TIIJ3 OMAHA DAllTl' BEK: TliV&SDAY, JUSE 13, 1901. mini sides or THE EIRE board case presented FIRE BOARD IS ENJOINED Jidgi Eittlla dtrt Decision in Farer of Chief B.d.ll. APPEAL 'WILL , BE- TAKEN AT ONCE Court Hold Hint 1'imtr of Trlnt In Vested Jointly In Mnjor nml (.'My Council Mined on Pii r uirr Drclolon, Jurigo Lee Kstelle granted a temporary Injunction yesterday which prevents tho Hoard of Kl-o nnd Police Commissioners involving pectlng ttuit nil of It would stand, nnd that uiero in ii prriumpiion 10 mm encci. "While, therefore. In the one ense the net slioiilil ho ssutalncd unles the validity In clear, in ine otner tne wnoie anoiiKi inn unless It Is manifest the portion not op nosed to the constitution can stand by itself, and that In the legislative intent it was not to be controlled or mociineu in Its construction Hnd effect by tho part wmcn was void. Illshop, In "Statutory Crimes," pase h, savs: "Courts do not close their eves to what they know of tho History or tne country and of thu law, of the state of tho law ut a particular time, of nubile net'pMfltlp frit und other like thine. Judge Davis, in a case in tne m c, a,, ni Phko 72, says: "Courts, In conatriilnR the statutes, may with propriety recur to tho history of the time when It was passed, nnd this Is frequently necessary In order to ascertain tne reason ns wen as i ne meanlni; of particular provisions of It. There Is tin more striking Illustration of that, as 1 recall It, than tho various state ments mat were mime on me nuesuoua tne rourteonin and nncemn t.nlUn n t t It a .tilt, ffltilu n.fitti. MnnrDN. I :...'." ".'..?. .An .. Jl.&w per annum, nnynuic monmiy. tw iNBO., me cuuri nun very careiui m .., rj.i0 relating to salaries be and Its rnnilrterntlnn of tho several nrovlslons ,,',0,:"' .V1 ?.VK-.in L'?r ....;S.i.. r rccolutlon, which was unanimously adopted Keanlveil. Thnt thrt intnrv nt lltn f-lllnf nf the tiro department bn and hereby Is fixed at ts,w) per annum, payable monthly, nnd that the salary of the assistant chief of the tiro department be and hereby is nxou at ana mat hereby ARGUMENT FOR THE BOARD neViu .n limit lu ".? Vme. t re- Fred U IluRbeo of truck No. 4 filed new canllnir the Invalidity of the same, to that eharces nealnst Chief Hcdell. In which he 0it7 AtUrnij Tile, a Bri.f with th. S'VUM T'Tlu th TL Hcnorabl Court shiners. Arc at 2213 Dewey avenue early Inst Sutur- Tho followlnB Is a copy of tho syllabi: aiiy mornlnR. Ilugbeo declares that Itedell, "Tho act of the leglslaturo of 1857 (Session -.i.i..,,., -n., nr nrnvnrntlnn erahbed him Laws 1597, chapter 10; Complied Statutes, Knout ca,uso r, Provocation, graooeu mm CONTENDS AGAINST REDELL'S STAND .c.r2"- ln'fnr.,11.""mr" '"S; by 'ho"cck' hUed h'm. v c 'b'i J .v. iiuiiiviiij -- O CUHl CUIIlir HUH lllt'U UIUUIVU UUU ninij "uui nro ana ponce coinniir'iuiiem m cmei 01 ,. -the metropolitan class, Is void, as being an ln Authority nnd Hcspcinslblllty of tho l ire nml 1'olUi- llonrd Set Forth Fully and Clearly br Counsel for Defense. nottlon of the act conferring nuthorltv on tho covernor to nnuolnt tho commissioners In handing down tho decision In tho case section 163 would also be Invalid. On the wherein Klre Chief Hcdell asked for an X " ','Z n . ml erU." n" d onrd of Flru and 1 board Is recognized as a valid exercise of unlawful attemnt to deprive the neonle of It was resolved to defer action on the such cities of tho right of local self-govern- nugbee charges until tho right of tho board tU.ent. . . , v.... n .wl r..IA ,V. .nn... Visa lumn Tli nnlnlnn nf Itin I'ourt pnnlnlnn neptlon I " u '" -v.. IK) In Its entirety. No Intlmntlon Is made determined by tho supreme court. mat by reason or tne invalidity or tniu HOT AIR WEALTH STORIES Herman Koimtie Denies .story Oinnlin Mtrlke In Tcins Oil. n f order to restrain the Board from hearing charge, brought gainst Chief ,Xes? .he VoMltuUon tf th. r jol.ee Commissioners from trying him on leglslajlv discretion. This appears from Hedell of the flro denartment and taklnx I i .i, .,n,ni. Mri nr in charges preferred against him, Judgo l'.s- . ' r ,in ,,,,,, i ,,,vm any stens for his removal. I'nlted States they have cone Into the his- telle roferred to a brief that had been Is one of the rights vested In the neotilo Herman Kountzo has returned from a By an agreement entered Into by City lojy, ol l"? ,co.V"v. 1 '',,c . . ' .'.i,- handed him by tho counsel for tho defend- " . "LU",C",,,,1"V".'. 'r. r0"c!rr'u lr'P " no texns on neius ana uenounccs Attorney W. J. Connell and tho attorneys ,nrH nf n.n mnmitutinn in nnter tn eon- ant. Following Is the full text of tho brlof, -xeent in ih .xient the invvmnuin.- i.iv 18 a fabrication tno report innt no nas for the flro chief tho hearing was consld- strue it. which was prepared by V. J. Connell, may prescribe rules to aid the people pf realized auy profits from tho recent dls city attorney: Section lt of tho charter expressly pro- ren Ural ml r..rlnlno- nrH.F W9 tniS CflSe. J minK UIIU we linvo declared an Injunction. This makes It pos thin? tn nld us 111 nasnlntr nil the consiiiutinnnnty or mis net, or oi tins set- the municipalities In the exercise of such covcrtes near Beaumont. He says: right. Co e red In Another Cnc. slblo to talio thh asc to the tuDrcme court ' on m, namely An inspection or tne sec- viues mat nil powers unu uuues connccieu ,, nioio 10 iano mB asc lo me aupriuiB iuuim . .. ,,, .A,nP., nt ,uia riV with nnd liinl.i..ni in ih unnnlnitnunt. re. It also appears from without further delay. The attorneys an- . th . .ime .1.1. nc't was first nasscd .which moval. Kovornment and dlsclollno of the trucla from the opinion nouncod that the transcripts will be pre- i believe was In 15S7: that Is my recollection officers and members of the Fire nnd 1'ollco n"aD,e',ore u"i ll? wc".,a.!' . . ... t ..I nf I ,llinlmtila nf III,, nlll" llr!r llrh I'llles Id StntO OgalllSt Sl'aVO.V, Darca at once anu me case win do uihu ".. .... .. ...... -- i ,.i rim,.i.n it. "Three companies In which I um Inter ested own considerable land In that part decision ot tho supreme court which de- 1 J . I . , .1 iff .m ., . n 1 1 .. ciuiu'i u uuiLiuii ui nuuiiuii ivi li.v .ivj i nr nwnim n n rt nntivBrHiiiii u' tn inA n atnrv rnrprimrn in n innmimnntN iinn rrmnviiin i i, tnu iiiiiuuiitiiiio ui auuii iiiuiiij.- i charter unconstitutional. This section pro- of this city In 1SS7. and prior thereto. hire set forth with much detail. !!?'!'' n!i element of local solf-govcrn- and Is believed vlded that Omaha should have a Board of L.L'P. S 1. J 'e".A ho myor anrl I; t Hs section void 7. ,.,. . , "TUVi . 17, ",."e.m,VK Mown there In Dm nnrl Pnl r,i Cnimnlsslnnern nnmed hvli...- .,n ,.t .v,i. u,. Vm.. t I n 1 1 !.. .w.,.i.i ,1,,.. , ttn tinnr.l nf I extent that the lawmaklllc lioilv innv ereate Oil discoveries to lilU iUIIUWIUK fs m . . ... . . i . . I Of the court! "The OI ens. ino properly oi iuc icjas t.unu tne one construed ana uattio company is mostly rico lanu; SUDra. denied lOlm, f , l, C.l,ln ! T nn.l Ttnnrnvn. v nuuii: ul wiiiuiiii ma uunri in i iiiiuiu i ... to the higher court In a few days. nm5 i,e "A" 'orv' i'ct to the iloard lol Klro and "oIlS Commissioners. Portion of their own local ofllcors, nn.l nwnt company cons sta n part o tno sue Judgo Kstelle s action was based upon the net Itself, there can bo no two minds In shall be vested In and exercised by said '"soiar as it did so is unconstitutional, tor or tno town or babino rass ana land sur- " I . . . . . .i .. mi . .. t .1 it... I Mill flfrlf fn t ntlilrt flriil iiinliitiln t Hsa . . a . . . . regard to it; tnai is, so ini ns mose ieoie ooaru. ine uunca oi eaiu Dtmru mm mo , J", ii ,, .! rounding tnai town, mis land is wunin n o conccrnci wno are ivn g in u cuy power ana proceauro oi saiu . r,: T' T i.1: V.' . i".'. (Wfntv.llt- miles of thn recent dlsenverles to contain oil. I wont consequence of tho recent look over tho situation. tho governor. It waa held by the supremo am speaking of what Is known by every Flro and I'ollce Commissioners aro void. ' "r" i" usbisi in me exerciso or mien i touna tnai an oi tne on discovered so court that the nnnolntment of such a board "A"" thln the sound of my vole . faP confined to an area of probably 125 . rl . . . . nere ni umi lima ana wnn iuuk nny iiiicrv:ai i mm uui nu iuul-ii ui liny ui oniu jmuvioiuu.i i . . '."v. i .... ,,,i,ii M,,,u .., n by tho governor violated tho guaranty of hn the welfare of tho city of Omaha. At aa assjmes to confer nuthnrlty upon tho chapter 12a, Compiled Btntutes, attempts acres and that while much prospecting has iber of tne governor to appoint tne mcmucrs oi saiu i i'n chkuscv in any one ni ucen uono ana is uoing uono in omcr parts rhLTn 'T'ViVr' "J "r. 'n ?iD' ,l" of what is believed to bo tho district none coniciiiiun ui uuuiiNi'i iui iiic iimiiitiu i u...v. .... ""'""7 utu.--.-i . . .. , . . ,. sumntlon that tno pro- sion 10 iiiscush mai provision must not ne " iu woim umc ihuuikcu uu. nellnn lfiC. nf the net nf Construed as lmillledly HUStllllllntr Its eon- I "nnr enmnnliv linn linil mnnv nffera from one of thoso who did not believe thnt that 1897 authorlilng the governor to appoint stitutlonnllty. A e merely refrain , froni nrfnoetors who desire to devclon the land. four members or tno bonrti was me niauce- ujiiuwimr hii upunun on mo suojcci. - - ----- t j . . uui so iui we uuvu iiitiuu uu ijuiiii uuiqi We may lcaso a part of tho land and will probably develop some of the ground on our own account, but so far wo have tho people whoso affairs they administered, Omnha oimht to be, to use their own ex- Is based on thu assumption thn Consequently the boatd wts reorganized and pression. laKcn out oi noiiucs.-- i was vision contained in too mcmbclB were appointed by the mayor. .v... nn rfhenrlniis remedv that thev were tt-..,i i mi i if en i in f?. nnrl i wn nne nr iiui rev wno i nielli rnr ine naRsairf' or rno nci. in oiiilt i:"" . j .1 i. ... .....i i. i- ,...T.... i... ..ii 1 i. i ..r..i...V . i... .i,.. .,f il... nr. ttui, tinu n in niiinvib ui. i nuiuo, u in v.itiiiiirii timi ,nu f.,,.v ui ...u .. . u . fnA... II..1. n n .i I i --'- in mo ynv in juini iirucn uhviui. ()f us mni it was urged and insisted mar governor to appoint iormea sucn nn essen- , sioorcs nna omcrs mere aro nciore me ior th control nnd government of thn tire nnd tlal part of the provisions relating to the "B. .um,lorl1; Construct Oil the follOWlllir rieCtlOllS Of thO ,.nllon Inrnaa nf tl,o l,.. nf nmnlm .t.nnl.l II..III-.I nf I.-1,., un.l I'nllxn I'lmimllllrniKH UK POint tllO COmtU Clinllter ()f the Comtllled HtattlteB KOVCm- l. ..In.,.,,! t. ihn ,,r n l.nnr.l nf Urn , ra.mlr. Ihnl nil nf nnnlt nrni'lalnni Rhnlllit I'liriiosc of the Iliinctinetit How can It be said that the provision con f on i no governor to np Issloncrn was tho Induce tilnoiwl In Inn l.iin.lu if n l.nn.l nf llrA I In paiililr. Ihnl nit r lng cities of tho inctropolltan class, namely: nmi ,)0co commissioners, to be nimolntcd be declared Invalid. aectimiH iwj lo iii). inclusive: by the governor. Wo all know that. , ,...., ,.,,,. Heetlnn 1M r.iiils uu fnllnws: "In each In n ormcr t.ne city of the metropolitan class there .hall .Matter of I nlKlm. This is not tho first time Buch a conten- l"B of additional polltlcnl power lit the . . ,. Bmollnt of mnnoy In oil lands bo a Board of, Flro and I'ollco Cotnmls- i wua one who said, and stnted It bluntly lion linn been made. It was urged with governor, a negative Is given to such con- nn(' n . . . i' t .i,.i sioners, io consist ot tno mayor, wno simii and boldly on tne streets of Omaha, that much vchemenco by the senior counsel ior n m i uy in rnci mat me law provides be ex-ofllclo chairman of the board, and "you were avoiding Soylhi to fall on plaintiff In tlie ease of State ex rel Wheeler that 'not moro than two of said commls- ruur I'luumrn m mu unj, vnu mum i' ijnaryocus, nnu, worn you iiiko it out or against aiuut, u- eu., p. mv, mvoivinu inis '" .n nun,, iu miui iiuuutui mini iolnted by tho governor." the politics ot the city of Omaha you hnvo Identical act. The following Is' front his or party allegiance. In the argument of this case It seems to t n the politics of the state of Nebraska. brief: "These Invalid provisions are no in- It Is manliest that tho purpose of the mo that It Is practically conceded thnt this um there was not any one at thnt tlmo torwoven with the other parts of the act, enactment was to crente a board for the case turns on the constitutionality of sec- that ever dreamed or thought or Imnglncd and form so essential a part of the wholo management of the tiro and nollce depart- tlon lCrt. On the one side It Is Insisted that anything like tho police commission, ex- nchemo of legislation, that tho ontlro act ment and that the manner of the nppolnt- mo nujirrniH uiim, m mu vnny nifi cepi ns it was to no nppointen ny mo l must bo necla red invalid. y y uuu uuuiu wan thn I& Nebraska, at nae 4S0. Insofar as I rnmrnnr. nnd thnt wnn thn Inrltieement in Ti,., r,,ti,.ii.,u- m tim fnntentlnn of 1 merely Incidental to such nurtinsc. this section KM provides that the governor lmy judgment, taking the history of this cnunncl for defendants In tho same case: Section ie expressly declares that In each shall nppolnt, Is unconstitutional nnd that legislation, to the passago of this net. "Whore a statute contains provisions which city of the metropolitan class there shall mai provmiun oi uruuun im m uui m- namciy, mat u mignt no tnacn out oi nre Invalid or unconslltutionni it tno vnim uyni ' " iiuuiu rnnHiiinsiniiero. .1. ............ ... ,t.n .nennn nf 1 1. n n nl T ll fl f I 11.1 .. . . .. I . ., .. I . . . . . . , . i . . . , 1 .Pl.la lu n illullnnl nrnt'Ulnii ...Vilnl, nn.. ment for enacting tho several provisions fnrmnri nn .Infinite nlnns t lenmeit with relating to a bonrd of fire and police com- t""'1 no dennuo plans, l learned, witn mlssloners for tho eltv of Omnhn? if it l surprise, that It was reported In Omaha claimed that biicIi Inducement was the pine- that Mr. Crolghton and Mr. McShano had In Texas in the Inst few weeks. I nsked Mr. Crolghton about It today and he said that there was not a word of truth in tho roport, so 1 expect It was on a par with tho one respecting our company Many thousands of acres havo changed hands at fabulous prices and some of the people hae paid moro than they can ever get out. At tho same time tho discovery Is a good thing for that part of tho Btnto iiuiciiirnt um jM.nou.. v.. ... iiuiiui-B, unu mo urai ny iu uu 11 .in m nnu invalid portions nru not u tuniii'tini v , . ......... ..,, j .... hnve a consinoraolo imiucnco in the rest of the act can stand. On tho appoint It by the governor. I might say. In , to be Incapable of separation, nnd tho stund Independent oi the mnnner of ap- "na ' ' '" ,, ,, u i,Ji, .nirt other side II is contended that such pro- congratulation of my own view ot tho valid, part Is a complete net nnd not de- polntment. Its commerce The oil Is now being shipped vision wns an inducement to tho passage thing nt the time, that 1 think It haa been penitent upon the part that Is void, the lat- Section 1(57 relates mainly to tho appoint- for fuel, as there are no roflnerlcs at of the tict, hence, that section must fall. t,orno out thnt It got Into politics moro tor alone will bo disregarded and tho re- ment of members pf the board by the gov- h, . ,d h prepared for lllumlnat- In tho brlof that was handed to me yes- lhnn tt ever wns before In the state. That malnder upheld." ernor, and is within tho decision of tho su- wnicn it couia do preparca ior liiumnmi tnrrinv hv ths attornov for tho defendant wnn mv tmlirmeiit then, thnt vnn worn tm, fniiAn,in ia n nnm. nf ihn vitnhi in nremo court in tho Moores ense. ins purposes, altnougn it is claimed mat In this case, if I read It correctly, It Is simply transferring It from local municipal the samo ense: "If a portion of a lcgishv Insisted that that question has been dls- politics to state Politics, nnd It was. .ilvn net I iinennstltlltlniinl nnd it cnll bl posed of; that is, tho constitutionality of The governor, after this net was pacsed. separated from other portions ot the act ness and under this section 1(V has been disposed of. ex- ammlnted a Hoard of Flro nnd I'ollce Cam- .....i n.n inii.r nnfnr..e,l Inriennmlent nf thn Is probably void ccpt so far as tho appointment by the mlssloners and for several years we had, I former, and It further appears that the tin- Section 1D relates to the powers nnd governor, nnd that, In tho case of State think I may snfely say. moro politics In constitutional nart did not constitute such dutlcH of the bonrd nnd Is clearly within mrnlnut Mtuht piled In thn rnsn of state on thn Unnnl nt Flrn nnrl I'nllre ('nmmlgilnn. ... i ,l... nnncn nf ihn nihor thn decision of the siinreme court In thn relation of Wheeler ngnlnst Stuht, reported crs of tho city of Omaha and around about parts of tho law that they would not havo Moores case, which recognizes In terms 111 VOL U, HI- PUKO I hnlrl thn r.nnstltutlonallt and has practically held that that part assailed nnd Judge Norval In his opinion "Tho same rulo obtains In relation to of a metropolltnn city- In the exercise of tho Section ICS prohibits the appointment of tn0 oil Is of a quality which could be tututc, nnd that right to maintain a lire and police depart- Cholern Morbus n Dnnicerons Dlscnae In many Instances attacks of cholera morbus termlnato fatally beforo medicine can be procured or a physician summoned. Tho Bafo way Is to keep at hand a reliable medicine for use In such cases. For this nurnose there 1b nothing so sure ns Cham VI rilC I1U X UlllU uiiiiiiiooiuiigip, unu ...v. uin.iUii3tiiLtiivf.nti. I wniCIl IS UllCOUSlltUllOllUI milY, UllUCl 1U 1 lllv:.t. I ---- - other sections, namely, scotlon Iftl or part if I am right In tho other, that this part operation of the foregoing rule, be rejected Section 170 provides that tho chief of berialn's Colic, Cholera and Diarrhoea pinion, nave neen oi tne section, nameiy, appointment oy tno fr0m a section or sections of a law and nonco snnn do stinject to mo oruers ot tno nemedy. W. K. Bosworth of Lafayette, Alabama, says: "In June, 1900, I had a serious attack of cholera morbus and one dose of Chamberlain's Colic, Cholera and Diarrhoea Remedy gave mo relief In fif teen minutes." For sate by nil druggtats. . of the section which provides for a Board held that that provision of the law was nrts of tho sections of a s oi Fire nnd Police Commissioners, and tho unconstitutional. which Is 'unconstitutional of Purity it a bottle of that sparkling and delicious beverage, ABC &OHEM1AH "Ktmo- nt !! rinMlcd Rrt.ll It is the best of table beers whole some and inspiring. Possesses the true hop flavor. Is an ideal tonic and appetizer. Order Proa C. R. MAY, Omaha. Oar Aftlntr book of Mtnat Mflom 0rmn Bupcen ffMon raqtiMt. Tt AaHrtl)rlf hu III ww. van i v lewjonx na mm v "llottled nt the llrewrrv Only. Never Sold In Iltltk," The Greater Union Pacific Railroad President McKinley's CHOICE of ROUTES PUTS Union Pacific First on List After full arrangements had been made to return anothor way tho head of the Federal Govern ment changed all plans by select ing the Union Pacific for Mra Mc Kinley's homeward journey, thus placing his official seal of approv al on tho Union Pacific as tho quickest, safest and most com fortable route between the Atlan tic and Pacific Coasts. 5t:r STUDY THE MAP 1 . . i sAstf?A' utp or union neinc sn.so Uoitattllt, L..VI4M may, under the ment. rule. he. relected Beet of it, and 169, Ih that opinion, have been of the section, namely, appointment by tho rfom a section or sections of a law nnd pollco shall bo subject to tho orders of tho sustained. -It mat is irut u i can Drum governor, wns nn inducement to ine pas- I what remains bo Blistnlncd, unless tncy aro xsoarn oi i- ire unu i-once i.:ommissioncrs. and Police Commissioners to crente the nollce relief fund. Stetion 1SS nrovldes thnt tho Fire and Polite Commissioners shall be trustees of thu police relief fund and snaih invest tne same from tlmo to time. constitution, section i&'j provides ior. tne aisDursemeni . tt,i. .,.... of tinllce relief fund under Much rules' and statute 'henco regulations oh shall bo' .trirovfd by tho It nurnorts to I Uonrd of Fire and Police Commissioners. I'riiliulile liffet't of Decision. If the blunderbuss of counsel for plaintiff mysoii iu Dcuevo inui, ui tuuino mm nuuiu nK 01 hid ati, iiirn mni bl-uiiiiu iuo inn, lnsonnrabiy conncctca in suosiance. ' dlsposo of this case. That Is the keystone of the nrch. and It Is ,.... .... r nnr. Kt An.ilv 'llu loundntlon: and, you eliminate from this Opinion of the Court. Stulit M"" Apply. chapter Section lfi6. with it necessarily falls Thn fnllnwlnir U from Judiro Harrison's In a very careful readlnK of the caso of .167, 168 and 163, and various other sections, oniXn- "Under tho act or charter of 1R87. tho State aKalnst Stuht I cannot seo thnt I think. whirh tho act " ot 1837 bv Its terms rcnenled the supremo court had any other question Bo that my opinion Is-nnd It Is not nr- fLc0nhnd heen elected a nuroro it, rrom a rcaoinK oi tne opinion, nvea at nosiuy, out arrived at arier con- f nnrn nVP(i i,v tho than tho nUustlon of the effect of the leads- sultatlon with those who nre much more :.?!" ' i""iS ! 'K...r. iVJo IWiirVs ntteinptlPK to limit the terra-or lenrned In tho law than I am ami arrived pWuirl not ho nhrlcleed hv a oxtond tho term, rathcr-of the police mag. at nfter an Investigation and Inspection oi fS , f m; in tfc m Pnt lstmtn nf thin eltv. From a readlnK ot this I this act. and ot an tne authorities thnt :i '. ..r.v i n... n 1 . . miiili nnr. opinion It seems to me that that was what have been presented to mo-that this net "0 0f It as makes the term of ofTlco of a war ubiuiu niu uuiu, tit iui... tun... ik .iv.iitt ...u. ...... InaUleil nn nnn hnml thnt thnt wns nn 111- If It falls, then ducemont to the passage of tho act. and, If Judgment, to sectl ll.tvnn Inunfnr nn If f-iLVn him R term thnt I tho POWer Of Somel wns different from tho term provided by tho of pollco or tho chief of the fire depart miiM ii rinTthrM wnn lnHteiiil of the con- 11 lno niuiidcrouss or counsel ior piamtin we nro relegated. In my LH.minnnT term oi t wo veara Is of no cf- ls rcaiiV It would knock out each nnd Ion 72 of the act ns to Si'V U ? beinc letermlnod hat the ?nw ?s III- of tho loregolng provisions and would l, 'lf .S!?'?' HhoronslfAM IharUciilars Practically overrule the Mjpreme coarU " tjst lnd cnted br ncs us to tno consideration .""'"'" "'.r. nellovun rnlleee. in Sn?"i.li?rh,HV,nnB,?BrS nf Vhen 'vurs helnS of sectloti n thfi. It seems"to' me wm d "L""0.1.,.",i?.,.,! "n..SVr"0"i.Kv .TV The ofiicers wrt men of tho Are nnd police ceremonies of the elghtee nn nducemont to the passago of tho act. Kovern and control a case of this kind, ni- vh"0o R c 7 One test o bo applied In tho 'IfPartments would prnctlcnlly he without menccmeat week of that tbo act must fall. The supreme court. I though that Is not beforo me at the present Jiri n? thr. Kn ne niioi nn In Dlil or llcli Ine. '1 he provisions of law ' , . ....... ,riVi., i V,.i -m Vh,; t me. but It was somewhat nreued nnd In. olll,lon .of 'PI ?.r?K."'n.K.,.V""v" J tn the nnrk hoard wou d n so bo yesterday afternoon, under was toV "t (at fs.' that "the term of'thJ !-'on here-Insisted that that Provls on , , , lcr ."nX1' , t . voU. Tt mlmltli,! hnt the Judges, under Thomas J. Kelly, vocal pollco magistrate was not an Inducement Si10"1'' BIov"R:,J, ,V, J1v,,',,,.,' ""SiL0" the lcKlslatofa to tho passage of the fur- "eclHlon Tho first port ot the "iPESfM was for the "mayor and Common P.rnL.th.?. .V boKl. """" " voted to the pupils of the that this nart of the opinion relied on by council of the city of Omnha to remove ' u' " a VAt the mere dcslana. Tho provision relating to their appoint- program opening with counsel for defendant in this case .was die- y ",enrvl"' ""'"Xn"?- tlon of the tlmo at which the police Judge ment W 'p uisinct juc ibm. m fne nro- Bthclbert Novn, BUns I"!?' " ZV'A AXWSroaDS created "by ordlnanco of the- clty-and that '?' commence his term or jm.ee am. .ne ""'uej;0V "A0" jjn, o7 Flro and, Pollco The second number, by m like .Is: w"ll''Ln? . .l mltn.ll0'l the power of thn f ,1" n.Vssess cli MEnin- Commissioners. Is void. If buch provision wai ..Tho Swallows." by ''In regard to the appointment of tire and HS.h. ' 'il S'sS' ril hVnennS; cKnce or importance that the determination n the at er case : were me nu ueemen . or StutBmnn c.0'nE,"?2onS 1 "?.""; n.W.nes..l.0.r to direct the manner I 1 which a thine mnv of tho exact time or tno inception 01 ino - tVn , 1. would I "Su-eethenrt bv Frank I, I I VI i 111 VII Mil Will UUVU V . ' t I ov. I'U u I . . . II.. l. ,1 r. I ... . . enmhlned. have, onornted as an inducement eounuy so 111 inc. . - !: I I a Star." by cnaries H. passago by the legislature of this or for n'ark half closed with Ilcgina taining, ns u niu, wiun wiui 111- i " .iT... .-.1 .A..i,,i t.ti .u. .. .. .1 ..ti.. .. . v. ... M 1 ii-Kuiiv 11 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1. . 1 1 1 1 1 in., nunc i 1 1 1 . ii... 1 r 1 11 1 t 1 1. in lviiaui .110 bo of tho same polltlcnl faith or allegiance. be done, but not to do tho thine; itself. and further,, la this connection, In Section " 't 1 inl, rTinn for the 16S. as follows: 'No person shall be ap- Pf"' ,ho tcmlorary Injunction should bo 'o. pom.eu a pouco coinniissioiier wno is en- con i innnnn inr 11 rinniiii,t' n ill cikiiu ileum - .-- . ...... i - gaged in tno snio ot malt, spirituous or ,, . . plan for the organization nnd government '.L'f .",,','', i;k , TL W M's Slarv tc". yinoup liquors, or wno is engaged In the " ' ' of a class of cities; and. further, it seems : v Tno second nart of tha program presented uuHiiicss oi iieaiing in tooncco or articles c ear thnt naa tne legislators Known unit ",";"" !" "J i.;,T,i ,, vi ,, ,, manufactured therefrom, or who Is an Jndsr Kstelle' nnlnlnn C.Ivpb Rx- either the time of tho commencement of clnls or employes would not exist. representative songs, sung by Mr. Kelly, agent for any lire Insurnnce company or Members a Chnnre to Speculate. the term stated In the lnw, or tho exact I . ,,, mii-v nmiTrrTinY Including an aria from tho oratorio, 'Sam ?"!!!n"J"!. P""np" ff?"01" Counsel for some of the ox-morabers of 'cKi "? term as nxed. must no no son," -Du bis wle elne .Dlumo," nuben- ."'I""'LB. '"".'"."""''h"' ' !,- "Unci, lliev wui m liu ,m... ...v -"';;""'";,' . , . .... ...l ..r.lnV tn Mn nnlw Willi T,ln snnn irivu. uurn imikikiu hi nny ot sucn !". uoiiuiituui um iiihk to wiinnnia nnnrovni irom ine inner iuiu iniimvii inii,i Force la l'reven. .'ire """'i ' ...... callings or huslnoss within one year provl- to tako stock and figure out their where- more Important parts of the net. Tho In- chief from Assnultlnn Men. Eyes," a chansonctto, "Dltes-mol," by VOCAL RECITAL AT BELLEVUE riensliiK Feature of Cercnianle Con nected with Annunl Com meneenient. Tho recital of tho vocal department of connection with the nth annual com- Institution, was tho dlreotlon of Instructor. program was de- departtnent, tho "Tho rtosary" ot by Mls3 Flngade. Miss Kalletrom, Frederick Cowen. double number, iynes, and "Were Hawlcy. The first Id do Koven's "My Heather niooms," sung sJi'a.fbo'-'r.uTlined1 refiY'thofflco olTo- Zt" th "CW ddSln by JudRe XnSPoV goverSSS Tn' W natuVeV'wn Chief Redoll's salary has been reduced Nevln. and an Irish folk-song, "Over lice commissioner while ho holds any Estelle. There nre no less than three sots viewed In the light of tho purpose of tho from J3.00O to $2,000 a year and the chief Here." Mrs. Kelly sang three songs: county, city or school district office.' " He of men who have boon removed at various law iih an entirety. Another test to be np. , I)olice w beon instructed to protect "Dear, When I Oazo Into Thine Eyes," Hays: "It Is claimed that th s last Is class ,,, K . . , .,i cd hero Is, May tho constitutional and OI l'ollce unB oc"" ' , at.nm.. ar,H .,, ' wi.iniiMn -nn,i nn. n.rmu.ihia ..n.ir n,,r times by the flro and police commission ! .i.i!. nni ,,nriinn. nf tim inw 1 thn men of thn Are doDnrtmont from as- Bendemeer's "Stream and I Know a constitution. A question which might arise and either have now or havo had casos In separated, nnd Is tho former so completo Bnult by Rcdcll at flros, cnglno houses and Place Where the Sun ls Llko Oold." Tho In regard to tho political qualification was the courts for reinstatement and hack nay. within Itself and Independent of tho latter othr nIaca program closed with the singing of Francis rnnsldereil in Stntn mrnlnst Senvnv. 12 Nah.. . . ihni ih. fnrmnr will he onerntlve nnd enn oiner places. f'"'1""1 " . ... 451: State against Smith, S5 Neb., 13: Steto A" or tnem Daso their actions upon tho cforced without tho latter? If so. the At a special meeting of tho Board of Flro Allltion's "Song of TnanKsglving. by Mr. ngainst ucnus. supra nna determined, nna allegation mat tno Donrn not only did not former will he upnoia anu .no inner cnsro- nnd i0iico CommlsslonorB last nlcht. with Kelly. h7ro' In Veganl to'Tho Mrtl rol?MMN ,mu"?.. remove them, but that ftYKTnnou ncel and enforced by thTs cou7t! Mnyor Moores presiding, and all of the 16S which wo kavo quoted, speaking of It 11 vaH proninitea trom doing so by one (See State v. Hardy, 7 Neb., 377: State v. members present, the following resolution r.' ArtHMni . a. ...... . i .. i ti m l At ... 1. 1 in a . . i- I I n o;o,.n... 1 11B tK opposed to tho true genius and spirit of the M" neo.areti io uo or no force and eifoct. Vo v- Van Duyn, 21 Neb.. 5fiC; Maldoon v.' nnd unanimously adopted rf.nillillenn tirlnelnlMn ,if nut. r-..,.Arnm... I junil U. 1 Ciser nns n SOIL nnnflinc in ne. I a A..l o-. X7nl. ir.T. MnaRAnorr V Sfnte i. I .... .. .1 i ..in.. both state and national: but we need not half of eleven former firemen and about Nob.', 67t: Mngneau v. City of Fremont. 30 t)onB llnv bccn ,ne(1 wtlh the rjnnrd of Uplrlts. 11 iNMo y i uiuw in-uicr n is vicious nnu twentv member nf thn noil hn Ken.. ti "" . v. own,,, w ..... pir0 nnd Police Commissioners of the City wun New City Ticket Office, 1324 Farnam. Tel. 316 Union Station 10th and Marcy, Tel. 629. Nothing equal to Prickly Ash nitters for Introduced by Commissioner Kennedy removing bat sluggish b llous feeling so tn...i ..i.,n. common In hot weather. It creates strength, vigor, appetite and cuoerful uiKUuaa nr uvviuv wiieuier It IS VICIOUS ana .wnntv memham nf Ihn nnii.. hence unconstitutional, for It so It would lwc,uy members or tho pollco force not artcct tne. oue onrorcement of the other wcro romoveo nnout a year ana a portions of the law, or of- tho parts of It In ago by tho fire nnd pollco commission ,,e en V.v" thn' ,.n h,:" r the ground, as alleged, that thcro question does not enter Into the decision I funds with which to pay them or mo uiumaie issue nerein. hnsod h i suit unon thn nlleirntlnn Interiiret .IiiiIkc llnrrlNon. were, In fact, removed for polltl . .. ouiKrr .-iiiiiiuiHuiiiiuit, v.iiui'.uj.. ..uiT.iiin, nr omnha chnrclne unier iiedel nalt so Neb.. (VSo; state v. sioore, .Neb., h.o.) brutal, tyrannlcnl nnd overbearing i upon It hna been further sti ei 1 as n rulo on this towftrd the olllcers and men of tho ...... . SUIIjeci: 111" i:illiniivuiiwiitn nn.l iHimnie nnrtnicnt nf an Id cltV. ntld that ' were not tutlonn, provisions may even bo contained S h XL used obscene nuuslv . reiser I in tho snmo section and yet no distinct nml .,.i .i,.,.,i innv,M conduct lire de- wlthout o. nro. toward said that they separable. that the llrst may stand, ofllcors and men nnd has also uted porsonnl leal ron- though tho ast foil. The point Is not vln,pnce pon anii toward them, whereby icai ron- w),ether thev arr ' ES"ta'nc,J 'jlJl"1," they have been humiliated and Injured In In that cose Judge llarrlsun slmnlv said sons and that other men were snnnlntort In .netinn. fnr the distribution into sections ls ...ii.. "7"'..' t.V. . .i that tho provlslonH.pf.lGS which specify or tholr nlaces. In order tn .ee.irn hir -n. purely nrtttlclal: but whether they are e. S r"nf '. n I t , i mt undergone tho ordeal W l. ho relied nnnn the ,!. J personal, ttbuie and violence on Examining boald and has think to the passKge of the net He savs nf thn ohsrter wh.eh nh.h.tn,, Vn;:;,. WA . it. Am A 1 En 'urm: .!l"Uvl iWLl.a lo Practice at tho Nebraska of1 iheotlurnoKon r'of 'ufo '""nut ,or Polltlcal reQsons this is one of State v. Hardy. 7 Neb.. 3S0.) capacitated lo do effocTivo nnd ! efficient cessful aspirants are John O this ouestloti thnt Is hefnr.. me nn! Ihn sections which Judco Estello's rtenUInn Lpliolil Ilimril' Contention. - work nt lire i occurring in said city, and Wilson. C. J. Backus. M. P. namely, whether, the appointment by tho declared to hnve been annulled hv thn ,. Not only Is the general principle cqn- '"""".. ' i1,.."'. .V,7ci.''Tu. ''""U Q. W governor was an Inducement to the pnssngc I ,.. ,iii . u , , tended for by counse for defendants de- ? , I'v iT, ,nnVin .1,'ninhTn. v nf tim mu u-.ia n.n hnfnm tiwii.n liArriMn?., prcmo court s (loclsloii. It takes tho wind i..i.;.i , u,.. .,,,0.. nnri i .im to IsBtio nn order of Injunction restraining J It wns not lioforo tho sunremo court in out of the sails of Yelser's clients. As fnr n stuht ense. hut tho'ldentienl nrovlslons in- nml enjoining this .board from hearing or city, !L'2.CV -8' r!n?t Stuht. and. so ,ho firemen nro concerned this c.-i,n. volved In this action were considered by SSSM ? uT'n rcmov,n or k iui us j niu itniu m icarn irom an inves.i- , . , . , . ; ,, . .. tho supremo court ann tno question nere i -,;(., " . .i.in Ji.i i... iv,... gat Ion of the reports of the Stuht case nnd been tried beforo Judgo Estelle' and the involved settled, Whereas, A petition signed by eighty- i.n nn.n i ., '. i. rrM i. r...... .',;..'... i . In j....... . . . . 1 1 4 .4 - t.... one members of tho flro denartment hns DANIELS COME TO JUDGMENT Omnha I.nw .Student Aeinilt Them selves llonoi-iihly ami Aro Adinltted In tho Ilur. A class of sU Omaha law studonts has beforo tho State been authortrcd bar. The suc- . Kuhn, 0. C. Goodrich, II. ernlmont and 0. E. Johneon. Tho oung lawyers will open offices In this whero they have already become nown In serving tholr apprenticeship. .. . ... 'i"i,ii " iircnieii were iieieateu, i eiser is perreci- rno iouowihk " nmii juukh jiurn- h. - .....v ,:.iih ihn untri hnnrH nirin Yni wnrst tlmo It has been, up for adjudlca- ,ng an appcal to tho suprcrao rou?t. The yon'- oplnton jthe Stu ht case: "n regard "re'ntoVM1 ,r'M8,ciebf0,fS ttStt'Jll 1 have given till, more lhan usual atten- case Involving tho rights of the cx-pollco- mlsVioners tlie law provides for four not n'l-'SI e1'?. li'TJf.?,?,,1 ,wi,ei, il.'Vl "lii'.'.V tlon and 1 have been aided and assisted by men has not yet been tried Norvolvery pPopori ? li ' S "oZ case" X t TherB are two "ther bunches of ex-pollce for df- icn Sore than two of whom shall be of the ' n.n Znn .LiH ' snmo polltlcnl faith or allegiance; and. "m?n ttln, L,,"mcors n"d men of salu ac- rnrtner. in tms connection, in sontinn nil. i - -., ... .. ... ivher.ina ii ii nn iiuiviinuivii mat one part of an act 'r" "u -urumcn wno nave nrougni ns follows: "No person snail be appointed vj: ",',J '"' ,', '" "' ,, rAnoVii V,n T,. o'fVhTaWoWS suit, in court protesting against being re- n. police comml,, oner who Is engaged .., fftAVCSVctt an Inducenfont to"; thess of 'th. ac" from service the respective de- orlot'enlagerin the bu.lne.J SLViSTSer lSeXed0hnvtfhB8ft1lunreh,1 then the whole act mint fnii Thnt hn,- Dartments. In one of them, which nn ihn n. .i..niino in inhnxpn nr nriinina mnnufnn. until said order is reersoa ny tne supremo m nvnp 1 H i tint thlnlr lu Mk.ii i. . I - ...... .... I . . i liower of the court to nvestiKut ant rtP. fc . ine mcnro nnv ,irt insurance com nan v or tnmnnnleM. ..Whereas, Until such reversal s obtained ... v. . u .. .... -r. :.- -w. i mnv.n wah reinninien nnn hnv u'nm cvi.mn - . iciiiiui., nMiiii-i nn in unconstitutional. n.'v. or interested tr.erein, Ifimn?'.ib0 (,0,")r,n,.lC1 t'V something out- Judgment for back pay during the time they soliciting fire Insurance sldo of the act Itself In my Judgment, and nm supported In that and led to believe were out of the service It hns been sug- tured therefrom, or who Is an agent for I ivh-Jl." e or who shiln havo Pment nre entitled to protection against ,i, or who snnii nao i , .. . . .-,, nn, ini,,.,, h." coin been eng business T " r of such' ca i ngs or l!!,l,h,erefno8rSe,U,,eS It""1 within one year previous to the ''n. " ,.'5 ItnnrH nf v mnnlntment. Nn nersnn h.-ill hn nesolved. by the Iloard Of ! Injury by said Ire nnd Police ihni hv nn invniiun!tnV n r.7...r.. Y eested that under the decision of .Inrto-n i'TI" ..!..". . ' ilL . . nn..V;;nHn?.hV..""'"..0n ... .u. i.",... . " " (la. ."'1"'."fV i.Vi ,riru". . " CommlHtnnf nf the CltV of nm.hn Thn finiiiinen in iiiiin ine iniicn ni nnnen mm. i . r atatutory construction, hy an Investigation of Ulshon on statutorv crime m.,i ..nrin,,. cases an.d also by Cooley on constitution limitations'. Cooley. on constitutional limitations says "It must,, be obvious; In any case where part of nn act Is sot aside ns unconstitutional that tt Is unsafe to Indulge In the same ex treme presumptions In tne support of the remainder that are allowable In support of n complete act when some cause of Inva lidity s suggested to the whole of it." That ls, applied to this case, it having been determined that that lrovlson which says thnt the gov ernor shall appoint Is unconstitutional wo shall not Indulge in tho same pre sumptions to sustain this act thnt we would otherwise If the act were before us for the first time. "In the latter case we know the legislature designed tin whole net to have effect, nnd we should sustain it, If possible; In the former we do not know that the legislature' would havo been willing that a part of the act should be BHUtalned If the rtmnlliilr were held vnlH. nnd there Is generally a presumption more or less Btrong to tho contrary." I take It by that that lie means that tho legislature i'unvu uu wnoie ac, pending ana cx Gstollo nil of the men who havo been re moved from service In tho two depnrt- " ...i.. i.. i.-,.,.. i ino onicers nnn memners oi ine lire iienari. miHMiuiier wiuit- in; iiiimih nils uuuniv. u iy . . .. . . nr Mnhnnl district nmee." It In elnlmed thnt I mcni or tun my in ymniin, so rnr as ments will be trying to break m again, this Inst is class legislation and not per- ,h,u'efrtn,Y" I,,' in', ,,,in fB ,yn ?rn"5"Aci mlsslble under our constitution. A ques- "' ""ll,"nrtc" ?vlf T.iSnS in ."h-r,lrh IC'K.MEX COXUUMX CIIIKK HEIKI.I.. tlon which might arise In regard to the ., "'SneMv from flr n,ithf "n?.: political nuallflcat on was considered In J0 "?f J'rnPlnS,n. JTr Yhl Lln..,h'i . . . .. , ... tiiritn nuniiiMt Seavov Neh 4M atntn caro "n'l management of the property of Adopt He.olulliin DennnneliiK III . "..."RL B Neb "3- Bt'nte ncalnst saM department. Cimdiict nml Hnilnrslnix llonrd. B"!"". Aeji-',L3'Jbtte against The chief of nollce ls herebv renulred tn CURES PRAINS 'Si At a meeting of the Ice Deliverers and noT becnTsked 'torerexa'm.n'e Uhere. In SoiWoSOThS Wagon Drivers' union, held at their hall. OTvJ0huh- Iffes'n'nVnt'tt Sixteenth and Cuming streets, last night Z "K" S "egainsen.e?ni"?.1 "ffi,"1?,',"!1.111.1,", f.BV .'"ih"''0" ino nre aepartment matter came up tor sonally I should condemn It as opposed to nl.niveii Si mnv if ih... ., some dlscu.slon. Ilefore tho meeting wa, XcffifesoouWVnn. HoVVhiwr.hVrt ended a resolution was adopted condemn- n1CnatlonSl- bit we need not dliSu.s o? ho8r1 ' e,ch member of the fire depart- lg Fire Chief Hedell for his alleged brutal decldewhe'ther ftS?vl?lou. and 1 SSS'un $ n'' n" 'V'L11 treatment nf ih Mm-n ,,n, hi. ,nm. constitutional, for If so It would not affect ?Pi.. tPcF.ef ji"...'!0?! 1,1 eneh the engine unupcs oi 1111: cuy. CSSOJIVESV Don't UWe the wetV, wiUrr ittl pr'PMU"" reprcienica to oi tlw ium u" I'oBU's wxirci. inejr ontn conUla "wnoa siennoi" which irriwio. um ikln ukfn lntrnllr. Ii rteafllr pnlion. talni-d nnlr m ealed Luiti eucloicd la bun Wfi)pr. 'vu?iiwj:iaiji . . ... umv. ... I the due enforcement of the nther nnrtlnnn m ii c3"cnalD6r vote ot-tnanks to t)ie (aWi or of the purts of u , 'relation Cms Pinvn III Snlury. .iiiiurra 01111 iuD uouru nt rire nnu iu nro nnu jinnee coiniiiiEKioners, conse-1 After ih .:in .hi. ,.a-iu ,, Pollen "nn,i..lnn. i...,..i ..... iiiient y the determination of such nnestlon Alter tfie "doptlon of this resolution it hnif nf .h .ih. k. " " does not enter Into the decision of the wfla suggesttd that as the salfary of the " !.,.?.e. ',Bh,Jr,.l.hree "reraen b. LB.ne.d ultimate Issue herein," n chief ot police Is only 9S.040. the compensa- w.n. . -I , . . V ' . I",c", Hr.OoTrriiinriit. tlon of the chief of the fire department dtn" o V union " i .Sihe ros'oluUon" ln '""'""nB, t"" of reaucert to a similar nure. Com iitnt ot ion union, signed the resolution, government In accordance With the eon- mlssloner Heafey prepared the following F. KAY'S RENOVATOR Invigorates and renovates the tyhtem; purines sud enriches tba blood; cures thu worst djipepsla, constipation, headache, liver and kidneys. 2&oandll,utdruggUtk Free R advice, sample and book. Dr. 11. J. Kay, Saratoga, N.Y. ENOVATOH mm.. m -.;-o?a.iv w as m I (a 65 JJk The Pan-American Exposition at Buffalo affords an excel lent opportunity to visit the East. Niagara Falls, The Thou sand Islands, the Adiron dack, and many other charming resorts nre within short distances from Buffalo and can be ensily reached by lake or rail. Low rates to Buffalo, via the Burlington Route, nre now in effect. Ask about them. .raws TICKET OFFICE. BURLINGTON'' STATION. 1502 Farnam St. 10th and Maion Sts. Telephone 250. Telephone 128. Its Reputation is Built on a Firm Foundation The Bee Building Tho Bee Buildtae Fireproof Architectural Construction. Beauty. Absolute Perfect No Dark ) Cleanliness. Ventilation. Offices. All Nlcht 24 Hours Satisfactory Perfect Elevators. Electric Light. Janitor Service. Heating Service. f , REASONABLE COURTEOUS THE BEST RENTS. SERVICE. OFFICE NEIGHBORHOOD. "Omaha's Best Office Building" R. C. Peters & Co., Rental Audita. GROUND FLOUR, BEE UUILDINO. ffl