma
trau, McClelland, Nelr, Nelson, Nurdgren,
Taylor of Merrick, Taylor of Hitchcock
and Walte. Those who changed from op
position to support were Fuller of Seward
and Dofial of Butler.
The house debated the humane bill of
Taylor of Hitchcock against coursing meets
for some time this morning and finally rec
ommended It for passage. The debute
brought out a number of Incriminations of
brutality and as a counter charge pour
sporismanshlp. Foot hall and baxe ball
and horse racing were dragged Into the
discussion as similar amiinemeiits and no
less reprehensible. Murphy of Saline county,
a resident of Friend, was th strongest op
ponent of th bill, as the national coursing
meet Is held In his town.
II. R. 4, appropriating $.,4 0X1 for a new
science building for the Wayne Normal,
was recommended for passu ge, and also II.
It. 202. by Baker nt York, which is de
signed to make the enforcement of the anti
pas law easier by making It simpler to
prove the fact of use.
Members Piialala Vote.
The following explanations of votes on
capital removal were handed to the
sivaker:
Evans of Adams Mr. Speaker: Vnder this
bill !n per cent of the people may be de
nied the right to vote their preference on
the location of the tsplial. That is suf
flclent reason to defeat any bill. I further
state that not one of my constituents hn
arked me to aupivort thl bill.
Stebbin. of DawsonMr. Suiaker: If th.
peopl desire a I he nee to voie on a fair
capital removal proposition, I think tiny