the ALLIANCE HERALD LLOYD O. THOMAS, Business JOHN W. THOMAS, Editor Published every TbursdAy by THE HERALD PUBLISMIMQ COMPANY Incorporated U..I o. Thomas. President Csrl Thomas, Vice Pre., John W. Thomas, Secretary Entered at ths pest office at Alliance, Nebraska, for transmission through tit aalia aa second-ciass matter. .nnontDTinM DDtrin II II PER TEAK IN ADVANCE 0OBM v B kavw, V - - If your copy of Tbs Herald does not reach 70a regularly or satlsfac- nn ahonid nhona 140 or droi a card to tbs emcs. Tns nest or serr lee la what we are tnxous to tire, ao don't bsaltate to notify aa without delay when T eaiaa yonr paper. A CORRECTION By JOHN W. THOMAS, Editor I hare learned to not pay much attention to "roorbacks" false or mis leading statement sprung on a candidate Just before election, too late In tbe campaign for hint and bla friends to reach the voters concerned with a correction before elootlon. However, I bare information regarding a political stunt that has Just keen Dulled oft to misrepresent Lloyd C. Thomas, candidate lor state Kep rosentatlve from tbe TSrd Nebraska district, composed of Box Ilutte aud fwrlJ-a couutiua. Itie "roorback" referred to reverses the positions that have actually been eoeupled by Lloyd and his opponent, Mr. W. It. Harper. I suppose some voters In the two counties will be misled by It, and I do not appose I can reach all of them with a correction before election, but think I ought to let aa many of them aa possible know the facts regarding tbe Is- se Involved. The matter referred to relates to the adoption of tbe proposed prohlbi tion amendment to tbe constitution of Nebraska and the attitude of the two candidates for the legislature from this district. To make the matter clear, and fair to both candidates, and to undeceive voters who may have been misled, we go back to the beginning of the campaign: Last winter, before the primary election for the nomination of candl datea had been held, Archie Gregory, secretary of the Box Butte County Dry Federation, wrote to the candidates for nomination to the legislature from the 73rd representative district and the 28th Senatorial district, re questing that they state their position on the proposed prohibitory amend ment. The replies were open to Inspection of persons who might wish to read them. It was generally understood in Alliance, where both candidates for Representative reside, that Mr. Thomas made a plain declaration In favor of the prohibition amendment, and that Mr. Harper's reply was evasive. How the Roorback" Waa Worked Notwithstanding tbe above facts, there was published In The Alliance Semi-Weekly Times of Friday, Oct 20, a sta'ement that Lloyd C. Thomas had been "wriggling around" on both sides of the "wet" and "dry" ques tion. About the same lime, perhaps on the same day, Mr. Harper wrote me ciergy or tne norm part or Sheridan county, where the prohibition amendment will carry strong, stating that he was for it. Then the state ment in the Times regarding "Lloyd" was clipped and sent to the paprs of that part of the district with the request that It be published. Mr. Harper may tninn mis was nmooth work, opinions differ, r think it was rather coarse. One thing that is hard for me to understand is how men who are honest In ordinary business transactions will use unfair means in politics in order to gain a point over an opponent. letter of Lloyd ('. ThoiiutN Under date of February 28, Thomas replied to Mr. Gregory's inquiry. I wish to call attention to the fact that this reply was made with the under standing that it waa for public Inspection and could be published at any time by any one who cared to have it printed; and that it was written seven weeks before the primary and more than eight months before the election. Here is tbe letter: Alliance, Nebraska, February 28, 1916. Mr. Archie Gregory, Secretary, Box Butte County Dry Federation, Alliance, Nebraska. Dear Mr. Gregory: I am in receipt of your letter of inquiry of the 26th and In reply am pleased to state that I am in favor of the proposed prohib itory amendment and that I expect to vote for the same at the election. I thank you for your kind letter and for the opportunity of expressing myself plainly on thine questions. , Very respectfully, j (Signed) LLOYD C. THOMAS. I W. It. Harper' Reply In a lengthy letter dated February 29, Mr. Harper replied to Mr. Gregory's Inquiry as to how he stood on the prohibition amendment. This letter was also opes to Inspection and has been read by quite a number of persons as well aB copied, but after it was received by Mr. Gregory the writ er of it requested him to not publish It. To this request Mr. Gregory con sented with a promise to not print it without 1Ib (Harper's) consent, altho no promise was made to not leave It open for inspection by any one who wished to see it. After the misleading statements had been sent out from Alliance con cerning Lloyd's attitude on the issue involved, I wished to print the two let ters together, but in view of Mr. Gregory's promise to Mr. Harper, I would not print Harper's loiter without Gregory's consent. He gave his consent on condition that Harper would consent to it. In company with Mr. Greg ory, Dr. Geo. Hand and C. A. Dow, I called on Harper and requested that he give bis consent to having the letter printed. This he flatly refused. I then told him that I had read the letter carefully and that, while in defer ence to Mr. Gregory's promise, I would not publish it in full, I would exer cise my prerogative as a newspaper man and tell some things that It con tained. He requested time to consider the matter further, which was given him. Within a few hours. I waa notified that he gave his consent for the publication of the letter, but before it had been put into type be notified me that he had decided to withdraw his consent. There was much in the letter that waa neither here nor there regard ing the Issue on which he was asked to state his position, but among other things he stated that it would be impossible for him to pledge support to that which was not a law, that he could support and help enforce the laws after they were made, but that was all. 1 could not help smiling when I read that part of the letter, altho I really felt sorry for Mr. Harper when he was crowded into a corner where be had to either "fish or cut bait" or else make himself ridiculous in trying to get out. Mr. Harper should be informed that he waa not nominated for gover nor or sheriff or some other office connected with the executive department of government, but that he has the republican nomination for the LEGIS LATURE and that the official duty of a legislator is not to "help enforce the laws" but to help make them. I submit to any intelligent person that , he ought to go to school, a few days at least, before going to the legislature, and learn what every schoolboy knows before leaving school. He ought to know, too, that Instead of it being improper for a candidate for a legisla tive position to declare his position on proposed leglsaltion that everybody is Interested In, It is eminently proper for him to do so BEFORE ELEC TION. Mr. Harper also stated In the letter that his saying at that time that he would support the amendment would be entirely out of order inasmuch as it had not been made a law. I am Informed that he has recently stated In conversation that the reason he did not declare in favor of the prohibi tion amendment in that letter was because it would hurt his business. Do the people of these two counties want to be represented in the state legis lature by a man who Is so afraid of hurting his business that he will not give a straightforward answer to a fair question? Do they want to be rep resented by a man who has bo little conception of the duties of a legislator as to say that he could help enforce the laws after they were made but that was all? I am of the opinion that a large majority of the voters of Rox Butte and Sheridan counties prefer to be represented in the legislature by a man of more frankness ar.ci better informed regarding the duties of public of ficials. Fair Flay for All la making the above statement. I have earnestly endeavored to be per fectly fair with all parties concerned. After the election la over, whether Mr. Harper is elected or not, he will be my neighbor, and I shall then be able to look him In the face as I can. now and say, "You know I gave you a hqunre deal." After he had tried nil summer to get "wet" democrats of Alliance and Rex Ruble county to bolt the democratic nominee and vote for him. then for him to try to line up the "dry" voters by Bonding out mislead ing Haumonts regarding his opponent within less th in three weeks of time for election, is not right and it is only fair to the people as well as both of the candidates that a correction be made as far as it is possible for me to make it before the votes have been cast. When I asked Mr. Harper for his consent to publish his letter he of fered to write another and give it to me for publication, but that was so un fair that I would not consent to it. To publish the letter or his opponent written at the opening or the campaign mora than t ight months before elec tion, then permit Mr. Harper to conceal the contents of his letter written about the same time but write another Just before election and publish it is not only unfair to his opponent but also to the voters who have a right to an honest expression of their attitude towards rroposed legislation that the next legislature will have to deal wltb. I asked Mr. Harper whether be bad changed his attitude on the prohi bition question since writing the letter to Mr. Gregory last February. He said that he bad not. That being the case, be has no right to try to Influ ence one class or voters by the fact that he refused to state bla position In mat letter, ana men try to influence another class of voters by writing an other letter now. And I do not believe that a majority of the voters of Sheridan and Box Butte counties want to be represented In the legislature oy mat aina or aoubie-deaimg. RESUME OF DEMOCRATIC CANDIDATES 1 urnunni ui promise previously maae in mese columns, we give a statement concerning democratic candidates for state and county offices at tbe election to be held next Tuesday. The object Is not so much to tell voters more regarding those prominent candidates about whom all are posted, as It is to give helpful Information concerning tbe candidates that have not been so much In the limelight during the campaign. At every election there are many voters who know nothing as to the quauncation or some candidates for or against whom they vote. We can render a better aervlce by giving needed information than by rehashing matter that all are already familiar with. At the bead of the state ticket Is elth Neville, nominee for eovernor. So much has been published regarding the attitude of gubernatorial candi dates on statewide prohibition that other qualifications have been over looked to a great extent. Mr. Neville Is a business man, Interested in ranching and farming. His word Is as good as his bond. This Is the repu tation he bas among bla acquaintances, republicans and democrats, "wet" and "dry". In North Platte and Lincoln county where he baa spent practic ally his entire lifetime. While not a politician In the common acceptation of the term, be Is a successful business man and competent to continue the "business administration" of the present governor. Lieutenant Governor Edgar Howard Is editor of tbe Columbus Telegram, one of the leading weekly newspapers of the state. In the early days of southwestern Ne braska, be was engaged in the newspaper business in that part of the state. He bas been more of a politician than the democratic candidate for gover nor, that is, bas participated In politics more, but has always boen classed as "progressive". He is one of W. J. Bryan's strongest supoprters. Two years ago he Btrongly supported the adoption of woman suffrage and at tracted statewide attention by his able advocacy of the measure. He fav ors the adoption of the prohibition amendment to the constitution and of adequate laws for Its enforcement. With both candidates for governor pledged to the enforcement of prohibition, If adopted, and as the lieutenant governor is ex-offlclo president of the upper house of the state legislature, there la a possibility of a contingency arising under which his attitude may bave a vital bearing upon the issue. Secretary of State Honesty, efficiency and fairness, these are the things that are needed in the office of secretary of state, and these are the things that Charles W. Pool, present incumbent, bas brought to the office. He Is an old-time news paper man, and within the last few years has become a homesteader In Grant county. It is commonly conceded that a state officer who serves one term well should be honored with a second term. We do not know what more the people of the state could want In the office of secretary of state than they have been given by Charley Pool and his efficient nHiutnnt 11 a ought to have another term. Auditor of Public Accounts This Is an office to which the maloritv of nonnia o-i itftin itaniinn but it is one of the most ImDortant in its relation in th Hnnnrm r iiu uitl and the honest expenditure of Its funds. Wm. H. Smith of Seward, anoth er newspaper man, has given careful attention to th nrilnmm Hntisa nt hia office and has made a record of efficiency in all the details of his work that enuues mm 10 a second term. State Treasurer Some months ago there was aulte a "temnest In a tpnnnt" In tha otato capltol building down at Lincoln, caused by friction between George E. Hall, state treasurer, and some employees of other departments, caused by differences of opinion on some legal questions arising in the administration of his office. We never gave the matter sufficient attention to imriArstnn,! clearly and fully Just what the differences were, but all the while we had ine impression tnat Mr. Hall was honest in his convictions and that the dif ferences were due largely to the rapid race at which he trteil to inHtnt some radical reforms In the conduct of the office, lie that as it may. it Is noteworthy that those who disagreed with him then in the matters at issue are now supporting him for re-election. State. SiiHriiiteiHleiit of Public Instruction Prof. W. H. Clenunons has not been before the nubile .ve ifi a nniitin. al way, as much as some other schoolmen of Nebraska, but he is one of the leauing euueators or tue state and without doubt one of the best qualified. His experience in normal school work especially fits him for the nffi of state superintendent of public instruction. Attorney General Willis E. Reed, the present incumbent, is a man who hniiovoa in iinine things. His aggressiveness dining his first, term of office has made him sonio enemies, but it is a question now whether that will not help him more than injure him in his candidacy for re-election. He has the reputation of being a mau of his word and of strict busluess integrity. He nromlnnn to continue to faithfully enforce the laws that are now on the statute books of the state or that may be put on while he holds the office of at al. ('onunl.HNloner of Public Laud and Buildings If the voters of western Nebraska, regardless of nartv. wish to linn thin end of the state recognlxed by tbe election to this office of a man well qual- meu 10 uu 11 acceptaDiy. tney nave tne opportunity to assist in the good work by casting their ballots for G. L. Shumway of Scottabluff. He has a hard row to hoe" from the fact that he resides In the extreme western part of the Btate, while his opponent is an eastern Nebraska man. We wish to warn readers of The Herald against making a mistake In marking their ballot, aa there are two Shumways on the ticket, tbe first Is H. P. Shumway, republican candidate for lieutenant governor, running against Edgar How ard; the other la O. L. Shumway, the democratic and DeoDle's indenenrlent nominee for commissioner of public lands and buildings. llallway t ommlssioner Victor B. Wilson is the nominee of more political parties than anv oth er man on the election ballot, being the democratic, people's independent and socialist candidate for railway commissioner. Aa their nominee for a state office he Is an honor to the parties that have honored him. They could not have selcted a more competent man for the verv Imnortnnt nfliM f railway commissioner or one more worthy of the office. He Is a man of affairs. He bas the education of a lawyer and training In the school of ex perience of a successful business man. He Is radically for the rights of the common people, but no one need fear that be will conselnt to the needles crippling of railroads and public enterprises in order to gain public ap plause. Mr. Wilson is a brother-in-law of A, G. Brice of Alliance and bas visited in this city a number of times. The Herald sincerely hopes to see Alliance and Box Butte county pay him the well-deserved compliment of a rousing majority. Regents of State University The board of regents of the Nebraska State University have an Imnort. ant work to perform In managing the affairs of that great institution, and men 01 acuity are neeaea. two regents are to be elected this fall. The democrats have two able men in their two candidates. Dr. P. L. Hall and U. D. Landis. CoiigreHuian, 6th DUtriet We admit that the candidate who runs acatr,st Mohoh ! KlnkniH in tha "Big Sixth" is up against a hard proposition, one of the difficulties of the cituatton being the Immense siie of the district making a thoro canvass by new uiaa iiupoBsioie. lo. u. Aicuermott is earnest and talented young man of progressive principles and with an al U.ty that will, no doubt, put him to the front iu this part of the west iu the years to come. State Senator George hi. Adams of Crawford Is well 1 n..v .1 to the voters In the rnnn. ties of Sioux, Dawes, Box Butte. Sheridan, ':. :ry and Brown, comprising the 28th senatorial district, having boen a la.-.Jldate before for the same office, besides having served some yearB ag a.-; representative in the lower nouse or tne legislature. He is popular in homo county, which he car ried by an overwhelming majority two years r.ro and will no dnnht rrn again this year. State Representative Indications point to the election of Llovd (.: Thomas from the 73rd district, composed of Box Rut t ml Sheridan counties He Has made a fair and square campaign w hich .i.s to be utmrecintnrl hv vot ers generally in the two counties. Rox Ilutte County 'i n 'l Usually a pood share of the doi.iocr.ilic Rox Butte county are elected, even when !lu ioual and state candidates. This year wif. President Wilson, it Is probable (but a gf.o'.U dates for county office will be elected. Only a brief mention can be made h te: Jn ty ticket as candidate for county clerk, lie 1.5 the son of a well-known Rox uutte county rarmer, is well qualitied for the office aud popular umong his acquaintances. Fred Mollrlng has served before aa cou.ity treasurer for which office he id a candidate. When in office before he was faithful obliging honest and efficient, a guarantee of what he will be a?al:i if elected. We feel that we ought to say a little more concerning the office of county superintendent. We have for a long time taken the position that the Buperlntendeucy of public education us well as judicial positions ouuht to be nonpartisan. As we have ;ot yet secured the no. partisan nomination or county superintendents in Nbraka. it is still necessary to make party nominations. However, voters can overlook purty name and vote on the merits of the candidates and aa the circumstances indicate is best for the cause or education. Miss Opal Russell Is liulshing her first term as county superintendent. We have never heard an intimation that her work has not been cllicient and satisfactory to school 1 itiot's, teachers and school dietrict officers. Under these circumstances we believe it would be a serious niis take to .r.ake a change, in the oihee. no. It will be die compliment and one that is merited if republicans and democrats will unite their votes aud give Mi?s Russell the endorsement that he deserves, a big majority. Sheriff Cal Cox doesn't need anything said about him to help in his cam paign for re-eleciion. He is known to almoM every voter in tbe county, his fllllllllllllllllllMIIIIIIIIIIMIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIHIMltlTMIIIIIIIIIMIIIIItirrHinflRtm Nebraska State Volunteer Fire men's Association President, J. P. Hoffman, Ord. First Vice President, Harry Hanser, Fremont Second Vice President, John W. Guthrie, Alliance. Secretary, E. A. Miller, Kearney. Treasurer, II. A. Webbert. Kearney. Board of Control: Jacob Ooehring, Seward, chairman; William & Mote, Cbadron; F. B. Tobla, Sidney; O. A. Rboadea, Saottabluff) Bert J. Galley, Columbus. A department devoted to tbe Interest! of tbe Volunteer Firemen of tbe state of Nebraska. Edited by Lloyd C. Tbomaa, state publicity chairman. iinnHiimmnHHnniinin ninmi Mmm North Platte, Nebr., Oct. 20, 1916. 'ttes i.ts tea for county offices in ' ty goes republican on nat ' county going strong for :.n.b;r of democratic candi- J. Maniou heads the couu- We, the members of the North Platte Fire Department, fellow towns men of Keith Neville, candidate for governor of Nebraska, wish to pay trib ute: AS CITIZENS, to Mr. Neville's wise conservatisms, absolute integrity and business acumen, we owe much; AS MEMBERS OF THE FIRE DEPARTMENT, unitedly we give bias the full measure of our confidence, earned by unswerving fidelity and devo tion to our Interests. Our First Mascot no parade was complete without lltUe Keith Ne ville, in bis fireman's uniform, fastened securely to tbe seat of honor on one of tbe host carts. In after years, before the advent of the auto fire truck, hi touring nv (the largest and finest in the city), responding to the first note of alarm, was always in readiness to transport men and carts to tbe fire, thereby con serving our time and strength. AS NEIGHBORS, we testify to bis Ideal borne life, his simple charac ter unspoiled by great wealth, bis many charities tendered nnohntrnlTft- and with finest courtesy. Born and reared In our midst we bave bad am ple opportunity to observe his development from the eager, inquiring youth to tbe level-headed man of affairs. We earnestly ask you to support him at tbe polls, believing aa we do that it 1b a privilege to elect to office a man of such exceptional character G. R. TIGHE. J. R. BASKINS, P. H. SULLIVAN. Committee. election by a good majority waa a foregone conclusion early In tbe paign, ana now since tne absurd attack waa made upon bla official record fen a vain enort to dereat him, his majority will probably be Increased by a hundred or perbapa two or three hundred. Joe L. Westover, son of District Judge Wm. H. Westover, ie well read in the law. He haa the talent and the experience necessary to fill the ofllee of county attorney acceptably if elected. As railroad man, farmer and ranchman, P. H. Dillon has had observa tion and experience that will be helpful to him in discharging the duties f county assessor if elected. He has a large circle of acquaintances in tbe county and looks like a strong candidate. We haven't paid much attention to the "mud slinging" that a few par sons have done as usual. Often that kind of tactics helps the candidate against whom used. It ought to be bo in the case of Anton Uhrig of llen lngrord. candidate for county commissioner. He is an Industrious, bard working, honest citizen and has the respect and confidence of his neighbors and acquaintances. A half truth is some times worse than a lie made oat of whole cloth. One of the meanest things about the slander of Mr. Uhrfcx is that the figures used are Juggled in such a way aa to cast a reflection up on the integrity of a man whose absolute honesty Is unquestioned by per sons familiar with the facts referred to. If fair minded voters wlU make K a point to favor the candidates who are unjustly attacked for political pur poses in the closing days of a campaign, it will help to put a stop to the un fair practice. Under the circumstances, voters ought to favor Cal Cox for sheriff and Anton Uhrig for county commissioner, as a rebuke to unfair political methods. Every man who votes for Cal Cox for sheriff ought vote for Anton Uhrig for county commissioner, and every vote for Uhrig ught also to go to I'ox. WANT AD DEPARTMENT FOR RENT FOR RENT Two furnished rooms. 321 Big Horn. Phone Wal-1 nut 8092. 44-2t-7676 ROOMS FOR RENT 132 Chey enne Avenue, Alliance, Nebraska. 44-tf-7682 WANTED CilKL WANTED Inquire at AIM- anre Steam Laundry. 38-tf-7512 IADY COOK WANTEDTwithout children. For ranch work. Phone 471. 38-tf- FOR SALE FOR SALE Rlack walnuta. hull ed and sacked $1.00 per bushel. Everbearing strawberry plants, $1.00 per hundred. Forest trees, Cotton wood and Willow, right to plant for pasture shade, windbreak, lawn or ornamental hedge, $1.00 per bund- red; $6.00 per thousand. WICKHAM BERRY FARM, 48-lt-7782$ Salem. Nebraska. FOR SALE One good 3V4 wide tire Balne wagon. One carriage In good repair. One set of work har ness. Inquire at 707 Missouri ave. 45-tf-7699 MODERN nine-room house, locat ed In choice residence district in Al liance, for sale at reasonable price Phone 340 or inquire at Herald of fice. 42-tf-7636 TFREE good organs for sale. Practically new. Taken in exchange on pianos. For sale at bargain pric es. Wiker Music House, Alliance, Nebr. 42-tf-7626 FOR SALE One lot, situation, lot 10, block 3, of Hitchcock, Hills and Snedeker's addition to Alliance, Ne braska. To highest bidder for cash. Write Mrs. Delia S. Dainton, Rart lett, Iowa. 48-H-7793 FOR SALE Five-room house, all modern, at 927 Laramie. 48-tf 7794 MISCELLANEOUS MONEY TO LOAjJnRoVBtTT county land nd ranches In the san1 hills. No delay In making the loan we Inspect our lands and furnish tfc money at once. J. C. McCorkle, M Corkle Ruilding. Alliance, Nebr. l-tf-6554 riEconn roit traivhex Railroad men can securs very us ful book at Ths Herald office. It Is 1 aallr tlms book for trainmen and p gtnemen. Ths price Is reasocabls. i-tf-C7I8 MOVE FURNITURE SAFELY We have equipped our dra ocs and auto truck with th late appliances for moving furnlturs without marring or scratching or damage. Up-to-date wagon pads 1 will be used by us on all moving Jobs JOHN R. SNYDER. Phone IS. 37-U-5950 Money to loan on real estate. No unnecessary delay In getting loaja. Apply toll M. Bullock, Room 4, Red dish Blosfe.. Alliance. POSITION WANTED h ottu. enced waitress. Inquire at Herald office or phone 340. 45-lt-7713$ w75ATTIjNlTn and reasonable ratea day or night Phone Red 72. Collier & Moore 48-lt-7777$ The Truth About Csuioer A valuable book giving a moat comprehensive explanation of Coa eer and ita successful treatment wits out the knife will be sent free to anyone Interested. Address O. A. Johnson, M. D., Suite 528, 1320 Main St., Kansas City, Mo. Adv. 1st wk 7780-31 C. T. KNAPTON IS NEW MANAGER AT HADDOIU' It was with great surprise that L. L. Covington, manager of tbe AM anee store of the Haddorff Miuoe House, received the news from the general manager that he had boen promoted and starting tbe first ef the month would bold down the posi tion of assistant general manager mt all the company's retail stores. lie will have offices In Omaha, Here but four months, Mr. Covington hua made for himself a host of friend, has developed tho business at the lo cal store to such an extent that th Alliance store has been able to stand ahead. For the last month the loeal ttore ranked first with over forty ealos, showing what a well-known line of instruments coupled with gen uine salesmanship ability can do. Mr. Covington is succeeded by C. T. Knapton, who comes here from the Oklahoma City store of the com pany. He is a man experienced In all phases of the piano business, Ls a man of phasing personality, a Bails man, and a man whom Alliance de lights to welcome whilo bldling the departing friend godspeed. Mr. Knapton has already assumed hi new duties while Mr. Covington has gone to Omaha to take charge of his oilice. Famous Collins Saddle Rest saddle made. Have stood the test for 50 years. Write for free catalogue. Alfred Cornish & Comp'y KiiocMiMrK to Collins & Morrison. Al I 'J 10 Farnani Ht., OinaIu, Neb.